Gransnet forums

Books/book club

Beautiful Ruins Q&A

(66 Posts)
GeraldineGransnet (GNHQ) Mon 15-Jul-13 17:09:38

Our summer reading book club is Jess Walter's acclaimed novel, Beautiful Ruins. Spanning five decades and half the globe, it's got everything from the Ligurian coast to Los Angeles, from clapped-out musicians and would-be screenwriters to Richard Burton.

Ask a question for Jess Walter here (especially if you got a free book!) before 19 August.

EastEndGranny Thu 22-Aug-13 09:18:42

I'm not sure I would have picked this up in the book shop but that would have been my loss as I really enjoyed it. The characters in the book were so different but each one was described really well. At our book club there are often comments about characters being very shallow. This couldn't be said about the people in this book. I hope we will take it on as one of our reads for the next 'term'.

Buddie Mon 19-Aug-13 17:57:15

I was delighted to recieve my copy of this book and am only sorry I have not quite inished it before the Q&A deadline. I am really enjoying the book but life has been getting in the way somewhat.

Like others I found the toing and froing between characters and time scale a little frustrating at first but realised quite quickly that it actually helps the story to develop. The passages from the sixties have their own pace as does the war-time section and the hectic pace of the life for Claire is all in keeping with the way lifestyles have changed within that time.

I should like to ask Jess whether the book was written in the sequence it appears or were the different periods written in turn and then integrated? Indeed, I have often wondered how authors set about including backstory and this seems quite an extreme example.

As a I had a relative served in Italy during the last war I found the insight I received into the life of the time particularly of interest and wondered if there were a similar connection for the author.

MissLes Mon 19-Aug-13 17:15:05

Hi Jess,
How do you think your years as a journalist have impacted on your writing style? Were any of your characters or stories based on people you met?
And I really enjoyed the book!

googleeyes Mon 19-Aug-13 16:13:42

I really enjoyed Beautiful Ruins, which is very romantic and cinematic and lush - and of course, is all about the movies. Did you always have in mind that it would be made into a film? Would you rather a 1960s type film or a 2013 type film? And how is it going?

cashmerequeen Mon 19-Aug-13 16:09:35

Hi Jess. The book took you 15 years to write, I read somewhere. Did you publish other books in the meantime? Is it very different from, say, 10 years ago? Do you think all books should have such a long gestation period?!

fastgran Mon 19-Aug-13 16:06:50

Pasquale is the most sympathetic character in the book in many ways and yet he is the only one not trying to write a book or make a movie or become some kind of creative genius. Were you saying in effect that all creative people are to a greater or lesser extent risible?

scribblegranny Mon 19-Aug-13 16:04:43

The book is full of different voices and genres of writing. Is that why it took so long? And was it fun to write? Were you every worried that it wouldn't gel into a coherent whole?

underwhere Mon 19-Aug-13 16:02:11

Have you been surprised by the success of the book - I think it was in the bestseller lists in the US for months? Has that changed your life?

granIT Mon 19-Aug-13 16:00:27

The satire is very powerful in the book. Did you ever worry that it was taking over? Michael Deane's autobiography is a great piece of comic writing, but the trouble with comedy is that it runs away with character and I felt as he became more monstrous he also became less believable. is that a danger for the comic, satirical novelist?

topshot Mon 19-Aug-13 15:57:14

I really enjoyed the book. Thanks, Gransnet! I loved the idea of the Hotel Adequate View. Where did that come from?

getmehrt Mon 19-Aug-13 15:55:18

There are lots of twists and turns in the book and different types of storytelling. Did you know how they were all going to fit together before you started out? Did you know how it was going to end?

frangipane Mon 19-Aug-13 15:53:33

Then book has a bittersweet feel - there's an awful lot of talent going to waste, one way and another. Were you wanting to say something about the experience of being a creative person? Its that the predominant experience of being an artist, in your view?

Clytie Mon 19-Aug-13 12:43:09

Thinking about it some more, I was inclined to patronise Pasquale at first. He seemed a bit of a foolish character with his poor English, impractical ideas and strangely named hotel.

But then I recognised that his English was infinitely better than Dee's Italian, and seeing his thought processes, he quickly became someone to respect and sympathise with - not a tragicomic character at all. Later it became clear that even the hotel name had been a calculated decision by someone who knew exactly what it meant.

By the end, Pasquale was my favourite - a strong character who did the right thing whatever it cost him. I was so pleased that he and Dee had a happy ending.

After all that I think my question is, did you expect readers to see him in that way at first?

Annie29 Sun 18-Aug-13 19:59:28

Thank you for my copy of Beautiful Ruins, I am really enjoying it. My question is why are some of the chapters in a different font ?

chrissy5061 Fri 16-Aug-13 00:30:34

Just finished The Beautiful Ruins by Jess Walters. No wonder it took 15 years to write, so much toing and froing, phew I'm exhausted. First book Iv'e read by a male author other than the classics. Really didn't think I was going to like it, I don't like books that keep going back and forth as a rule, however after a while about eight chapters in I was beginning to wonder how it was going to all fit in place and where it was going to end. We certainly traveled in the the book. I enjoyed the book, on a score out of ten I would give it eight. My question to Jess is. Have you been to Edinburgh and to the fringe festival? This book must have taken a lot of research, or you know the places so well. Thanks for a most enjoyable read I do hope that any current books take less time for you to write. I give you ten out of ten for your perseverance. Thank you once again for this lovely book.

angybev Thu 15-Aug-13 18:18:16

Thank you very much for the book. However, I have struggled with it and found it difficult to get into. The characters seemed unrealistic and the various storylines disjointed. I'm afraid I've given up about halfway through.

merlotgran Thu 15-Aug-13 10:09:14

Jess, How long did it take you to write Beautiful Ruins? Did you need to do a lot of research given there are so many characters, locations and time changes?

I had images for some of the characters that wouldn't shift throughout the book - David Gest for Michael Deane, Al Pacino for Pasquale but I struggled with Dee Moray. Did you base her on a real life character?

And did you wait until after Elizabeth Taylor's death before writing it?

Clytie Mon 12-Aug-13 12:12:54

While I think Beautiful Ruins thoroughly deserves to be filmed, I do wonder if it's actually filmable when so much of it is introspective?

I'd like to know who you'd have in mind to play Dee and Pasquale?

MoonlightSonata Mon 12-Aug-13 12:00:33

Hello Jess

I loved your book, and don't think I've ever read one quite like it.

If you were to compare yourself to another author, who would it be?

Thank you.

Sunhat Mon 12-Aug-13 10:35:26

Fascinating book, Jess.

I was impressed by the way you created so many characters and yet they were all so distinct from each other.

You said that eventually, Dee and Pasquale took over and finished the book themselves. Were the other characters more biddable, or were there also moments when Clare or Pat, for instance, struggled for control?

Noni Sun 11-Aug-13 19:29:35

Thank you for the free copy of the book.
I read it whilst in Italy, a bit further down the coast in Tuscany, but in a very small non touristy area. It was very appropriate that I read it there, and really got caught up in the story. My question is whether Jess has stayed in the area to capture the feel of the place so well? The Italians really do have a community spirit which was so well portrayed in the book in the fishing village.
Hollywood is such a contrast and of course the "movie" world is very unreal compared with a small fishing village. A great and enjoyable read. Thank you.

gardener Sat 10-Aug-13 15:31:34

What does the author think of the cover ?
Do authors get to help in choosing a cover ?

weather Fri 09-Aug-13 11:03:14

Interesting book...do you think it may be made into a television play/film?

rocketstop Fri 09-Aug-13 10:11:06

Thank you for my free copy. I wanted to ask how Jess managed to overcome feeling a might 'Scared' of writing about such legends as Burton and Taylor and wasn't he worried that the families , particularly of Burton might object ?The book was very different to the kind of thing I usually read but I found it really painted pictures in my head of the people and places!

gardener Fri 09-Aug-13 09:19:43

Thank you so much for the book which arrived last week...not had the chance to start it yet.I will take it on holiday next week.
It would seem most readers are having difficulty getting into the book.
And the print is VERY small ... Oh dear that makes me sound so OLD !!!