Gransnet forums

Ask a gran

Does Age excuse Everything?

(34 Posts)
EllanVannin Fri 12-Mar-21 17:35:10

Well said Chestnut. I still cried at the film not long ago---"The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas ". Age didn't come into it then !

Emily49 Fri 12-Mar-21 17:22:18

The programme asked how this could happen, that ordinary young men could do such a thing. One imagines they were terrified, as well as brainwashed

Chestnut Fri 12-Mar-21 17:17:55

There was a very complex and interesting programme on PBS America called 'Radical Evil' about the Nazi death squads, who gunned down about 2 million Jews. These were young men ordered to shoot large groups of helpless men, women and children, over and over again. The programme asked how this could happen, that ordinary young men could do such a thing. They committed mass murder but were they responsible when you consider the complexity of the offence? They could not refuse the orders, they were brain washed into believing it was the right thing to do, and the human brain learns how to adapt into acceptance of what is required when it has no choice. Very complex issue.

AGAA4 Fri 12-Mar-21 17:00:52

Those war criminals were monsters and should be brought to justice whenever they are caught and whatever their age.

NellG Fri 12-Mar-21 16:55:11

When it comes to crime age shouldn't be a free pass and people should be held to account whatever their age.

When it comes to attitudes and behaviour age is also not an excuse to continue unacceptable behaviour - ie racism, sexism etc. No one is too old to learn if they are still in possession of their faculties.

lemongrove Fri 12-Mar-21 16:53:42

What Chestnut says.

Chestnut Fri 12-Mar-21 16:51:35

As we all know on here, you are still the same person even though many things about you will change as you age. If you have committed a serious crime and never been caught or punished then of course you should pay whatever your age. If that means you die in a cell then so be it. You have had a life, and maybe many years of life, that which was denied your victim or victims.
We've seen the Yorkshire Ripper, Hindley, Brady and others die in prison. They were not released because they were old and neither should they be. So a Nazi criminal should also pay for the rest of their life, however short that may be.

Pantglas2 Fri 12-Mar-21 16:48:28

I’ve pondered this question since watching the 2 night programme on James Bolger finishing last night and I still haven’t come to conclusion.

I appreciate its at the other end of the age scale but no less relevant surely?

Blossoming Fri 12-Mar-21 16:41:34

I’m reading a great deal about Nazi Germany at the moment and I’ve noticed a couple of stories in the press in the last few weeks about elderly people being prosecuted for war crimes. This is one example I’ve been following. It’s in the Guardian, which I know many Grans find anathema, but it is in other media too if preferred.

I’m interested to know people’s opinions on this. Do you think it’s pointless? Do you think old people shouldn’t have to answer for their acts? Do you think justice should be done for the sake of the victims and their families? Do you think it’s important the world should know this is not now, and never was, acceptable?

I have skin in the game due to family history and that may colour my view.

www.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/feb/20/us-deports-former-concentration-camp-guard-95-germany