Gransnet forums

Books/book club

I want a very depressing book

(136 Posts)
ochia03 Tue 30-Dec-25 11:36:42

Ive always loved reading really depressing books, since I'm a rather happy-go-lucky person, so most of the ones I read don't make me feel very sad. So that's where I employ all of you great people, to find me a book that will make me rethink why I created this post. Please and thank you smile

Fallingstar Wed 31-Dec-25 12:34:24

The Road by Cormac McCarthy
Woman at Point Zero by Nawal El Sadaawi

MollyNew Wed 31-Dec-25 12:30:04

Is Dr Zhivago the novel as depressing as the film?

Shel1951 Wed 31-Dec-25 12:27:29

The boy in the striped pyjamas....John Boyle

nadateturbe Wed 31-Dec-25 12:25:28

"But You Did Not Come Back"Marceline Loridan-Ivens .
So sad and depressing two friends couldn't finish when I lent it.

Sparklefizz Wed 31-Dec-25 12:22:12

MayBee70

Sparklefizz

Maybee70 I thought A Thousand Splendid Suns was uplifting

While I was reading it, I spent most of the time in tears. It's one of the saddest and most upsetting books I have ever read.
Perhaps it would suit OP's requirements.

I was numb at the end. Reminded me of films that I’ve been to see where I had to stay in my seat for a while after the film finished ( eg Brokeback Mountain).

But you said it was "uplifting" in your earlier post MayBee70

Marilla Wed 31-Dec-25 12:21:31

A Long, Long Way by Sebastian Barry is set in World War 1 following the life of young Willie Dunne. It is a beautifully written book and yes it is terribly sad. It is a haunting story which will stay with you.

nanna8 Wed 31-Dec-25 00:20:36

Too close to home these days, isn’t it Purplepixie?

Purplepixie Wed 31-Dec-25 00:17:07

Try reading 1984.

nanna8 Wed 31-Dec-25 00:13:55

Hamnet is coming out as a film,too. Just been and watched Nuremberg, that’s depressing but what a good actor Russell Crowe is as Göring. I get quite a few books online and if you look for psychological horror novels most are depressing. Also Thomas Hardy novels - king of the depressives !

NotSpaghetti Wed 31-Dec-25 00:02:19

Germinal by Émile Zola

merlotgran Tue 30-Dec-25 23:58:54

Hamnet and A Little Life.
I don’t know what possessed me to read them during the summer after DH died. ☹️

keepingquiet Tue 30-Dec-25 23:47:21

I agree with Shuggie Bain and The Road, but Never Let me Go wins the prize for me!

Greenfinch Tue 30-Dec-25 23:43:26

I think there is a danger of confusing sadness with depression. Some very sad books are quite uplifting while depressing books can lower your mood and increase anxiety.

Fairislecable Tue 30-Dec-25 23:30:51

The Vaster Wilds by Lauren Groff I was gripped by this book but it is unremittingly grim.

I suggested it to my book club but no one else wanted to read it!

MayBee70 Tue 30-Dec-25 19:36:41

Sparklefizz

Maybee70 I thought A Thousand Splendid Suns was uplifting

While I was reading it, I spent most of the time in tears. It's one of the saddest and most upsetting books I have ever read.
Perhaps it would suit OP's requirements.

I was numb at the end. Reminded me of films that I’ve been to see where I had to stay in my seat for a while after the film finished ( eg Brokeback Mountain).

JamesandJon33 Tue 30-Dec-25 19:26:33

The Woodlanders,by Thomas Hardy is , by no stretch of the of the imagination, cheerful. Typical Hardy

fancyflowers Tue 30-Dec-25 18:39:16

Magenta8

George Orwell's 1984 is pretty grim, especially as the world seems to be going in that direction albeit rather later than predicted.

I agree. We don't yet have thought police, but Alexa is a good stand in.

Cameras all over the place, you can't go shopping without being on camera.

Sparklefizz Tue 30-Dec-25 18:09:12

Maybee70 I thought A Thousand Splendid Suns was uplifting

While I was reading it, I spent most of the time in tears. It's one of the saddest and most upsetting books I have ever read.
Perhaps it would suit OP's requirements.

ViceVersa Tue 30-Dec-25 17:32:02

Primrose53

Try “The Death and Life of Sylvia Plath”. I’ve just started it.

She is probably my favourite writer/poet of all time.

Scribbles Tue 30-Dec-25 17:26:15

Another vote here for Angela's Ashes.

Tenko Tue 30-Dec-25 16:58:39

I also recommend ‘a little life ‘ I loved it but it’s a hard read, ditto ‘never let me go ‘
My daughter recommended’a story of a heart ‘ I started it but wasn’t in the mood, but I will give it another go.

LilyoftheValley Tue 30-Dec-25 16:52:32

Black Beauty.

Esmay Tue 30-Dec-25 16:48:35

I find Bathsheba Everdene's doomed love for Sergeant Troy in Far From The Madding Crowd very depressing.
I've read it a few times and thought the film was beautifully done and all the way through reading and watching I want to scream at her- YOU'VE PICKED THE WRONG ONE !
But then , it wouldn't be a story ,would it ?

mrsmeldrew Tue 30-Dec-25 16:32:28

Just read "Abide with Me" Elizabeth Strout. Small town America 1959. Narrow minded bigots. Although there is redemption at the end.

Whitewavemark2 Tue 30-Dec-25 16:21:58

“Love set you going like a fat gold watch”

One of my favourite poems.

Morning Song.