Gransnet forums

Books/book club

Books that defeated you!

(256 Posts)
TerriBull Wed 01-Mar-23 11:45:06

Hot on the heels of Doodledog's uplifting thread, best novels and why?. What book/s have you abandoned or wished you had!

Mine would be, Cloud Atlas, I did finish it but found really heavy going, at the time a few people around me were saying "what a great book" I think it was a very clever concept and although I can be ok with a non linear narrative, I just didn't get on with it at all. Similarly, Lincoln in The Bardo which has won so many literary awards, Booker Prize winner and then the best Booker Prize Winner ever shock and very much loved over on MN, not by me, I think, it was my worst book ever. Other than that Johnathan Strange and Mr Norrell, I gave up 100 pages in, not enjoying it with 600 or more pages to go. The Lovey Bones, I just hated it, thought it was utter shite, I couldn't understand why it had so many accolades heaped on it at the time.

So what did you hate and abandon and what did you finish but wish you hadn't wasted your time on?

Musicgirl Wed 01-Mar-23 19:13:43

Lord of the Rings. My brother read it several times as a teenager and I tried to get into it but little elves don’t do it for me. I am not a fan of fantasy or sci-fi anyway.

downtoearth Wed 01-Mar-23 19:54:28

Read The Lovely Bones,whilst arranging a memorial for my daughter who wasnt buried for 11months,I loved the book

Sara1954 Wed 01-Mar-23 20:19:07

Grumpa
I enjoyed the book, but the only way I could read it was to go and sit at the dining room table.

Chardy Wed 01-Mar-23 22:16:08

Thursday Murder Club divided our craft group - people either love it or loathe it. I did get to the end, but I had to make myself.
I read War & Peace on holiday decades ago. I finished it, it was a good story.
Can't manage to get past the first few chapters of Far from the Madding Crowd or (1st) Lord of the Rings, though I'vetried each several times and they're also excellent stories. Am trying to get DGD into The Hobbit on Audible to encourage me to try again.

Rosie51 Wed 01-Mar-23 23:56:33

MaizieD

Oh, just remembered. Michelle O'Bama's autobiography. So worthy, so dull. I never got as far as her becoming First Lady.

So disappointing because I admire her greatly.

I struggled with the printed version so bit the bullet and went for the audio version read by Michelle Obama and loved it! I'd already had a couple of Barack Obama books on audible read by him and enjoyed them, so thought it worth the punt.

I struggled with "The Goldfinch" which one of my sons bought for me. That was a determined effort to get to the end. A good story that could have stood dramatic shortening! I really don't like to abandon any book I start to read.

PamelaJ1 Thu 02-Mar-23 03:11:04

NotSpaghetti

^Captain Corelli's Mandolin^
I tried and tried and tried!

I tried 3 times too.

Lauren59 Thu 02-Mar-23 04:26:44

Anything written by William Faulkner. I was required to read The Sound and the Fury at school. Awful.

nanna8 Thu 02-Mar-23 05:13:50

The Harry Potter books. Not bad films but I can’t read the books. Also the Da Vinci Code- dreadful style.

Gingerrice Thu 02-Mar-23 05:27:08

I'm with Notspaghetti on Capt Corelli - tried twice failed twice

Marmight Thu 02-Mar-23 05:52:43

Life after Life by Kate Atkinson. Love most of her books but this one defeated me

Sara1954 Thu 02-Mar-23 05:57:13

Marmight
Funny isn’t it, Life after Life is probably my favourite Kate Atkinson.

Rosalyn69 Thu 02-Mar-23 06:11:53

I too don’t like books written in the present tense. A friend and I used to challenge ourselves to read the Booker shortlist. Dreadful forgettable books a lot of them. I have become more selective now. Life is too short to deal with books I don’t enjoy.

Sara1954 Thu 02-Mar-23 06:17:50

A lot of Booker winners are awful, but I always think the Booker panel are far better informed and intelligent than me, so I must be missing something.

Sparklefizz Thu 02-Mar-23 08:51:05

Sara1954

A lot of Booker winners are awful, but I always think the Booker panel are far better informed and intelligent than me, so I must be missing something.

I agree. I have given up on several of them but, as someone else posted earlier, life is too short to persevere with a book you don't find interesting/enhancing.

I have loved books all my life.... if a book doesn't resonate with me for whatever reason (could be due to what's going on in my life), then I put it aside.

I read for pleasure ... if I'm not feeling it, I find another book. Every day I give thanks for libraries smile

Sparklefizz Thu 02-Mar-23 08:54:12

PS. I didn't like Michelle Obama's book, or Cloud Atlas, or Midnight's Children, or The Lovely Bones to name a few.

muppett1 Thu 02-Mar-23 09:14:37

Some Other Rainbow by John McCarthy and Jill Morrell defeated me as did Brief History of Time by Stephen Hawkin. I tried both several times.

MerylStreep Thu 02-Mar-23 09:22:35

Anything by Donna Tartt. And I have really tried 😟

Grandmabatty Thu 02-Mar-23 09:32:47

I am a firm believer that if I've started then I will finish, to paraphrase Mastermind. Some of the titles mentioned, I would agree are difficult and turgid but I persevered. The only book so far that I was unable to finish was Ulysses by James Joyce. It hurt my brain and I've given up a number of times! Maybe I should make that my project for March.

1summer Thu 02-Mar-23 09:34:26

Nearly all my late husbands books I found very boring and never finished one of them
Catch 22 - he read this at least once a year
Lord of the Rings
The Alchemist
All of Hilary Mantels (although I enjoyed Wolf Hall on TV)
All of Philip Pullmans
Any books people say will change my life ie Where the Crawdads Sing - The Time Travellers Wife. They don’t

Sara1954 Thu 02-Mar-23 09:51:10

Grandabatty
I agree with you, I always need to get to the end if possible, and very often I’m glad I persevered.

TerriBull Thu 02-Mar-23 13:02:18

I think like Sara above the reason why I do persevere with some books is that sometimes, what initially comes across as a complete bore, once you crack the first 100 pages or so it turns into something else altogether. I found that very much with Atonement, I really didn't like it at all until 70 pages or so in, but ended up loving it once I got into the heart of it. Although I would add that's an exception, more often than not my first instincts are often right.

pandapatch Thu 02-Mar-23 13:26:20

I also gave up on Johnathan Strange and Mr Norrell and Wolf Hall. Not a big fan of Phillipa Gregory either, but Shadow of the Wind is one of my favourite books.

Doodledog Thu 02-Mar-23 13:34:53

TerriBull

I think like Sara above the reason why I do persevere with some books is that sometimes, what initially comes across as a complete bore, once you crack the first 100 pages or so it turns into something else altogether. I found that very much with Atonement, I really didn't like it at all until 70 pages or so in, but ended up loving it once I got into the heart of it. Although I would add that's an exception, more often than not my first instincts are often right.

I found that with We Need To Talk About Kevin. I was reading it for a book club meeting and struggled until the person who'd chosen it said to start later in the book as the opening was hard work. She was right. I started where she suggested and it has become one of my favourite novels. I re-read it from the beginning when I'd worked out the structure, which was what was getting in the way. It's really a very good book.

annodomini Thu 02-Mar-23 13:42:28

50 Shades of Grey, not so much for the reputed raunchy content as for the appalling writing. I abandoned the attempt after the first chapter.

Sara1954 Thu 02-Mar-23 14:51:12

Doodledog
I don’t remember finding the beginning of ‘Kevin’ to be too difficult to get into, it’s a book that shocks and horrifies, but the worst thing is that you can see how in a country with few gun laws, this could too easily happen.