Gransnet forums

Ask a gran

Happy Valley Theories ***Warning: may contain spoilers***

(110 Posts)
Oldernewgranny Sun 05-Feb-23 11:06:27

So how do you think it will end or how would you like it to end?

Susieq62 Mon 06-Feb-23 11:55:52

By the way it is West Yorkshire not Lancashire !!

Susieq62 Mon 06-Feb-23 11:54:23

It was brilliant !!
Amazing acting !!
Awards all round I hope!!

Maggiemaybe Mon 06-Feb-23 11:13:31

I think he would have been a different person. At one stage last night I even started to feel a bit sorry for him. Until he told Catherine that he forgave her! shock

Callistemon21 Mon 06-Feb-23 11:08:11

Maggiemaybe

It was a perfect ending imho. All loose ends duly tied. I’m so glad Sally Wainwright wasn’t tempted to finish it all off with a Wild West type shoot out. The acting was superb.

Yes, me too.

What a conversation between the two main protagonists!
No Wild West dramatics but far, far better and so emotional.

Would Tommy had been a different person had he had a different early life?
Nature or nurture?

Greyduster Mon 06-Feb-23 10:54:14

How are the Hebden Bridge place going to manage without her?. They’ll stop chasing t***s and start chasing alien life forms instead!

Doodledog Mon 06-Feb-23 09:41:19

Iam64

It was a brilliant finale to what has been a brilliant series.
Sally Wainwright knows people doesn’t she. She gives older Lancashire women and the Lancashire countryside the starring roles they deserve.
Good triumphed over evil, in the end . I liked the superintendent’s underplayed recognition of Catherine’s local knowledge
Also -his response to Catherine asking who’s going to look after those two little girls. Their granny he said, in fact, there are two grannies. Full circle, grannies to the rescue

That's pretty much what the reviewer in the Guardian said, too:

'Catherine breaking off from tearing a strip of Ryan to make sure his tea doesn't spoil' grin

It was so good. I loved that even as she was handing in her uniform she was solving the mystery of the drugs. How are the Hebden Bridge place going to manage without her?

I'm pleased that she made up with Claire, and most of all that Ryan came out of it all so well - both his 'grannies' there for him, and no sign that Nature had triumphed over Nurture.

Nannagarra Mon 06-Feb-23 09:38:50

Can I add another Greyduster? Clare’s anxious movements and facial expressions in Nev’s kitchen conveyed a whole nuanced story without words.
Masterful.
Every one was masterful and the controlled writing superb.

Maggiemaybe Mon 06-Feb-23 09:32:35

And the script! Sally Wainwright really knows her stuff. That scene between Catherine and Claire…

“There’s tea in t’pot, but you won’t want it.” And when Catherine poured herself a cup we knew right away that all would be well between the two of them.

Greyduster Mon 06-Feb-23 09:18:44

Two BAFTA winning performances there, I think. I felt wrung out at the end. It was fairly obvious he was going to set fire to something when he took the petrol can but I wasn’t expecting that! And when she walked out of the cemetery she really did look as if she’d had a huge weight lifted off her shoulders.

Maggiemaybe Mon 06-Feb-23 09:12:31

Lancashire??!

Oh, I think you might be in trouble now, Iam! grin

Iam64 Mon 06-Feb-23 08:57:56

It was a brilliant finale to what has been a brilliant series.
Sally Wainwright knows people doesn’t she. She gives older Lancashire women and the Lancashire countryside the starring roles they deserve.
Good triumphed over evil, in the end . I liked the superintendent’s underplayed recognition of Catherine’s local knowledge
Also -his response to Catherine asking who’s going to look after those two little girls. Their granny he said, in fact, there are two grannies. Full circle, grannies to the rescue

Urmstongran Sun 05-Feb-23 22:35:10

The Telegraph just now:

REVIEW
Happy Valley, episode 6, review: a finale of understated, heartbreaking brilliance

5/5
Sally Wainwright and Sarah Lancashire gave Catherine Cawood the denouement she deserved – a sensational end to a truly great drama.

Redhead56 Sun 05-Feb-23 22:31:57

Superb acting I feel like a wreck now got to watch it another day.

Juliet27 Sun 05-Feb-23 22:31:23

Another bit of a tussle!!

Pittcity Sun 05-Feb-23 22:26:52

Good job Winnie was still keeping an eye out.

I hope the teacher's daughter finally took her coat off!

Maggiemaybe Sun 05-Feb-23 22:25:49

It was a perfect ending imho. All loose ends duly tied. I’m so glad Sally Wainwright wasn’t tempted to finish it all off with a Wild West type shoot out. The acting was superb.

merlotgran Sun 05-Feb-23 22:24:07

A really good ending. I’d like to have seen more of the pharmacist and his arrest but there wasn’t enough time.

Visgir1 Sun 05-Feb-23 22:21:35

Didn't see that ending coming? Magnificent final scene with TL and Catherine.
Absolutely brilliant witting from Sally Wainwright.
Going to re watch without the stress.

Sar53 Sun 05-Feb-23 22:19:35

A satisfactory ending, tense, shocking at times and emotional too.
A brilliant series.

Litterpicker Sun 05-Feb-23 22:19:26

I’m wrung out

Callistemon21 Sun 05-Feb-23 22:18:26

Maggiemaybe

“I might have singed one of your crochet throws”. grin

I was shouting "Oh, no, all that work, what a waste of a crochet blanket!"

Callistemon21 Sun 05-Feb-23 22:17:31

Typo:
me too.

NotSpaghetti Sun 05-Feb-23 22:17:28

Maggiemaybe

“I might have singed one of your crochet throws”. grin

Yes, that was a good line. 👍

Callistemon21 Sun 05-Feb-23 22:17:02

Sarah75

Really? I thought it was a superb ending.

Yes, me.

Slow and suspenseful in parts, with sudden bursts of violence and a satisfying ending.

dogsmother Sun 05-Feb-23 22:15:27

I thoroughly enjoyed that 😊