177ms - I read the Butcher's Hook, I thought it was very well written, slow start but gathers pace midway, Janet Ellis evoked the 18th century very well imo. I would recommend any of the following, all set in the 19th century though, Crimson Petal and the White (a lot of sex, but a very good narrative) The Meaning of Night a story about an inheritance, Star of the Sea - Irish immigration at the time of the potato famine, you need to get past the first 50 pages and then it's wonderful. I have Pure on my shelves, I haven't read it yet but will do. I tend to google books to see what the reviews on Amazon are like before I embark on anything now, to see what the general consensus is, on the basis that not everybody can be wrong if it's at least 4*.