Gransnet forums

Ask a gran

Manipulative sister

(34 Posts)
Nana56 Sat 08-Jul-23 11:14:19

She gets all the benefits but refuses to use it for taxi. That's hair and clothes money. She's not short of money

Callistemon21 Sat 08-Jul-23 11:07:57

The Disability Living Allowance is supposed to help pay for any help eg paying for a cleaner, taxis etc.

You might want to do some groundwork for her and find out about the hospital car service or the non-emergency ambulance transport service.

www.nhs.uk/nhs-services/hospitals/going-into-hospital/how-to-organise-transport-to-and-from-hospital

Nana56 Sat 08-Jul-23 11:02:23

I appreciate your comments. It helps to know that I'm not being mean spirited. She come for a meal twice a week, and is included in family events. I know I'm really luck to have a lovely family, bit isn't life what you make it? At times it's really hard work !!

Smileless2012 Sat 08-Jul-23 10:54:27

Your husband's right I'm afraid, you are being manipulated and as your children say, you are not her carer.

It's her choice as to whether or not she goes for dialysis and with her disability allowance, she should be able to afford a taxi.
If she's feeling ill because she didn't go, that's on her not you.

Could you tell her you'll take her to every other appointment and she'll need to get a taxi for the ones in between? That sounds perfectly reasonable to me. I can understand you taking her to be there when a transplant is being discussed for moral support, but you do need to put your foot down and stop her manipulating her.

If she can manage aqua 3 times a week, she can manage a taxi and to clean her own flat.

Take back control. It wont be easy but it is doable.

Callistemon21 Sat 08-Jul-23 10:53:08

Re the dialysis - could she ask for a dialysis machine at home? My friend was offered one but didn't have room but she did have hospital transport to and from the renal unit each day.

No, you aren't her carer, being supportive doesn't mean you have to be at her beck and call and a drudge.
Is she entitled to more benefits so that she can pay for a cleaner?

VioletSky Sat 08-Jul-23 10:53:06

You already know you are being manipulated into doing a lot for your sister and no thanks

Threatening to deny treatment unless you bring her to appointments is a disgusting thing to do.

I think you need to withdraw that support. It sounds like you are ready.

If she deliberately harms herself by refusing treatment that is her responsibility as a grown adult

Oopsadaisy1 Sat 08-Jul-23 10:52:09

Listen to your husband and children, sometimes other family members can see clearer what is going on.

Visit and be supportive, don’t give advice unless she asks and don’t offer to do anything that you aren’t comfortable with.

If she asks you to do something that you don’t want to do just say that you are sorry but you can’t do it. There is no need for you to explain why.

I’m sure she is worried and scared and her way of dealing with it is to not go to dialysis and making excuses why she can’t/won’t go, even though it’s keeping her alive.
Not sure how you can help her with that one as I’m sure it isn’t a pleasant experience but an essential one.

aggie Sat 08-Jul-23 10:50:02

She’s hurting and pushing boundaries , it’s hard to help her when she keeps pushing you away , it’s hard for you to keep getting pushed
I have no answers but my sympathy xxx

Nana56 Sat 08-Jul-23 10:44:41

I would welcome some wise words from the gransnet world.
When my mother died( we were estranged), as my sister was left alone she relocated to be near me and my family. She and my mother were very close, lived together. We kept in touch over the years.

She has renal failure snd needs dialysis. When she moved my husband and I viewed flats etc. When she moved we unpacked the removal van so she fidnt have the stress.
Recently I'm finding it increasingly difficult to be supportive. I understand that dialysis must be awful. However, I cannot support her when she refuses to go and the feels awful. Last week she said 'they're lucky I go at all'
Recently I went to hospital appointments to discuss transplantation. What hurt the most that ,the hospital is some distance, was that I didn't even get treated to a coffee.
I think lately she's pushing me. We were discussing transplant and I said leave some bedding out, it'll be nice when you come home. Her reply was 'oh yes and maybe you can deep clean the flat'
Get a cleaner!!
Finally, she's been saying if I can't get a lift to hospital, I won't go. I'm not paying fir a taxi. She has disability allowance.
She is not an invalid, goes to aqua 3 times a week. Also my husband gets infuriated as he thinks I'm being manipulated and my children remind me that I m not her carer.
Thanks for reading