Gransnet forums

Books/book club

I want a very depressing book

(128 Posts)
ochia03 Tue 30-Dec-25 11:36:42

Ive always loved reading really depressing books, since I'm a rather happy-go-lucky person, so most of the ones I read don't make me feel very sad. So that's where I employ all of you great people, to find me a book that will make me rethink why I created this post. Please and thank you smile

Lollin Tue 30-Dec-25 11:43:41

Very surprised by your heading so I did a quick search and 32 came up straight away. I thought better to a
Check, which books have you read already?

Greenfinch Tue 30-Dec-25 11:45:08

Have you read Jude the Obscure by Thomas Hardy?

winterwhite Tue 30-Dec-25 12:09:31

Or Great Expectations.

Moth62 Tue 30-Dec-25 12:23:06

How about “Angela’s Ashes” by Frank McCourt? I gave up halfway through as it was soooo depressing. Should for the bill nicely, I’d have thought smile

Moth62 Tue 30-Dec-25 12:24:44

FIT not for. How I wish there was an edit button on here like there is on WhatsApp! (Or I could just read and check carefully before I send, I suppose…)

Greyduster Tue 30-Dec-25 12:28:18

“Shuggie Bain”.

Humbertbear Tue 30-Dec-25 12:33:01

To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee
More by Thomas Hardy - Tess of the Durbevilles or Mayor of Casterbridge
Dickens - Old Curiosity Shop

Grandmabatty Tue 30-Dec-25 12:33:38

Definitely Shuggie Bain. Or A Little Life. It has to be the most depressing book I have ever read

Lovemylife Tue 30-Dec-25 12:37:53

Ten Thousand Sorrows by Elizabeth Kim

ViceVersa Tue 30-Dec-25 13:06:39

Oh I loved Shuggie Bain, but I wouldn't have thought of it as depressing. Same with To Kill A Mockingbird.

midgey Tue 30-Dec-25 13:09:07

Hamnet
This is going to hurt by Adam Kay
I found both of these books incredibly bleak.

TerriBull Tue 30-Dec-25 13:13:00

Yes another who would nominate Tess of the d'Urbervilles, it doesn't get much more depressing than hanging. A public hanging left a deep impression on Thomas Hardy which inspired him to write the book allegedly. I'd also recommend both "His Bloody Project" and "Alias Grace", riveting and depressing in equal measures with brutal murders at the centre of both books. Angela's Ashes a veritable catalogue of misery with flashes of brilliant Irish humour. Joseph O'Connor another excellent Irish author his "Star of the Sea" is one of my best books ever, it takes a good 70 pages or so to get into it, set against the Irish Potato Famine. Or for a more recent Irish flavour of utter misery, Liz Nugent excels with Strange Sally Diamond and my latest one by her Skin Deep. Khalid Hosseni's "A Thousand Splendid Sons" is another unhappy but affecting read. Atonement does pretty well in the miserable stakes and again a great book. My son tells me one of the best miserable books he's read is Alexander Solzhenitsyn's "The Gulag Archipelago".

I believe "A Little Life" out miseries them all, but I haven't read it, although I know fairly happy people who have.

Good miserable reading for 2026.

SueDonim Tue 30-Dec-25 13:14:19

Angel by Elizabeth Taylor. There are no redeeming features at all!

Books by Coim Tobin and Anne Enright I’ve always found gloomy, too.

MayBee70 Tue 30-Dec-25 13:18:42

If ‘Never Let Me Go’ is anything like the film it should fit the bill….

Graphite Tue 30-Dec-25 13:33:30

Another vote for A Little Life by Hanya Yanagihara. It's a very long book and immensely sad but worth reading.

Ditto, Star of the Sea. I've just started the sequel Redemption Falls which is sounding similarly gloomy but the writing is excellent.

One that others may not be familar with and which I heard discussed on Radio 4's A Good Read is Shyness and Dignity by Dag Solstad.

TerriBull Tue 30-Dec-25 13:41:13

I forgot Demon Copperhead, unremittingly sad but brilliant. One of the best books I've read in the past couple of years.

Redption Falls is indeed gloomy Graphite I didn't enjoy it as much as Star of the Sea, in fact a bit disappointing. I read it a while ago.

Cgto2 Tue 30-Dec-25 13:53:43

The Four Winds by Kristin Hannah.
The bleakest book I’ve ever read!

JdotJ Tue 30-Dec-25 14:42:32

I found Jude the Obscure really depressing but finished it just so I could say I had !

Lathyrus3 Tue 30-Dec-25 14:54:26

The Shipping News by Annie Proulx.

Wonderful gloomy descriptions of Newfoundland and the lives of the people there.

Magenta8 Tue 30-Dec-25 15:12:58

Death at Wolf's Nick. The profoundly depressing true story of taxi driver Evelyn Foster who was set on fire and left to die.

The subsequent police investigation was marred by sexism and incompetence.

TerriBull Tue 30-Dec-25 15:17:03

Cgto2

The Four Winds by Kristin Hannah.
The bleakest book I’ve ever read!

The Four Winds is a very bleak account of the dust bowl farmers, I didn't think it could get any bleaker until I read The Grapes of Wrath, which I imagine inspired Kristin Hannah's version. John Steinbeck lived through those times, so more of a horse's mouth account. Both are very good and very miserable.

Grandmabatty Tue 30-Dec-25 15:18:43

I loved The Shipping News! It isn't unremittingly depressing though. Beautifully written

BrandyGran Tue 30-Dec-25 15:19:24

The most wonderful book ever written in my opinion is Anna Karenina . I like a story about human relationships and this is chock full. My son says it’s like an episode of Eastenders!
Most people think oh that’s too high brow and difficult but it really isn’t. Give it a try and I guarantee you will at times be depressed.

BrandyGran Tue 30-Dec-25 15:27:20

By Leo Tolstoy