Gransnet forums

Chat

How long is your nose?

(82 Posts)
absent Fri 05-Apr-13 07:58:27

Is it ever right to lie? Is there such a thing as a white lie? Is it okay if nobody is hurt as a result of your lie?

Is right to be completely truthful if somebody is hurt or seriously harmed as a result? Do you have to tell the truth to people you don't like?

I have a strong commitment to telling the truth but I don't think it is always a straightforward choice between truth good/lie bad and can be something of a moral minefield.

Butty Fri 05-Apr-13 10:48:08

Glass - Thanks for posting that quote.

Galen Fri 05-Apr-13 10:44:29

Actually it's coffee!

Greatnan Fri 05-Apr-13 10:43:54

At this time of the morning? Really!!!!

Movedalot Fri 05-Apr-13 10:41:38

Have another wine until you do grin

Galen Fri 05-Apr-13 10:38:36

I suspect I'm going to need counselling if I hope to recover!

Movedalot Fri 05-Apr-13 10:31:55

Galen I am so sorry you have been traumatised in this thoughtless way, go and have a little wine and look at the cruise brochures.

Greatnan Fri 05-Apr-13 10:17:42

Get over what? I simply pointed out how impossible it would be for anyone to change their forum name without it becoming obvious
I have already said that I think anybody wishing to do so would be perfectly entitled to keep quiet about it
I thought I was being conciliatory!

j08 Fri 05-Apr-13 10:15:55

Galen grin

Galen Fri 05-Apr-13 10:14:55

What do you mean? There is no Father Christmas?
You'll be saying that babies aren't found under gooseberry bushes next!angry
( stomps off muttering under breath about tooth fairies being upset!)

j08 Fri 05-Apr-13 10:14:02

I used to believe that something bad would happen to me if I told a lie. I still find it a bit hard to do. Though I am definitely getting over that now. Needs must occasionally.

Movedalot Fri 05-Apr-13 10:12:42

OK, whatever you say! Strange all the coincidences and all the stuff you think you know about me. I am sure the gransnetters who bother about what you say will know the truth. As the young would say '^wha'ever, get over it^

Greatnan Fri 05-Apr-13 10:11:53

Movedalot - of course if you say you don't tell lies we must all believe you. If somebody changed their forum name, they would have to be very clever to change their style of writing, location, interests, etc. I know I couldn't do it.

absent Fri 05-Apr-13 10:04:43

Movedalot No it doesn't; it's a thread I have been meaning to start for several days apropos of something else all together (not related to Gransnet). Your concern that I am somehow obsessed with your posts is becoming worrying.

Movedalot Fri 05-Apr-13 10:01:11

This quite clearly stems from what I said on another thread so just for anyone who didn't see it - I don't tell lies! Happy to admit it. Why would I? As probably the least devious person you could ever meet I would soon be found out so there would be no point and I wouldn't be able to face myself, which is the most important thing.

There are ways to avoid hurting someone without telling a lie. When my son's fiancee rang her parents and wanted to speak to her mother, who was actually at our house (a different country) her father was not prepared to lie so just said 'she is on a mission'. Knowing her mother she just assumed she was helping someone. He didn't lie, he avoided telling the truth. The surprise was kept and the truth was told.

This is the trust which has kept our family so close and our marriage together for 45 years.

annodomini Fri 05-Apr-13 09:58:41

My mother, when she suspected I was lying, used to say, 'Look me straight in the eye.' I was very good at that, so I was usually able to detect a lie in either of my own two DSs and nowadays in my GCs. The youngest looks at me gravely and nods his head very convincingly - I don't think.

kittylester Fri 05-Apr-13 09:27:18

We always told our children that we would never know whether to believe them or not if we once caught them lying. It worked to some degree grin

In answer to your question absent, my nose is quite mobile depending on the circumstances. sunshine

Bags Fri 05-Apr-13 09:24:39

Thanks for the quote, glass. Sums up my view.

Bags Fri 05-Apr-13 09:23:45

For me, that's the best anti-lie thing there is – wondering whether you can be trusted again if you have been found out being untruthful. If you want to be trusted, it's a good thing to bear in mind. Compared to whether I will be trust again, which is important to me, whether something is right or wrong is hardly relevant. But trust is usually based on truthfulness and honesty.

janeainsworth Fri 05-Apr-13 09:12:19

Gillybob I love your Grandma's quote smile
And Glass absolutely - once trust has broken down, it is hard to restore.

glassortwo Fri 05-Apr-13 09:04:55

“I'm not upset that you lied to me, I'm upset that from now on I can't believe you.”
― Friedrich Nietzsche

It was instilled in me from as early as I can remember that to lie was the worst thing you could do, and you can read it in my face when I tell even a little white lie, but sometimes you need to soften the truth but it does not sit easy with me.

petallus Fri 05-Apr-13 08:55:17

I wonder if it's time i got over it grin

petallus Fri 05-Apr-13 08:54:21

I remember feeling very betrayed when, as a child, i finally discovered that my parents had been lying about FC. I had believed them instead of school friends who assured me he did not exist.

moomin Fri 05-Apr-13 08:46:59

Good grief absent that's a bit OTT shock My children loved to believe in Father Christmas and the Tooth Fairy way beyond the time when I'm sure they didn't (especially when I was caught out with a red sleeping bag over my head sneaking the pressies into my DDs bedroom!) as it was in their interests to carry on "believing".

However, I think there is a need for so called white lies in circumstances where people could be hurt by the truth. I try to tell the truth when confronted with a situation, but sometimes it is better to either say nowt or be diplomatic with the truth.

gillybob Fri 05-Apr-13 08:43:36

My grandmas saying when we were listening into adult conversations was

Nosy couldn't come so he sent Gilly

I say it to my own grandchildren now!

A bit of the thread sorry. smile

gillybob Fri 05-Apr-13 08:40:48

I agree Absent we all tell "white lies" don't we? Surely to tell a lie in order to protect someone's feelings is not a lie in the true sense of the word but merely a miss truth which is not the same things at all.