Gransnet forums

Chat

Has anyone done Jury service and how did you find it?

(108 Posts)
Judy54 Thu 12-Nov-20 14:28:18

I have been called five times and served on four occasions having been excused once when my Mother was very ill. It was an interesting experience and I am glad that I was able to do it. Apparently people are contacted at random with their names being taken from the electoral roll. They must have liked my name to call me five times! My Partner has never been called and would have liked to do it. The age range has changed from 18 to 70 years to 18 to 76 years so we could both still be called. Unfortunately due to ongoing health problems my Partner would be unable to serve. Have you served on a Jury and what was it like for you, if you have not would you like to do so?

Kate1949 Thu 12-Nov-20 14:30:45

I did it two years ago. I hated every minute of it. I hope I don't get called again. My husband has never been called and would love to do it.

ayse Thu 12-Nov-20 14:37:41

I did it 18 months ago and found it very interesting but difficult. I still wonder sometimes if I made the right decision but on the available evidence .....

I’d certainly do it again if called. Old fashioned I know but it’s a civic duty. Where would we be without it?

Purpledaffodil Thu 12-Nov-20 14:39:15

I did it once ten years ago and was called again shortly afterwards so was excused. It is very interesting to see how the courts and juries work. My main case was one of anal rape and made harrowing listening. But after our guilty verdict we were told defendant had done this several times before and got away with it. So worthwhile.

DiscoDancer1975 Thu 12-Nov-20 15:08:23

I’d love to do it. My son was called when he was 18! The rest of us never have.

Liz46 Thu 12-Nov-20 15:16:16

If any of you get called, learn a little about drugs before you go. I was woefully ignorant in the jury room and wished I had asked our (policeman) neighbour for a lesson.

kittylester Thu 12-Nov-20 15:18:43

I used to volunteer for The Witness Service at both the Magistrates and Crown Courts. I loved it and would have liked to do jury service.

Kate1949 Thu 12-Nov-20 15:24:42

I suppose it depends on what type of case(s) you get. Mine were not too bad. There was a lady I was chatting to at the start who was thrilled to have been called. She was put on a horrendous case and looked shell shocked at the end.

Whitewavemark2 Thu 12-Nov-20 15:26:19

No because I was a government worker and was always taken off.

I always fancied it, but on the other hand some cases must be extraordinarily distressing.

Elusivebutterfly Thu 12-Nov-20 15:33:50

I did it in the 70s when I was young and enjoyed it. It was a drug smuggling case at the Old Bailey involving a lot of people, hence it lasted nearly three months. It was also lucrative back then as they paid fares and lunches, which I would have paid myself when at work. People I know who served later got much less.
The length of the case meant I got a paper exempting me for life, though I can go again if I choose. I didn't know the age had gone up to 76. I think that's too old to travel and spend a whole day concentrating on important facts.

Luckygirl Thu 12-Nov-20 15:34:55

I was in the same situation Whitewavemark2 so I never did get to be a juror. I suppose it could still happen.

I used to take groups of college students into court as part of their course, and I always felt I would not want to be on the jury.

fevertree Thu 12-Nov-20 15:38:04

I've done jury duty and enjoyed the experience. I took my knitting for the times we waited to be actually called for a case, we heard 3 cases during the fortnight.

The most frustrating thing was how thick (sorry) some of my fellow jurors were, one couldn't tell the difference between facts or evidence and 'gut feelings'. It actually made me fear for the safety of the system.

Alegrias2 Thu 12-Nov-20 15:41:33

I did Jury Duty in 2019. It was interesting to find out how everything works and I was glad to see how seriously all of the jurors took the responsibility.

I had been worried that I would see or hear something I wouldn't be able to forget, but luckily that didn't happen. The case did involve a young man suffering life changing injuries and that was hard to see. At the end we were all told we wouldn't be called again for at least 5 years.

When the trial ended I decided to treat myself to a nice coffee and a cake at a nearby café. I came face to face there with the prosecution lawyer. We just smiled at each other and carried on!

mrswoo Thu 12-Nov-20 15:42:29

I was living in a small town in the west of Scotland when I was called up for Jury Service. Initially about 40 people were called - we were then told the name of the accused and advised to leave the court if he was known to any of the would-be jurors. At this point the majority of people got up and left! The accused was,as they say, a well kent face”. I had not lived in the town long enough to know him - so ended up on the jury.
I have to say, I hated it and the highlight of the three days that the trial ran was being taken to a local hotel for lunch.

tanith Thu 12-Nov-20 15:47:09

I did it a few years ago, I was bored most of the time sitting in the large room waiting to be called, one 2 day trial and sent home early most days.

Riverwalk Thu 12-Nov-20 16:14:45

I did it around 1982 at the Old Bailey!

I found it all very interesting.

ginny Thu 12-Nov-20 16:28:51

I was called about 20 years ago. I was due to start a new job on the first day of duty .I was let off and can’t say I was sorry. Never been called again.

My Dad did it and enjoyed the experience.

My Sister in Law need up on a jury for a murder case and absolutely hated it.

So I guess it depends on the cases you get.

My eldest daughter has been called to start in a couple of weeks and thinks it might be interesting but hopes she doesn’t get anything grisly.

Witzend Thu 12-Nov-20 23:00:02

I did it a few years ago, found it very interesting. Our longer case was one of historic sexual abuse so I was dismayed at first, wondering how on earth we could tell, when it was one person’s word against the other,
And allegedly happened years ago.
But it did become clearer to most of us - 10 to 12 - the other 2 had made up their minds from the word go.
I was impressed by our judge telling us that if we had the slightest doubt of guilt, we must return a not guilty verdict. Although that means that the guilty will sometimes go free, at least it lessens the likelihood of a wrongful conviction.

BlueSky Thu 12-Nov-20 23:38:09

Kate1949

I did it two years ago. I hated every minute of it. I hope I don't get called again. My husband has never been called and would love to do it.

Same here Kate I was horrified at being called. Hopefully I won’t be called again.

grannyactivist Fri 13-Nov-20 01:55:01

I did jury service a few years ago. I hated the fact that the jury were eventually swayed by one voice who dominated the ‘discussion’ and basically held the view that as the event had not been impartially observed it could never be proven ‘beyond a reasonable doubt’. Eleven jurors completely disregarded the physical evidence (including DNA). Can you guess whose was the dissenting voice? The judge eventually agreed to accept a majority verdict. I fervently hope the other jurors looked the defendant up online after the trial, as I did, and hope that what they found pricked their consciences.

I felt devastated for all the witnesses for the prosecution who must have believed that their combined evidence would lead to a successful prosecution. The victim was distraught.

heath480 Fri 13-Nov-20 02:24:26

I have done it and was called to do it again earlier this year,I am 72 and was excused because my hearing is not good,I have hearing aids now though.

I hated it,it was a long journey for me and involved a lot of sitting around.

I hope I don’t get called again,I also think 76 is to old,

tiredoldwoman Fri 13-Nov-20 04:38:40

Yes, I got called about 4 years ago . I had to go for 3 days, phoning a number each evening to hear if I was needed again . On only one of those days was I actually in the jury , both minor , almost comical cases , that I found to be a complete waste of the tax payers money .
I had to take time off work , which caused problems then bus into the next town never knowing when I'd be home .
On the day I was actually in the jury we had to leave via a secret back door to avoid the guilty party's family waiting outside .
The police presence outside the court was frightening so I 'm hoping never to be called again !

MrsThreadgoode Fri 13-Nov-20 07:36:50

I did it about 30 years ago and again in 2018, quite an interesting case, all ok except one youngish juror, who, as soon as we left the Courtroom was on his mobile phone, even in the jury waiting room, when we had to go and decide Guilty or not, this Juror said that the defendant was innocent and then admitted that he wasn’t really paying attention during the week long trial and we had to go through the whole case with him to get him to be able decide.
IMO if people don’t want to do it, there are plenty of people who do and will pay attention when they are there and will make a decision based on what they have seen and heard.
Why force people to do it if they have absolutely no interest and just want to get out of there?
In the end the defendant was found guilty and we found that he had a string of other cases against him and after our case he was due for sentencing for all of them. So I enjoyed it, but I don’t really want to do it again.

Lilypops Fri 13-Nov-20 08:28:58

I have done it twice now and I really enjoyed it , I loved watching the barristers work and question the accused, a lot of acting and adjusting of the wigs , am sure they must get itchy heads ! But very interesting and a nice change ,
Neither times were the cases upsetting thankfully , one was drugs and one was theft,
The only bit that grated was when the jury went in to the room to decide if the defendant was guilt or not , There was always one voice who dominated and would shout everyone else down. , but I wouldn’t have missed it and would do it again ,

Humbertbear Fri 13-Nov-20 08:39:24

I served on the jury at the Old Bailey on a three week case back in the early 90s. The case involved a dispute between members of a large family of travellers. I could never quite understand why the case came to court as there were no eye witnesses, no forensics and the police declined to turn up and give evidence. Needless to say we found all 8 defendants not guilty of multiple charges, even though we thought there was some truth in the matter, and it was all a great waste of public money.
I was a teacher at the time and I felt that the administrators needed to develop a greater understanding of the world of work. One day we adjourned at 1.00pm and we were told we could go to work for the afternoon. Ie the court wouldn’t pay us. It took me a long time to convince the powers that be that by the time I got back to school the afternoon would be over and that the school wouldn’t pay me because they had had to pay a supply teacher.
Bearing in mind the comments of some other contributors, you meet a wide variety of people on a jury and, like being in hospital, you have to regard it as a sociological experience.