Gransnet forums

Ask a gran

Old Wives Tale.....Egg Water and Warts!

(84 Posts)
Kateykrunch Mon 11-Mar-19 11:10:35

I was brought up believing that if you touched the water that eggs had been boiled in then you would get warts, I still avoid the water. But, I watched Jamie Oliver yesterday, he was steaming salmon and in the pan of boiling water he was cooking the green beans, but then, horror or horrors, he put 2 eggs (in their shells) into the same water as the beans!!! Oh my goodness, at worst those eggs have been up a chickens bum! I have to say it was my Mum who told me this, she also told me we lived next door to Cliff Richard and that she played table tennis for England, oh and I am a bit gullible, but really why would you cook the beans in the same water as a germy egg shell?

Saggi Tue 12-Mar-19 10:27:53

The boiling water will kill any germs....I always pop eggs in to boil with my new spuds when doing a salad. Warts from egg water.... really shoulda grown out off all the nonesense by now... walking under ladders ...new shoes on table...open umbrellas in house.... salt over shoulder....crossing on the stairs... honestly! I drive my hubby mad when I do this stuff...his mum was a bit bonkers superstition wise. And his biggest superstition is religion ...thank god im an atheist.

Fennel Tue 12-Mar-19 10:30:23

When we had chickens quite often there would be a smear of faeces or blood on their eggs. I always washed them.

nannyof4 Tue 12-Mar-19 10:30:27

Yes i have boiled eggs with potatoes and veggies why use another pan.

Willow10 Tue 12-Mar-19 10:37:35

We were told as kids that it was handling the eggshells that gave you warts. It made cutting the tops off and eating a boiled egg very difficult!

Annaram1 Tue 12-Mar-19 10:46:59

Besides the point a bit but I am allergic to eggs so never have them.
Just fascinated about the cockerels lack of a mating appendage. How on earth can they impregnate a hen?
Ain't nature wonderful?

notnecessarilywiser Tue 12-Mar-19 10:49:18

Warts were a real threat when I was a child - not only the boiled egg water, but the air from a bicycle pump or touching a road would also do the trick (allegedly). smile

Theoddbird Tue 12-Mar-19 10:56:10

I used to boil eggs with other things ...saved energy and washing up...

sarahcyn Tue 12-Mar-19 10:59:58

boat the weird bent pan used for boiling eggs is still used in my 94 year old mother's house but nobody ever told me what was wrong with using it for anything else apart from the fact it has 75 years of limescale on it (which is sterile anyway and good for your teeth)

MrsAllboys Tue 12-Mar-19 11:03:32

When you’ve finished eating a boiled egg you turn the shell upside down and crack it with the spoon so that witches can’t use it for a boat! (So I was told as a child?)

Molly10 Tue 12-Mar-19 11:04:48

I've never heard the wart story before but personally I would not boil anything in the same water as the eggs.

Years ago I knew a lad who lived only with his dad and they used to boil their eggs for breakfast in the kettle to have with their cup of tea in the morning. Yuk, and they definitely all had mucky bums then.

nannypiano Tue 12-Mar-19 11:19:51

When I had a wart on my hand as a young child I was told to dip my hand in the sea and the wort would disappear. I did and it did the very next day.

annodomini Tue 12-Mar-19 11:27:27

The juice from dandelion stems is supposed to be a sure-fire remedy for warts. I'm waiting for a new crop of dandelions so that I can test this old-wives' tale. Has anyone here tried it?

icanhandthemback Tue 12-Mar-19 11:36:51

thank god im an atheist. grinconfusedgrin

In the UK we don't wash eggs because the last stage of the egg developing process is the 'bloom' which is a liquid that keeps the porous egg shell from taking in bacteria. If you wash that away, you end up with potentially compromised eggs that go rotten quicker. You shouldn't store them in a fridge either.
I don't tend to cook eggs in the same pan as other things but will put them at the bottom of the steaming pan if I want hard boiled eggs to eat later.

LJP1 Tue 12-Mar-19 11:44:25

Warts are usually self limiting, that's why I can cure warts - that's what I told my students and their warts always went away.

Science shows that the bacteria from the gut are killed by boiling water. The pores in chicken's eggs are too small for bacteria to get through, so the yolk and white inside are sterile till the shell is broken. Duck eggs have shells with larger pores so their eggs can be infected.

A bacterium which can infect unsterilised, sealed foods, e.g. tinned meat (so 'blown' tins should not be used) produces a poison which is where the story about the dangers originated. The bacterium is killed by boiling but the botulin poison it produces, botox, is not destroyed and can be deadly. This is the poison used to smooth away wrinkles. Many people bless this bacterium!

Excessive cleanliness prevents us building up immunity to common bacteria when we are young and best able to do so - that's why so many children now have allergies. The old adage about a peck of dirt is apposite.

Grammaretto Tue 12-Mar-19 11:54:46

I now know why we never wash eggs or keep them in the fridge!
My DM kept an egg pan specially. Actually it was a double boiler. Eggs in the lower part and porridge in the top.
I still have the top part. I think the egg water pan was deemed too discoloured to be hygienic. Wish they still made pans like that.
I have a 3 tier steamer but it is lightweight and not the same at all.
As for warts; my DC had their verrucas frozen off. I had a crop on my fingers as a child. There was some black ointment covered by elastoplast. I found it morbidly fascinating to see if they shrunk. They must have because they've gone now.

Gonegirl Tue 12-Mar-19 11:57:59

"cockerels don't have a penis" (from further up/down the thread.

I googled it. So now I don't have to ask the obvious question.

MrsAllboys Tue 12-Mar-19 12:09:49

annodomini That may be true; I know that one of my Aunts when a child had her warts cured by some plant juice her brother used on her hand...apparently he had got the remedy from some local gypsies?. In the old days when we had gypsies! (They used to camp regularly near the farm.)

Boolya Tue 12-Mar-19 12:13:18

As a child I made breakfast in bed for my parents, boiled eggs, soldiers and acupuncture of tea each. It was a first and my mum asked me about using the kettle as she hadn’t heard it whistle - no worries I said, I made the tea with the boiling water from the eggs!

Boolya Tue 12-Mar-19 12:14:22

An acupuncture ? Meant to be a cup of tea......

MissAdventure Tue 12-Mar-19 12:14:42

Chickweed is good for warts. Well, bad for them, I suppose.

Break the stem and there is milky sap, which stings a bit after a while, but it gets rid of them.

Tweedle24 Tue 12-Mar-19 12:19:02

My mother told me that if I ate sugar raw (i.e. cube from the sugar bowl) I would get worms!

ReadyMeals Tue 12-Mar-19 12:26:55

Anja they are not washed and sterilised. Not in the UK anyway. Maybe in America where they chlorinate chicken

sarahellenwhitney Tue 12-Mar-19 12:32:32

Nothing surprises me where Jamie Oliver is concerned.

breeze Tue 12-Mar-19 12:39:42

I watched programme many years ago that was presented by Cheryl Baker. It may have been a kids cookery programme I forget. She said you should always wash your hands after handling egg shells as they are not washed and can carry bacteria. They have a protective membrane which stops the egg from going off so they are not washed before you buy. I would imagine any bacteria would be killed by the boiling water but personally I wouldn't put them in with any veg as sometimes there are little blobs of poop and tiny feathers on them which I wouldn't want in my food.

I've watched Jamie grab handfuls of herbs off of the window cill too. Hasn't he seen fly poops! Those nasty little orange stains you get on the cills in the summer. And flies, which could've been walking over dog poo could've been walking over the herbs. Yuk. If I pick from my garden I soak in a little bit of salt, then rinse before using. And do the same with any bagged salads or herbs that are 'on the date'. As you can get bacteria in those too.

Re warts. Don't believe in getting them from egg water but when my son was very small he had some tiny ones on his torso that wouldn't go. We took him to a specialist at Guys who took one look and produced a wooden cocktail stick from his drawer confused He proceeded to prick (much to small sons' disgust) a few of my sons' warts. Voila, week or so and they had all disappeared. He explained that by breaking the skin my sons' immune system would become aware of the virus and fight it. And it did. Who would've thought.

4allweknow Tue 12-Mar-19 12:44:20

Sodapop Didn't think sun cream existed when I was young 40/50s. Even in 60s very little known about it.