Gransnet forums

Ask a gran

Dilemma over potential house move

(34 Posts)
DinoGran Wed 05-Jun-24 09:49:45

My DD and GD have always lived within 20 minutes of me which has enabled me to look after GD doing school runs, overnight stays etc when needed. However they have recently moved to an hour's drive away and they would like me to move to the same town. Unfortunately house prices are higher than where I am now. I initially agreed because I do miss them, especially my GD as I've been a very big part of her life. I have found somewhere but it is £25k more than I can sell mine for and will need complete renovation costing at least £50k. This will take most of my savings. I really don't mind the hour's drive to see them and, if necessary, I could always stay overnight somewhere - they don't have room for me to stay comfortably in their new home. My GD has reached an age now where she is becoming her own person and I'm not sure how much more I would be involved in her life even if I lived close by. My DD moved to move in with her partner and so they have this little family unit that on the face of it is working out well. I really don't want to leave my current home. Any thoughts? confused

Dinahmo Fri 07-Jun-24 12:28:31

When we lived in Suffolk a lady moved into the village, having followed her daughter and family from Kent. She entered into village life, had a few Soay sheep, geese etc. Then her daughter moved away and she followed on.

If you move to follow your children you will be dependent upon them for a social life until you establish one of your own, which can take some time, especially if you are not a "joiner"

It's a difficult decision because, as one gets older, one may need help from one's children and they often don't have the time to travel. At that point is is a good idea to be closer so that they can help you if necessary.

Nannashirlz Fri 07-Jun-24 12:13:57

I’d just say sorry I’m happy here if you want child care you going to have to bring child here at end of day it was their choice not yours or are you going to keep following them wherever they go. Mine lived few hundred miles away in different directions due to work etc and met wife’s at same place they also told me to move i had a good job friends etc i stayed put last year 15yrs later Ive moved next to one of them but that was my choice not theirs

NotSpaghetti Thu 06-Jun-24 20:03:55

I'd find a nice rental flat/cottage/house that you can afford to visit nearthem. You can then invite the grandchild/grandchildren to stay with you if you like, without the drive.

Don't move just to babysit! I think an hour isn't very far to travel. I used to travel nearly that to school if you count walking to the bus stop! 🤣

madeleine45 Thu 06-Jun-24 16:39:39

Your family have moved for whatever reason that suited them, and they were aware of where you live and the financial situation in the various areas. They had CHOICE and used it. Why should they think that you would want to go through all the hassle of moving and all that entails, to a less comfortable , less spacious home, using up your finances and leaving your friends and life that you have built up, just to be available for their convenience? If you wanted to move that would be a different matter. There seems very little element of choice in the situation for you, more an implied sort of blackmail that ,if you dont move there ,you will see less or be less involved in their lives. I am sure that if you related the same scenario where parents were expected to uproot themselves for the benefit of the children, about some fictitious friends, they would be quite likely to say how unfair that was etc, whereupon you could say well that is what you want me to do! Even without mentioning this at all, and as we all are prepared to help our children when possible, it does not mean that we should totally upset our lives , simply for their benefit. You DO have a life of your own, and are not just hanging about waiting to be of use to them! Whilst they may have lots of reasons, prices or whatever, to have no spare room, they should be looking at the situation from any visitors point of view, - not just yours - so maybe there is a b/b close by , or a simple hotel, but life should be a balance, So while we never want to be counting in the "I did that for you so you should do this for me" decent relationships and partnerships of any kind work best when there is give and take, on BOTH sides, not you give and they take!! I would choose to stay in the home I loved and want my children and grandchildren to be in touch and visit ,as I would visit them ,because we wanted to be with each other and not to just to be used . ( Another idea, rather naughtily came to me ! You could say "O yes. Then you would be near enough to ...take me out, look after me, take me to the doctors etc etc. "}So you have lived the life many of us have lived , fitting in with family needs and moving for things like change of jobs. Now it is your time to consider your own needs and wishes. If you are happy where you are and have a bit of a financial cushion, why the heck would you want to move to something that suits you less.? Of course there is also the fact that at sometime in the future , they may need to move , for work or whatever and you could end up stuck in a place you do not want to be in. Stay independant and enjoy your home.My old old way I used to suggest to students or friends, was to have 2 pieces of paper, on one write the pro s , and on the other the con s . Each time you think of something, add it to the list and fold over each time. Then after a while, get the lists out and look at them. You will see how things group together and can see patterns. Some things are very obvious and others can be surprising. But the point of it is to do it for yourself. No one else needs see the paper, and no one else will be influencing the list. Keep that stashed away somewhere, and when your family have made you feel guilty, upset, annoyed, go back and look at your lists and know that these are the things that really affect your life and you have every right to do what suits you. Good luck to you , you have survived all that life has thrown at you, enjoy yourself and do as you want, so long as you keep within the law. There are no pockets in shrouds, so treat yourself kindly and dont feel the slightest bit guilty!!

SusieB50 Thu 06-Jun-24 16:18:49

Stay put! You can have GD to stay in the holidays and visit them staying in a ABNB . My DD was very keen for me to move near them when they decided to move away to a part of Norfolk that had NO public transport ( I don't drive) I think she now understands it would not be a good plan . They visit often and I stay near them in ABNB until SIL finishes all the house renovations !

Shelflife Thu 06-Jun-24 16:05:11

Clearly you have doubts , pay heed to your thoughts and stay put! Your DD made the move and now they want you to follow suit! As you say your DG is growing fast and things change. Stay on your own patch and visit when you can and very importantly when it suits you. If you moved to be close and then they moved again - how would you feel? Would you you move again - probably not! Please think hard and don't be coerced into moving. Do want you know is right for you.

silverlining48 Thu 06-Jun-24 15:31:06

I may have misread your post as you only mentioned dd and gc initially so I thought your dd had gone to another area to live with her partner. Rather than they went together ….apologies.

silverlining48 Thu 06-Jun-24 15:26:52

Also not to be negative, but if the house your dd has moved to is not hers, should the relationship break down she would have to find somewhere else which might be in a less expensive area. Hope not of course, but it’s something to consider.

Calendargirl Thu 06-Jun-24 13:53:34

You obviously don’t want to move, so don’t!

It’s not like they are now living the other end of the country.

And believe me, when the GC get into their teens, they just don’t need you like they did when small. You very much move down the pecking order in their lives.

Stay put, and enjoy the occasional visit.

Smileless2012 Thu 06-Jun-24 12:49:08

'If in doubt, do nowt' and don't leave yourself short financially DinoGran.

silverlining48 Wed 05-Jun-24 17:20:35

We were in the same position, in a nice spacious detached character house but in a less sought after ie cheaper area. Dd moved to a house in a wealthy sought after area which we coukdnt afford to move to without depleting all our savings and taking out another mortgage, , fir a smaller house and nowhere near as nice as the one we have.
Now children are older we are not needed for care and not part of their lives as we once were. My advice? Dont get into debt by moving.

midgey Wed 05-Jun-24 17:03:34

Don’t run your savings down, it is so useful to have a cushion. It allows for emergencies and importantly treats! Stay where you are.

Norah Wed 05-Jun-24 16:53:09

I'd not move. Good to stay put!

AreWeThereYet Wed 05-Jun-24 15:52:42

Agree with others. It's a big change to make when you can't see what will happen in the future.

Do you have a spare room where GD can stay for the weekend now and then? Mum and Dad get a break and you get to keep up contact with GD as she grows.

dalrymple23 Wed 05-Jun-24 14:34:28

Agree with everyone. Stay put. Family dynamics change over the years. Your young might move again. Then what?

Junior daughter, spouse + 3 are in the USA. Communicate by email only! Senior daughter + 1 in London - not spoken for 14 years. Her choice. Neither girls know where their brother is. Neither do I, nor do they know what his two children are doing, or his ex-wife. or where they are living.

I can do absolutely nothing about it. They are adults and make their own choices, it is sad but I am not going weep. Hard hearted, maybe but that is life.

Oh, happy families!

zakouma66 Wed 05-Jun-24 12:46:09

I think you've answered your own question. You don't want to move.

You may have many opportunities ahead of you either with or without family.

The GC will grow up and make her own life.

karmalady Wed 05-Jun-24 12:43:16

Stay where you are, it is up to dd to work around this as many do. Dinogran, try not to feel the guilt that dd has put upon you, life will go on and so will your loving relationship. Be straight, say it as it is and don`t qualify with reasons. She needs to know so she can make arrangements

Dingleberry Wed 05-Jun-24 12:33:18

I had this problem, A few years ago after my husband died, our son and daughter in law bought a new home about 30 motorway minutes away from me. Like your family, they wanted me to sell my home and move nearer to them as commuting to my home from their new home to leave our granddaughter with me for childminding was too far. I didn't drive so could not pick her up and it would have been three buses for me to get to their home.

I finally realised that the reason they wanted me to move home was so I could look after her and take her to school, pick her up and look after her until her parents got home. They also said she could stay overnight with me at the weekends and holidays.

I love our granddaughter but I did not want my life to be all about childminding just because my husband had died.

I decided to stay where I am and they were not pleased so I told them that they should not have bought a house so far away from me and this had been our home since they were born.

I honestly think sons and daughters can be very selfish, expecting grandparents to raise their children for them. We had no-one to look after our children as both our families had died just after we got married so we worked around it, my husband working days and me working evenings.

DamaskRose Wed 05-Jun-24 12:23:42

Calipso

It's always worth asking yourself the question 'What happens if they move again?' Where does that leave you?
From my own experience with (several) grandchildren, once they start senior school the dynamic changes. They still love you for sure but they belong a bit more to the world and a bit less to you. Which is as it should be.
Good luck with whatever you decide - I think you know the answer flowers

Just this. An hour’s drive isn’t much and if you make regular trips they’ll see that life is still going on and you’re all still close.

welbeck Wed 05-Jun-24 12:18:43

they are not thinking of you, but their own convenience.
you need to think of you.
stay.

V3ra Wed 05-Jun-24 12:11:12

Another vote for don't move!
What activities and friendship groups do you have in your current town?
I presume you didn't spend all your time with your daughter and granddaughter?
You need a life of your own which will be harder to establish somewhere new.

One suggestion for keeping in touch day-to-day that works well for us is to set up a family WhatsApp group between you all.
We use ours for news, questions, photos, jokes, anything that we would talk about in person if we lived closer and met up more often.

We can't stay at our daughter's house when we visit either.
One suggestion for you would be to stay in a Premier Inn or similar when you visit, and your granddaughter could join you for a sleepover in your room there 🙂

DinoGran Wed 05-Jun-24 11:42:09

Thanks for the responses. Its confirmed how I feel about the move and that is I don't want to leave my very nice home for one that is so much less. I can do a lot with the money I would have spent and it may come in useful to help GD with any educational expenses she may have in the future. She'll be disappointed but I'll suggest going to see them this weekend and doing something nice and see how that lands. I am torn but it really doesn't make sense for me to do this. flowers

Spinnaker Wed 05-Jun-24 11:41:40

I really don't want to leave my current home.

These last few words say it all OP flowers

tanith Wed 05-Jun-24 11:36:34

I’d stay where I was too.

Georgesgran Wed 05-Jun-24 11:21:29

I’m not sure I’d move, given the circumstances either.