Gransnet forums

Chat

Are our views always entrenched?

(513 Posts)
Greatnan Wed 19-Jun-13 09:51:57

Somebody said to me recently that she thought people's views on such matters as politics and religion were so entrenched by a certain age that nothing would change them.
Well, I have had my own views on religion very much modified by a certain member of Gransnet, who has answered all the questions I have wanted to ask for years, with infinite patience, kindness and warmth, never taking offence.
No, Gransnet is not my Road to Damascus - I will always be an atheist and she certainly has not tried to convert me. What she has done is show me how much her church means to her and some of the good it is doing throughout the world. Oh, she agrees that there is much that needs changing, but she explains that it is like having a family member that does things you don't like, but you still love them. Change is taking place at grass roots level and she hopes it will filter up to the men at the top (yes, they are all men!).
When she first joined GN, I would never have envisaged that we could become such close friends and I thank her for not giving up on me!

granjura Sat 22-Jun-13 22:48:52

Of course I didn't Anna. Don't worry about me - maybe it is because their views are entrenched? But thanks smile and thanks to all who have sent me pms but just were too worried about posting openly.

Ana Sat 22-Jun-13 22:37:38

I don't believe for one minute that granjura was being serious about sending families out to sea, gracesmum. Why is everyone giving her such a hard time? hmm

granjura Sat 22-Jun-13 22:32:02

Conclusion, yes, people from the very left and the very right do have entrenched views. Some but perhaps few are trying to look beyond the divisive left and right- and try to find ways to go forwards, irrespective f entrenched politics. Because at the end of the day (I know - annoying expression) - that is the only way to go. The UK will either work together and attempt to close the huge divide - or sink. I am full of hope, as I have grand-children growing up there, so it matters hugely to me. Bonne chance UK.

gracesmum Sat 22-Jun-13 22:28:25

Which makes me think that all of what could be said, has been said.hmm

Ana Sat 22-Jun-13 22:26:03

granjura smile

granjura Sat 22-Jun-13 22:09:02

Maybe families living in bedsits could be put on boats at sea, like those private prisons - and join you lot smile

gracesmum Sat 22-Jun-13 21:40:33

grin

Elegran Sat 22-Jun-13 21:30:18

ah!! Just seen the double entendre, Gracesmum Not intended, I assure you. These crabs are crustaceans, though only metaphorical ones. Wondered why you were blushing over rowing.

glassortwo Sat 22-Jun-13 21:19:39

Well I bailed out ages ago!

Elegran Sat 22-Jun-13 21:17:41

Rowing term, Gracesmum for when the oar does not dip deep enough into the water and does not do any work, just makes a lot of splashing, and quite often the rower then falls over backwards off the seat because they are pulling against no resistance. I suppose it is catching a crab because all the splashing is like a crab escaping and flailing around as it hits the water - who knows?

gracesmum Sat 22-Jun-13 21:13:20

Crabs???blush

annodomini Sat 22-Jun-13 21:00:53

Bon voyage, Elegran and Bags and anyone else who managed to scramble aboard. I baled out some time ago. See you when you reach safe haven!

Elegran Sat 22-Jun-13 20:46:26

Welcome aboard! I take it you don't mind taking an oar? This lifeboat is heavy laden and we need to get under way soon, before the storms return.

Butty Stop giggling and get behind that oar. Now all row together .. in ....out.....KEEP TOGETHER AND STOP CATCHING CRABS.

Bags Sat 22-Jun-13 20:41:05

wink

Butty Sat 22-Jun-13 20:36:11

Elegran and B - You've both given me a fit of the giggles. grin

Bags Sat 22-Jun-13 20:32:57

Nicely secured around my middle, thanks, elegran. Haul away!

granjura Sat 22-Jun-13 20:24:22

OR families ?

Elegran Sat 22-Jun-13 20:21:50

Don't drop it.

There is a long line attached, so you can be hauled back to the lifeboat if you drift too far. The whistle is good and loud, blow it if you need a helicopter rescue.

Bags Sat 22-Jun-13 20:18:37

Chuck a lifebelt over here, would you, elegran.

Thanks so much!

granjura Sat 22-Jun-13 20:13:24

Moved, no idea what was in your post and why it was deleted. I've been out having supper with friends and was hoping to find a reply to my question, which was is it better to build/renovate flats in towns as wisely proposed, for older and younger people, and for families. But sadly nobody has replied.

Second homes are privately owned and paid for by the buyer, and therefore has nothing to do with this equation. What someone is alluding to, I think, is that we have a small flat in the UK, for when we come and visit friends, grandchildren and family, and in case we ever get too old to live out in the sticks in the old house here- and that is, I am afraid nobody's business. Tax payers are not asked to contribute, are they? I totally refuse to feel embarrassed or ashamed about this, really.

We do not live in Switzerland because it is a tax haven for certain expats - only very rich ones get a tax deal, and certainly not in our County- which is one of the highest tax area in CH, because 50% of the population has some kind of benefit or other due to low wages. A huge difference I think to coming to live here to be near my parents and look after them, in my birthplace - to intentionally moving to a tax haven for the very purpose of not paying tax in UK. Or is it just me who thinks there is a big difference. Certainly no Champagne parties here, I can assure you- but plenty of community use of our old Vicarage by all, young and old. Wonderful.

Elegran Sat 22-Jun-13 18:46:32

Lifebelts for all, Greatnan, unless passengers push one another into the shark-infested water while fighting to be the first to grab one.

Greatnan Sat 22-Jun-13 18:39:54

Is there room in the lifeboat for me - I can't stand any more either.

I started this thread hoping for a genuine debate,as I have had about religion, but it was hijacked for personal reasons.

Bags Sat 22-Jun-13 18:39:03

Don't worry, elegran, the thread has moved on. I expect lily and I will politely agree to differ, as usual wink

Bags Sat 22-Jun-13 18:37:59

I think there is an important difference between saying an idea is silly and saying a person is silly. It's quite possible for an intelligent person to entertain silly ideas. I know I have at times, and I've been glad to be better informed. There's a skill in saying an idea is silly without upsetting someone, of course, but it can be done. (Not saying I'm particularly good at it but I do try to attack ideas rather than people).

Elegran Sat 22-Jun-13 18:33:39

Knowing when to retire from the lists and let the principals get on with it is a life-saving ability Bags Keeping the peace can only be done for a while, then the bystanders save their own skins and let the combatants continue with the real quarrels. I have baled out, suggest you do too.