Gransnet forums

Ask a gran

Pumpkins

(14 Posts)
62Granny Fri 17-Oct-25 17:01:03

The sheer volume of pumpkins on sale already, it seems so wasteful for one day, most people just scrape them out and don't "use" them for anything apart from decoration for one night. I am sure if you buying them now and making lanterns out of them they certainly won't be good for making soup or anything with them after the event. I went into our local Morrison's on Tuesday and they had huge cardboard boxes in foyer stacked full it must have been 3ft side by 4 ft tall. I am sure other supermarkets are the same. I know you can use it for bird/ wildlife food afterwards, but realistically how many younger people would bother.

MollyNew Fri 17-Oct-25 17:16:53

I agree, it does seem wasteful. However, I thought the large carving pumpkins were not as nice to eat? Am I mistaken?

Jaxjacky Fri 17-Oct-25 18:05:51

I’ve got no energy to complain at this 62Granny, one tradition - although it used to be turnips - that’s lasted and gives pleasure.
I’d rather folk focus on the other tons of wasted, easily edible food wasted every day in the UK.

GrannyIvy Fri 17-Oct-25 18:10:48

We do pumpkin carving with our dgc every year and the pumpkin we scoop out we give to our neighbour who then makes gorgeous pumpkin soup for us all

62Granny Fri 17-Oct-25 18:15:12

I don't think the very big ones are any good for human consumption as they are grown for decoration and if you scrape/ cut out all the flesh they are no good as lanterns.

Georgesgran Fri 17-Oct-25 18:16:08

We take the DGSs to a farm outside Hexham - rides, playground and thousands of pumpkins. Admission isn’t cheap and any pumpkins we take have to be paid for, but thousands must be left to rot on the land or go to animal feed.

I feel it’s probably a crop just grown for profit, easily replaced - a bit like Christmas trees.

Patsy70 Fri 17-Oct-25 18:43:23

In our village a farmer requests we take our unwanted pumpkins to feed his pigs!

Esmay Sat 18-Oct-25 07:34:28

Unlike our American cousins we Brits aren't into eating that much pumpkin .
I have made and like pumpkin pie and soup
But we love Hallowe'en (as they do).
I just think that it's a bit of fun for the children.
Even my C of E church is having an All Soul's party .

Cambsnan Sat 18-Oct-25 07:51:02

Is it more wasteful than Christmas trees? Both are grow as a single use product we do not eat.

Casdon Sat 18-Oct-25 07:52:05

I suppose it’s the same as growing flowers for sale really. They are used for decorative purposes only too.

Grandmabatty Sat 18-Oct-25 07:54:19

I'd rather have pumpkins for decoration than plastic stuff. At least they will rot down if unused.
Disclaimer: I have plastic stuff and a pumpkin!

Sarnia Sat 18-Oct-25 08:15:52

Please DO NOT leave pumpkins out for wildlife. The Forestry Commission tells us that pumpkins are not a natural food for our British wildlife and can be harmful. especially for hedgehogs which are already in decline. 62Granny please do not tell people otherwise.

Norah Sat 18-Oct-25 19:14:54

Pumpkin Soup

Pumpkin, scoop out inner flesh, roast seeds
chopped onion, saute
grated garlic, saute
coconut milk
cumin
fenugreek
salt
pepper

Cook, blend. Top with roasted pumpkin seeds.

butterandjam Sat 18-Oct-25 19:36:51

DH made a delicious pumpkin pie today.

Birds get the seeds. The skins go in the compost heap. Nothing wasted.