Gransnet forums

Ask a gran

Smelling good?

(104 Posts)
ROMILO Thu 21-Aug-25 14:58:50

I have used the same perfume 'Beautiful ' for many years but I think they must have changed the formula because the last bottle has lost both potency and staying power . Have you any suggestions for a similar floral perfume that isn't in the silly price category.

sandye Sat 23-Aug-25 14:03:25

I have used one called Maroussia for years. Don't seem to be able to buy it in Britain so had to buy it all when aboard but can now get it via Amazon. It seems to last all day. Very flowery

RobertaDanversWalker Sat 23-Aug-25 13:44:32

The young man serving me at the garden centre till said I smelled “amazing” and asked me what my perfume was. I told him it was Black Orchid by Tom Ford and he said, “it’s gorgeous but I couldn’t afford to buy it for my girlfriend.” Which impressed me that a) he’d heard of it and b) knew how much it cost!

nexus63 Sat 23-Aug-25 13:40:40

i wear charlie red, tweed and coty l'aimant, i have noticed the last bottle of tweed did not smell the same, i am a creature of habit and i have been using these since my teens.

henetha Sat 23-Aug-25 11:05:00

It's ok NotSpaghetti smile Are cheaper perfumes always copies of well known expensive ones? If so, I didn't realise that. But it wouldn't worry me if they were. As a person who just cannot afford those I am perfectly content with my M&S ones, or similar.
I can't help feeling that many modern perfumes are overpriced.

NotSpaghetti Sat 23-Aug-25 00:05:25

Sorry Henetha if that was confusing, it was Diffuser who said the M and S dupes are excellent.

I wondered what they were dupes of?

Doodledog Fri 22-Aug-25 23:57:37

I like several of the Saltworks range.

You can buy a box of trial samples for £29 (you get ten, but at the moment there is an offer on and they throw in an extra three) so you can see which you like. The box includes a voucher for £25 off a full size bottle, or you can use it against there handbag-sized bottles if you can't make your mind up.

My favourites are Tabac Soleil and Brown Sugar, which aren't floral at all, but they also do a floral trial box if that's your preference - I'm not sure what Beautiful smells like. They are long lasting too.

henetha Fri 22-Aug-25 23:11:27

I do t know if Mand S are copying anything, but I do know that their perfumes are lovely and at a sensible price. My favourite it Florentyna.
Next do some nice ones too.

NotSpaghetti Fri 22-Aug-25 23:04:07

So what are the M&S ones copying?

Diffuser Fri 22-Aug-25 22:12:23

I can only echo the M and S dupes are excellent. You have to apply them more often (obviously) but I have used Pink Pepper, Pistachio and Neroli and have had unexpected compliments each time I've worn them.
My 'going out ' perfume is Liz Earle 15, unique and beautiful

Oreo Fri 22-Aug-25 21:38:51

Luckylegs

I read about a new dupe today and bought it without even trying first. It’s from Superdrug and called Cherry Noir for £12. It’s apparently the best dupe known for a Tom Ford cherry one at £290 or something ridiculous. All the other smells in the Artiscent range are half price but not this one obviously. When I first put it on I thought it was very strong cherry smell but it has matured into a lovely smell and quite long lasting. Has anyone else tried it?

Thanks! Will try it😃

Primrose53 Fri 22-Aug-25 21:38:40

I have been using Calvin Klein Euphoria for a while and love it.

I like Clinique’s Aromatic (?) in the yellow box and I love Clarins fragrances.

NotSpaghetti Fri 22-Aug-25 20:29:26

This is the video that "sold" the dupe to me just in case anyone else loved this fragrance.

youtu.be/WgD0TyEl0Uo?si=Ib5eBZR5w966Ay36

NotSpaghetti Fri 22-Aug-25 20:21:05

No, but have tried a Plum Japonaise one.
The original isn't made anymore and my husband loves it. There is one purporting to be the real thing on Ebay at £526.87 at the moment!

I did quite a lot of research as to which dupe to go for though.

I feel disappointed that there isn't a copyright on perfumes as it really is an art making them.

Luckylegs Fri 22-Aug-25 19:47:32

I read about a new dupe today and bought it without even trying first. It’s from Superdrug and called Cherry Noir for £12. It’s apparently the best dupe known for a Tom Ford cherry one at £290 or something ridiculous. All the other smells in the Artiscent range are half price but not this one obviously. When I first put it on I thought it was very strong cherry smell but it has matured into a lovely smell and quite long lasting. Has anyone else tried it?

NotSpaghetti Fri 22-Aug-25 19:39:09

If you have someone to buy for you could go back and ask him?
grin

ViceVersa Fri 22-Aug-25 19:18:30

NotSpaghetti

ViceVersa

On a side note, I was in a shop yesterday and the young man who served me smelled absolutely amazing - I was seriously tempted to ask him what he was wearing, then decided that would make me seem very creepy!

I often ask.
I don't think it's creepy (unless you say it in a creepy way!)...

It just felt a bit 'cougarish' to me. He did smell very good though...

TwiceAsNice Fri 22-Aug-25 18:22:06

Clinique Happy and M&S Florentyna are both floral and not expensive . I alternate 4 perfumes , the other two are Body Shop White Musk and Elizabeth Arden Blue Grass again not expensive

NotSpaghetti Fri 22-Aug-25 17:18:48

ViceVersa

On a side note, I was in a shop yesterday and the young man who served me smelled absolutely amazing - I was seriously tempted to ask him what he was wearing, then decided that would make me seem very creepy!

I often ask.
I don't think it's creepy (unless you say it in a creepy way!)...

NotSpaghetti Fri 22-Aug-25 17:17:43

Janiepops I'm not talking about Nonenal which is quite different.

Just as our skin changes at puberty, so it does later.

ViceVersa Fri 22-Aug-25 15:23:34

On a side note, I was in a shop yesterday and the young man who served me smelled absolutely amazing - I was seriously tempted to ask him what he was wearing, then decided that would make me seem very creepy!

Fartooold Fri 22-Aug-25 14:36:47

A boyfriend bought me some Chanel No 5 for my 21st birthday and have used it ever since! I still think it is lovely, what a boring old fool! Not the same bottle!

J52 Fri 22-Aug-25 14:34:27

Beautiful makes me sneeze, I don’t really care for the fragrance so it’s just as well.
A relatively cheap everyday day perfume is Elizabeth Arden’s 5thAvenue, an oldie but still on sale. Has a hint of Lily of the Valley.

Janiepops Fri 22-Aug-25 14:31:26

Anais anais is lovely, my sons say they know when I’m in their houses!
A strong one of old is Youth Dew, but I haven’t sniffed at it in many many years, not sure if it’s changed at all.
I love Tweed, got some online last year, it’s still lovely!
Just pink, by Next is flowery and fresh, I always get compliments when wearing it.
Our smell does change. The smell is Nonenal, you can buy persimmon soap to help counter it. Look it up on google, it’s got all the info you need. 👍😀

Dee1012 Fri 22-Aug-25 13:57:34

NotSpaghetti

I have found that my body chemistry has probably changed as I have aged (quite dramatically at the menopause)- because I love fragrance and have always had several "on the go".

I find that several are very different on me now even though they aren't necessarily ones that have been reformulated.

You can Google it.

I know Clinique said Aromatics has been reformulated.
It was to comply with EU and IFRA rules (around safety I seem to remember).

Found this really interesting!

I've always preferred quite a 'strong' scent, quite simply because so many just didn't work for me.
Lately though they seem to smell differently on me....perhaps it's this!

I'd also give the M&S range a go...Florentyna is really nice and the Apothecary range have some lovely items.

ROMILO Fri 22-Aug-25 13:24:18

NotSpaghetti

I have found that my body chemistry has probably changed as I have aged (quite dramatically at the menopause)- because I love fragrance and have always had several "on the go".

I find that several are very different on me now even though they aren't necessarily ones that have been reformulated.

You can Google it.

I know Clinique said Aromatics has been reformulated.
It was to comply with EU and IFRA rules (around safety I seem to remember).

Interesting point about body chemistry I am 82 and have not noticed this before now but I wonder if medication may also have some effect.