Gransnet forums

Ask a gran

What would you do?

(87 Posts)
narrowboatnan Sun 16-Jun-24 10:14:34

My DD and family are going to foreign parts for two weeks in July and I have offered to house sit and dog sit. My DH (though not so Dear just now!) was coming with me but has now decided that my absence would be a good opportunity for him to get on with jobs on the boat without tripping over me and the dog (she’s coming with me). He says he’ll take me - it’s a two hour drive - and return home the next day. He is, however, very sticky about returning to collect me at the end of the fortnight. He thinks that my DD should bring me back! I pointed out that, having just returned from her holiday, with four children and a husband tired from travelling, plane delays etc would not be in a good place to add a four hour round trip onto the top of that!

I said I would go by train, but he thinks that would be unwise with an 8-month old puppy and a suitcase, especially as I have two train changes to make and then get from one end of Birmingham New Street Station to the other to make my last connection.

He has now spat his dummy out, along with throwing all his toys out of his pram and told me in no uncertain terms that “if she doesn’t bring you home then you’re not going!”

How dare he tell me what to do!! Do I (1). carry on sticking pins in my little wax doll; (2) say stuff it and go by train anyway; or (3) see if my son, who lives in the same town as my DD, to bring me back

WWYD?

NannyMags Mon 17-Jun-24 15:06:02

I would start by asking your son, who lives near your daughter if he wouldn’t mind driving you home. Two hour journey would be a good chance for the two of you to catch up. If he didn’t want to do the 2 hour return drive could he stay one night with you and your husband or even stay a night in a Travel Lodge type hotel? It is depends on his health and stamina.

Nannashirlz Mon 17-Jun-24 15:02:54

I’d say to daughter i don’t mind waiting an extra day until you feel up to the drive. After all you are helping her out by staying in her house . No i wouldn’t let a man order me around I’d let him toss his dummy out and say fine I will get train and you can look after the dog too lol

123ish Mon 17-Jun-24 14:56:19

Leave your dog with husband. At the end of your house sitting meander home staying at interesting places. Plenty of art galleries, National Trust properties etc.

Nan0 Mon 17-Jun-24 14:52:03

Ask son, and go by train..husband can pay the train/ taxi

hamster58 Mon 17-Jun-24 14:24:41

I see you offered to do this and when your husband changed his mind from staying with you, he’s still offering to take you. I actually don’t think up to that point he’s being unreasonable in thinking the younger family members should offer to bring you home. He’s being considerate in thinking the journey by train won’t be easy for you. Sometimes our children get so used to us offering to help they don’t think to reciprocate (should but don’t!) so I don’t think it unreasonable to say to your daughter that Dad’s bringing me but he’s going to be busy at the end of the holiday, so can she or her husband do the return journey. Not easy to ask I know, but not unreasonable. I think his current stance is made out of subconscious frustration, more than bossiness, maybe feeling you do a lot but don’t get much back maybe.

mousemac Mon 17-Jun-24 14:21:35

Since you do not specify whether you DD is also his DD, that is one thing one would need to know before wading in.
If she is also his DD, then he ought to be more empathic to her needs.
If not, maybe the following Qs might help to untangle what you are faced with.

Is this a typical thing with your DH? (I.e. choosing to remain at home and let you go elsewhere without him.)

If not, maybe you should try insisting he comes with you and see what kind of reaction that produces.

It looks very odd, to me.

rowyn Mon 17-Jun-24 14:18:54

Whilst I appreciate that this forum is great for sharing problems, I feel this request is a step too far. We are NOT Marriage Guidance counsellors. !

knspol Mon 17-Jun-24 14:10:15

Wouldn't go by train with a puppy and a suitcase especially with the changes involved.
Is it possible DH will calm down and change his mind?
You've committed to going now so tell your husband he can either take you and bring you back or you'll just take the car and drive yourself. Failing that if DH is still willing to drive you there then you will have no alternative but to ask DD to drive you home sometime after their hols.

Lindylou23 Mon 17-Jun-24 14:02:22

Go and house sit, worry about getting home when it happens, OH might have calmed down and missed you will come and get you

grandtanteJE65 Mon 17-Jun-24 13:53:20

Keep your mouth shut right now, go to your daughter's as planned, and take the train home. If you fear the puppy may wee in the wrong place, take a damp floorcloth in a plastic bag with you and a bottle of water for mopping up.

Arrive home with no notice given, and if your darling daugher's daddy is still in the huff, tell him to be his age.

Poor choice of words, he is being his age, I suspect - grumpy old man, tell him to put a sock in it!

luluaugust Mon 17-Jun-24 13:47:40

I would phone my DD and ask if there is a possibility of her taking you home. If not try son. If either agrees to help accept DH’s offer to drive you there and assure him someone is bringing you back. If neither DC can help for a valid reason it looks like you are on the train both ways
I can never see the problem with pet/house sitting, different walks, different shops, places to visit, however, if he wants to paint the boat so be it. Good luck

HazelEyes Mon 17-Jun-24 13:47:35

You take the car so you can use it while you’re away. Or you incorporate a mini break on your way home to break your journey up using trains/taxis. Your life, your body, your choice.

V3ra Mon 17-Jun-24 13:15:30

I'd missed the part where the arrangements had been made but your husband has now changed his mind.

He's being unfair to everyone in my opinion.
He's the one who's causing the complications and he should be the one sorting it out, ie collecting you himself.

Pythagorus Mon 17-Jun-24 12:58:55

A few choices!
1. Cant you drive yourself there?
2. Taxi to take you home? Perhaps your son/ daughter could pay half.
3. Ask your son to take you home. It would be nice for his dad to see him.
4. You have offered to go and do this. Your husband has offered to take you. I think he is generous to do that. It’s up to you to sort your return journey if you go.
5. If you go return on the train with puppy. Just take a cross body bag and a back pack. Re el light.
6. You don’t have to tell your husband how you are getting back. Say your daughter will you home and then if you feel up to it just get the train back! Not a lot he can do about that because you’ll already be there!

You can sort this! Go girl!

Rainwashed Mon 17-Jun-24 12:37:24

Can someone eg. your daughter take you to the station and your husband pick you up at the other end? or get a taxi.

Marthjolly1 Mon 17-Jun-24 12:34:23

How very dare he indeed. Certainly he is throwing his dummy out of the pram in his great big trantrum. There is lots of very good advice for you here. Have you done this train journey before. Is the dog used to train journeys. If not I would consider alternative arrangements for it. And I would have already booked my seat on the train by now. Good luck. I hope it all works out for you. But don't be bullied into changing your plans.

Luckygirl3 Mon 17-Jun-24 12:33:53

* ....... then you’re not going!*

Ahem ...... is he your boss? Are you a child?

You can do what you like!

pascal30 Mon 17-Jun-24 12:29:08

I would leave the puppy behind and get a train both ways. If your husband can't be co-operative and help both you and your daughter then make him at least take responsibility for the dog..

Tenko Mon 17-Jun-24 12:28:08

If you drive , could you not drive there and back ? That gives you some freedom when you’re there .
Otherwise could you dh and dd meet halfway on both journeys ? You could have lunch or a coffee . You’re doing your dd and her family a favour after all .
We do this when my mum goes to my sister. Who’s a 2 hour drive away . Also with my goddaughter who’s a 4 hour drive .
I would certainly object to my husband telling me what to do .

icanhandthemback Mon 17-Jun-24 12:23:44

Dcba I love that idea. 🤣🤣🤣

Dcba Mon 17-Jun-24 12:11:54

Assert your independence ……hire an Uber to bring you back home and charge it your husband’s credit card!

Pippa22 Mon 17-Jun-24 12:07:48

If this were me I would leave my dog behind with the husband and go to my daughters on the train and back on the train a day after the family get back so you can hear all about their lovely holiday straight away. I value being independent and don’t like asking for help so wouldn’t even consider expecting to be taken and collected even though you are doing your family a favour. If you are able I don’t know why you are expecting to have lifts.

Jannipans Mon 17-Jun-24 12:05:24

How about a compromise? A meeting point roughly half way (pub meal with DD or other family - one lot there, one back perhaps?)
Hubby still only doing same mileage, couple of nice meals with family, win win!
(NB. Make sure the pub/restaurant is dog friendly!)
Alternatively just meet halfway and swap without the meal (easy to meet up anywhere these days with a google maps pin!

WonderBra Mon 17-Jun-24 12:03:53

1, keep on with the wax dolly.
If you can drive, take the car - much easier for you when there if you have transport so you can go shopping, visit your son etc.
If not, then see if your son could give you a lift home, but failing all else, the train would be OK, depending on your health and agility, and the dog's behaviour / if it would worry on the train.
Ignore the black mirror..... wink

Stansgran Mon 17-Jun-24 12:03:51

The answer is obvious. Kennels