Gransnet forums

Chat

Do you belong to any other forums?

(244 Posts)
kittylester Mon 16-Sept-13 07:17:54

And, if you do, can you recommend any or do they all end up as bad tempered battles for supremacy and the moral high ground? sad

Having been a member of gn since early on, I am really unhappy about the vitriol often unleashed on here. The odd spat is understandable but GN seems to have a large number of, mostly new posters, who delight in creating discord.

So, can anyone recommend any general forums like GN used to be.

Aka Tue 17-Sept-13 20:50:03

Have to disagree Absent a yawn emoticon could really cause offence. I'm sure it's better simply to answer briefly as Anniebach did politely pointing out the pompous truisms?

gracesmum Tue 17-Sept-13 21:34:08

"Pompous truisms" (not that anybody is being judgemental understand) and "politely" in the same sentence ....hmm

bluebell Tue 17-Sept-13 22:23:00

Grace grin

Ana Tue 17-Sept-13 22:26:33

'pointing out' is the crucial bit of the sentence, surely gracesmum?

gracesmum Tue 17-Sept-13 22:34:52

Trust me to pick out the wrong/irrelevant words [duh] emoticon

Aka Tue 17-Sept-13 22:42:44

Not a matter of judgement when someone is stating the obvious though pomposity is perhaps open to a subjective judgement. However Grace I like the way that you managed to make you point with a touch of humour smile

Aka Tue 17-Sept-13 22:43:40

That was in reply to your 21:34:08 post

Aka Tue 17-Sept-13 22:44:23

All my words were considered and relevant! grin

absent Wed 18-Sept-13 01:51:21

Well if that's the case Aka, I'll just have to copy jing's example and use @boring. grin I think this is one of the most boring threads ever seen on Gransnet – and there have been some in the last nearly two and half years!

gracesmum Wed 18-Sept-13 07:51:19

I feel sad for Kittyl however whose original question expressed a level of frustration subsequently seen to be entirely justified.

j08 Wed 18-Sept-13 07:58:21

I think it's one of the funniest threads. Everyone talking at cross purposes. grin

j08 Wed 18-Sept-13 08:02:53

It's got loads better since Annieb joined in. smile

baubles Wed 18-Sept-13 08:13:11

In answer to your question kitty, I don't belong to any other forum.

Because I don't have a lot of free time to spend on here I tend not to get involved in any of the more serious topics, which can be quite fast moving.

I just haven't been able to make sense of this one at all!

baubles Wed 18-Sept-13 08:16:51

The second I pressed 'post' I realised that my assertion that I don't belong to any other forum is a nonsense. I'm a member of Mumsnet but tend to think of it and GNet as branches of the same thing.

Some Mumsnet threads can descend into bickering fairly quickly, the AIBU topic is a hoot at times. grin. There is lots of kindness and support when needed though, just like here.

thatbags Wed 18-Sept-13 08:21:36

Yes, baubles, DD told me about a hilarious thread on MN when someone told the story about a nosy MiLsnooping in private things while babysitting. The hilarity was caused by the suggestions of booby traps to ascertain the snooping once and for all and to stop it by clever strategems. It worked.

The plan used was to leave papers about house-selling and emigrating in a drawer the woman thought her MiL pried in and then pretend to know nothing about it (actually the husband didn't). It was brilliantly done.

Wish I could find the thread.

shysal Wed 18-Sept-13 08:33:00

A friend of mine used to booby-trap her oven with loose tins, knowing that her MIL would check for cleanliness.

Greatnan Wed 18-Sept-13 08:50:55

My own MIL didn't even try to hide her snooping and caustic comments. It was worth getting divorced just to get rid of her!

Ariadne Wed 18-Sept-13 09:35:13

I belonged to a forum on a breast cancer website, and, at the time, it was brilliant. You could join whatever thread you liked, but there were threads on each stage, so if, for example, you were in the middle of chemo, you could go on there and ask daft but worrying questions, and talk to people who were going through it or had been through it. It was so comforting, and I "met" so many brave people.

Aka Wed 18-Sept-13 10:37:13

Yes Anniebach a welcome breath of fresh (Welsh) air to replace some of the fusty hot air currently circulating in GN [wind emoticon]

lynne Wed 18-Sept-13 10:46:33

Kitty...I've been a member of GN since day one but now don't enjoy it so much....changed a lot...but agree with ariadne support is there when you need it

j08 Wed 18-Sept-13 10:58:35

Well, the answer could be, post and try to change it.

grumppa Wed 18-Sept-13 11:01:51

Just caught up with this thread.

No Gracesmum, I am not aware of any prejudice against men who contribute to the threads, though I am a little surprised at Greatnan’s comment about men that “the bar and banter threads seem to be their natural home”.

And in answer to the OP, I only belong to one other forum, relating to one dead author of children’s books. Not much scope for friction there!

overthehill Wed 18-Sept-13 11:09:40

I am not particularly sensitive and quite like contentious issues.

I used to post on Healthy Pages but found it was full of new age hippies who wanted to do lots of back slapping and hated it when anyone should criticize their point of view. I went on there because I am interested in alternative medicine but that was only a very small part.

Anyway, the other forum I like along with someone else here, is Moneysavingexpert.com. Lots of tips and a more gunge ho approach to discussions.

I like this forum, again for advice and camaraderie between us grandparents.

Greatnan Wed 18-Sept-13 11:15:19

Grumppa - my comment was not meant to be any reflection on our male members - just a statement of fact that those threads seem to be the ones they enjoy most.

Aka Wed 18-Sept-13 11:24:16

I like the sound of that OTH might give it a try myself.