Gransnet forums

Ask a gran

Theresa May

(324 Posts)
Riverwalk Thu 05-Oct-17 09:43:52

After yesterday's disaster is it over for Mrs May?

maryeliza54 Sat 07-Oct-17 15:14:27

Well there's a pretty good imitation of a rather nasty tight wing swarm going on on this thread now isn't there. For whatever reason you didn't get the glorious leaders resounding conference speech you wanted and are feeling a bit miffed. Get over it, we all know she'll carry on limping on until they can decide on someone fit to replace her and what a choice they've got. The cough has probably bought her a bit more time that's all .

maryeliza54 Sat 07-Oct-17 15:09:41

lemingrass you have clearly lost the plot completely. How did my post go on and on about the bracelet? I mentioned it at the end - and do you honestly think that I'm not fully aware of who FK is ? The depictions on the bracelet are by her and of her. I'm fully aware also of her political views and very critical of her support for Stalin.

whitewave Sat 07-Oct-17 15:08:14

Week end papers buzzing with speculation.

But my guess is that they can’t get rid of her as they would end up with something worse.

Wonder how many letters the 22 club has received so far? I suppose they can get them in dribs and drabs and presumably reach 48 eventually. Then there would have to be a new leader.

lemongrove Sat 07-Oct-17 14:57:56

Just buzzing outside now,?

whitewave Sat 07-Oct-17 14:57:01

lemon you clearly haven’t been paying attention annie is now a Tory supporter.

lemongrove Sat 07-Oct-17 14:55:56

Day6 ?

lemongrove Sat 07-Oct-17 14:54:32

That’s because Anniebach actually cares about the Labour Party, it’s been a huge part of her life and still is, whereas she doesn’t care about the Tories and won’t be voting for them.So, seeing Corbyn and McDonnell doing their Marx Brothers routine, understandably upsets her.

Day6 Sat 07-Oct-17 14:51:05

maryeliza Day6* annie doesn't need you to defend her - she knows very well that she used the word swarm in a nasty negative way recently several times directed at me and those I agreed with.*

I am defending the right to free speech. You want to criticise Annie over her use of the word 'swarm' when I think it's been used inoffensively and appropriately.

You have decided it has negative connotations when it merely means a group which gather and descend...as in a swarm of wasps or bees. Nice friendly bees swarm, don't they?

The politics forum does have groups who collect to back each other, does it not? One group tends to swarm more...(they have built a nest in the forum rafters I think) the minute anything contentious is mentioned, and that will have been noticed by all who read or comment here.

There is another swarm...who tend to buzz around outside most of the time but pop in to make their presence noticed every now and then.

I see nothing offensive whatsoever in referring to a group by using a collective noun. That you try to pull someone up by making the word 'offensive' says a lot about your sensibilities and the way in which you want to shut people up. That's YOUR agenda.

lemongrove Sat 07-Oct-17 14:50:57

Well, your post was so ridiculous, going on about a bit of jewellery, perhaps you didn’t know Khalo was an artist?

maryeliza54 Sat 07-Oct-17 14:49:55

annie seems to be to spend all her time making the same set of comments about JC and JM - I'd love to see some comments from her about Conservative social policies.

maryeliza54 Sat 07-Oct-17 14:47:29

Where did I use the word 'lauding'? I just gave my opinion that I wouldn't wear jewellery with a political connotation. I must have touched a nerve lemongrass to provoke a 'for God's sake' response - talk about OTT.

lemongrove Sat 07-Oct-17 14:46:13

* Anniebach* makes fair comments about Conservatives,
maryeliza as do the others that I mentioned.
Annie is upset, as are other people about the direction that Corbyn and McDonnell is taking the Labour Party in.

lemongrove Sat 07-Oct-17 14:42:18

For God’s sake maryeliza that bracelet was not lauding somebody because they were a Communist, but because she was an artist it was a highly decorative bit of chunky jewellery.
Also, swarm? It’s a perfectly acceptable word, so we can all use it if we like, it only has negative connotations in your own head.

Day6 Sat 07-Oct-17 14:37:37

Tegan2 - especially as a member of a pack that is known to turn on it's wounded in a pretty evil way.

Oh come on!
All is well within the Labour party is it?

We all know Labour politicians who a year ago - just twelve short months ago, who were openly against Corbyn and Momentum.

Momentum is trying to have moderate Labour MPs deselected! There are HUGE divisions within the Labour party.

Now, those Labour MPs who could openly stab Corbyn in the chest last year because he was being harangued by the press and public opinon are having to quietly stab him in the back after his upsurge in popularity following May's ill-timed election. Perhaps they are all self-serving hypocrites? The older I get the more I think that of politicians - of any political persuasion.

Let's not pretend the knives are reserved for May. Corbyn has his enemies on the back benches too.

A week is a long time in politics as someone once said....

maryeliza54 Sat 07-Oct-17 14:36:10

Annie fair with her criticism - I can hardly type for laughing at this comment. What a joke - hells bells.

Baggs Sat 07-Oct-17 14:34:27

Good posts, day6.

annie, did you see this about JRM? Someone shouted right into his face that he should just "Fuck right off and die!" (paraphrased). JRM responded unflappably with: "And if I do will you promise to pray for my immortal soul?" Such cool ?, and people say he's old-fashioned. Not when it comes to repartee he aint.

maryeliza54 Sat 07-Oct-17 14:34:16

* Day6* annie doesn't need you to defend her - she knows very well that she used the word swarm in a nasty negative way recently several times directed at me and those I agreed with. I'm highly amused when the right wing start pontificating about how horrible and mean the centre left are when you read the posts from you, annie and others on this thread. I'm left of centre and have said nothing about TMs clothes or cough. I think the security breach was appalling and I felt sympathy for the cough. I also wish she hadn't coughed so we could have concentrated on what she said. I'm puzzled about the bracelet though - I wouldn't wear jewellery with depictions of someone far right on it. Or far left or any political figure for that matter.

lemongrove Sat 07-Oct-17 14:32:26

She was fine with the speech in Florence, and at other venues btw. She has no trouble with public speaking.

lemongrove Sat 07-Oct-17 14:29:53

I am discounting Iam64 and Anniebach and Anya as well as a few others on GN, Labour supporters who are fair with their criticisms.Criticise the politics and policies by all means, have a chuckle at some outfits that politicians wear, but have a bit of humanity for other things.That goes for what we say about ALL politicians.

Tegan2 Sat 07-Oct-17 14:24:10

She has always tended to sip water during interviews. I feel sorry for her as I would a wounded animal, especially as a member of a pack that is known to turn on it's wounded in a pretty evil way. Then again, she chose to join the pack; wasn't born into it. However, the lapse of security immediately made me think of how she has cut police numbers over the years thereby causing security problems.Also wondered if the security at the conference was arranged by the company her husband has links with?

lemongrove Sat 07-Oct-17 14:23:19

Such rubbish being spouted on here about May ‘not having a cold’ ( are you all psychics?) When you have a sore throat, and I have one right now, I can chat with friends on the phone but after a while the voice starts to crack and I cough.
It’s what happens.
Such rubbish also about the choice of bracelet.?She liked it! So what?
Day6 exactly, some of the left wing sound to have very little kindness in their souls.?

Day6 Sat 07-Oct-17 14:22:22

mostlyharmless, does it MATTER why her voice failed, why her throat dried, why she coughed? It was a genuine few minutes where she really could not speak because of a PHYSICAL problem.

It is awful for any speaker. Been there, done that.

That is why I sympathised. We should be able to leave personalities and policies aside to agree it was awful for her at such a crucial time.

Those who are analysing why she had a cough ought to be ashamed. She is a confident woman and a good public speaker (imo) and would have had no qualms about delivering her speech. The timing of her cold was dreadful.

I thought she dealt with the idiotic "comedian" very calmly and very efficiently, taking his paper and putting it down.

As someone on a radio phone in programme remarked, had he attempted that in America, he'd have left the hall in a body-bag.

May's security was appalling. Did she need that to contend with as well?

She's been badly let down by so many. Call me soft, sentimental, daft, whatever, but I was happy for her that her husband was waiting for her in the wings with a hug. I'd have liked that sort of support too after such a difficult time.

Anniebach Sat 07-Oct-17 14:19:37

I cannot say I want a Tory or labour government , neither give me hope . Corbyn and his devotees aretoo much like .Trump and his devotees, this is frightening.

Iam64 Sat 07-Oct-17 14:05:52

I heard Ken Clarke interviewed after TM's conference speech. He was straightforward and entertaining during the interview, as he usually is. He said he likes TM and described her as a loyal and dedicated politician. I always felt the tories missed a chance in never having Ken as leader.

The key thing is the policies. I've disliked the news coverage which described her speech as disastrous, no comments about the policies just repeated references to letters falling off signs, "pranksters" and her cough.

mostlyharmless Sat 07-Oct-17 14:05:05

Having watched Theresa May's speech live and in full she was speaking clearly at the start - no coughing. Only after the P45 was delivered did she start looking flustered and started coughing. So I think the cough was mainly a nervous reaction. That sequence of events doesn't come across in news reports.
I still feel sorry for her though. How awful for that major speech to be such a disaster! But as a Labour supporter I can't wait to see her go.