Gransnet forums

Chat

Mourning period - out of fashion to mark it

(37 Posts)
Grannyknot Mon 06-May-13 12:24:27

We were watching the new Skandi thriller last night (Arne Dahl, we do like it) and one of the characters who has lost her husband wears a 'mourning ribbon'. When a colleague comments on it, she replies "XXX wanted me to wear one so that people would know how I feel".

Got me thinking about my lovely gran, her and my granddad were so in love until the day he died. They would call each other 'Sweetheart' which would make us giggle when we were kids. After my grandpa died suddenly of a heart attack (way back in the 60s I was a young teenager) - my gran dressed all in black for a certain period of time (six months I think) and then gradually in lighter colours but still grey or black and white; until eventually she was back in her normal clothes, after about a year if I remember correctly.

Publicly making a statement about being in mourning seems to have gone out of fashion now for every day folk, (unless of course runners or sportsmen wear a black band to mark a tragedy) - but it had never occurred to me that it had a purpose other than to constantly remind the person who had lost someone that they were sad, which seems negative. Now I'm thinking that there is merit or value in other people knowing that you are in mourning for a loss of a loved one.

My gran was very dignified in her loss and in her mourning clothes. But she didn't revel in it, if that makes sense. I know it can be taken too far too.

HappyNanna Mon 06-May-13 12:35:28

Reading this reminded me of an incident from my childhood. I was in a ladies dress shop (the old-fashioned variety, not like they are today) with my mum when two ladies came in and one of them asked about a grey dress. The shop assistant obviously hadn't got anything in grey so started showing her some others. The lady said 'no they won't do, I'm in second mourning'. Obviously I hadn't a clue what she was talking about and my mum explained later. We didn't observe the tradition in our family though.

yogagran Mon 06-May-13 13:25:40

Wearing a black armband as a public display of mourning used to be a very common sight but I'm not sure that I could do it.

Absolutely nothing against it mind you, just not sure if I manage it hmm

dorsetpennt Mon 06-May-13 13:42:42

People don't even wear black at funerals these days - I know sometimes it's requested not to, but if not people still don't. I remember wearing black arm bands, people used to close their curtains when the hearse arrived at the house - that often doesn't happen either - the hearse coming to the house first. In Jewish homes the mirrors are also covered up. I think funerals and periods of mourning are done with as quickly as possible, people these days have a weird attitude towards death - don't like to think or dwell upon it - mourning properly helps you to come to terms with your loss.

Galen Mon 06-May-13 14:24:54

I remember when my gran died. I went into a dress shop to get a black dress, the assistant replied ' I'm sorry madam we don't have any as it isn't the season for mourning!' confused

baubles Mon 06-May-13 15:48:41

In Ireland it used to be black then purple, I'm not sure of the timescale but I know my grandmother's generation would dye the clothes they already had.

Galen Mon 06-May-13 15:50:31

How would you dye black to purple?

numberplease Mon 06-May-13 16:02:00

I have a black skirt and cardigan that I wear for funerals, if I need a coat it has to be the darkest one I have, too expensive to buy all black in one go. I remember closing all the curtains until a funeral is over. What bothers me a lot is seeing everyone so upset at the actual funeral, then at the "do" afterwards it`s completely different, everyone eating and drinking and having a high old time!

Bags Mon 06-May-13 16:14:17

I think it is traditional for the 'wake' to be jolly as a celebration of the dead person's life. At my father's 'wake' there were people who had known him when he was a child and a young man but who hadn't seen each other for many years. Naturally they exchanged happy stories about the past which was great for my siblings and me, and probably for my mum too, after the solemnity of the funeral.

As for mourning fashion, is there anything to stop people doing the Victorian thing if they wish to? The thing is though, lots of people who aren't in mourning wear black or purple. And what if you don't want people to know you are in mourning? I think it's possible to do one's mourning without making a show of it, and some people might prefer that.

I love the fact that there is more freedom in social customs nowadays. I think that is a healthy sign.

There are different cultural traditions to take into account nowadays too. We aren't all from the same background.

Galen Mon 06-May-13 16:53:41

The day of DH funeral was hot like today it was the 30may 2003. We had loads of wine and tea in the garden with a buffet and at about 9pm we sent DS out for fish and chips. My brother when he returned home to Scotland told everyone it was more like a garden party!

Nonu Mon 06-May-13 17:02:49

Galen , that is good , your DH would have approved .

Whatever floats your boat . smile

LullyDully Mon 06-May-13 17:36:07

I didn't go to a funeral until I was 21, my mother didn't think children should go to them. I had a real fear of them , I think because of the hush hush approach to death.

I do believe people are far more open today and children are included, helping with their understanding.

My mother had a terror of death whilst my father had a more pragmatic, common sense approach. When he was terminally ill at 92 he brought up the subject of mercy killing with everyone in a uniform to no avail.

Stansgran Mon 06-May-13 17:53:26

I seem to be aware of funerals much more these days three so far this year and I seem to have an all purpose uniform for t hem. Few people can buy clothes especially for a funeral these days but I do remember as a teenager trying to buy a red jumper after my father died to cheer myself up and just couldn't bring myself to wear it .i do remember a shop full of black hats on the rue de Rivoli in Paris specifically for mourning- this was in the sixties.

baubles Mon 06-May-13 20:10:05

Galen Mon 06-May-13 15:50:31
How would you dye black to purple?

I'm not sure, perhaps they had a couple of black outfits and a couple of purple ones. I daresay there would have been a bit of lending and borrowing amongst the family.

Deedaa Mon 06-May-13 20:22:31

I remember years ago seeing some dresses in Worthing Museum. They were the trousseau for a victorian vicar's wife and were all dark grey or purple - the only colours he thought were suitable for her station! Heaven knows what she would have been expected to wear as mourning, black would hardly seem sufficient!

I did go to a wonderful funeral back in the 80's. The lady, who had sadly died very young, wanted everyone to wear their brightest clothes and I remember her husband wore the purple trousers and red velvet jacket that were her favourites.

annodomini Mon 06-May-13 20:24:14

You'd lighten it first with a product sold by Dylon and then use one of their dyes. Unless the garment was synthetic - then the best course would be to buy a new one.

Galen Mon 06-May-13 20:25:30

Don't think I'd bother.

Grannyknot Mon 06-May-13 21:38:36

bags I understand that people can do their mourning without making a show of it, and clearly many do. I also realise that there are many different cultural traditions. I'm a real believer in live and let live.

The point I was making was that I understood for the first time (believe it or not) why someone might want to signal to the world that they are in mourning, as opposed to wearing black to reflect their own sorrow. There is nothing stopping people doing the Victorian thing (is that where it stems from?) but for some reason, you don't see much of that around nowadays.

Stansgran Mon 06-May-13 21:46:55

I have letters with black borders obviously treasured by my grandmother announcing family deaths. In a way they were right to acknowledge grief as a real thing. Now we push it under the carpet or medicalise it.

ps Mon 06-May-13 22:11:48

Grannyknot I make a point of wearing an article of clothing to reflect the passing of someone dear to me. I do it out of repect and rememberance for the departed and have no problem in others knowing that I consider myself to have sufferred a loss. I do believe however that the days of mourning are being lost to all but immediate family.
As an aside may I add that I find the thrillers on BBC4 by Arne Dahl far superior to any other productions on TV whether they be crime or political thrillers. Unmissable in my book and the highlight of my Saturday nights.

Galen Mon 06-May-13 22:15:30

I wear black to funerals (habit) but not after. The day after dh's funeral I think I wore a flowered dress.

Grannyknot Mon 06-May-13 22:46:13

Wikipedia is interesting on the custom of mourning... once again thanks to GNetters making me think, I am learning something new smile

"The custom of wearing unadorned black clothing for mourning dates back at least to the Roman Empire, when the toga pulla, made of dark-colored wool, was worn during periods of mourning".

Bags Tue 07-May-13 05:58:38

Only male Roman citizens (so not women and not the slaves or servants) wore the toga so the custom didn't apply to everyone. Ditto here ehrn mourning clothes became common place, which I had laways understood (could be wrong) to be during Victorian times: only the relatively well off could afford to but new stuff for mourning. Ordinary people just had to wear what they had already, as they did for everything. If you've only got one "best", you tend to keep it for Sundays, weddings and funerals.

(Relatively is the significant word.)

Bags Tue 07-May-13 05:59:03

ehm???

when

Bags Tue 07-May-13 05:59:47

to buy! and always!

fingers not awake yet, obviously! wink