Gransnet forums

Chat

Do you have a song (songs) you can’t stand ? *Title edited by GNHQ*

(160 Posts)
Lucca Tue 24-Nov-20 18:58:00

I can’t bear “Cry me a river “

pollyperkins Thu 26-Nov-20 08:34:06

Well I either like or feel neutral about most of the songs mentioned. The only ones I agree with are Fairy tale on New York and hallelujah.
I dislike very maudlin sentimental songs especially sung in a poppy way with an American accent but can’t think of any examples. Oh yes, the song on the current John Lewis ad.

MissAdventure Thu 26-Nov-20 09:43:54

Seasons in the sun by Terry Jacks.

MattJo Thu 26-Nov-20 11:47:28

I'm with joannap on We'll meet again. Also can't stand Hallelujah - too many awful screechy, warbly versions trying to sound soulful.

Callistemon Thu 26-Nov-20 11:51:40

Every time you go away
You take a piece of me with you

Which always reminds me of the DC discussing body parts and which bit she'd taken that time.

Callistemon Thu 26-Nov-20 11:52:47

Oh yes, the song on the current John Lewis ad.
It's awful, isn't it, pollyperkins.
But I think we'll be outnumbered.

MayBee70 Thu 26-Nov-20 11:54:13

Have I the Right by The Honeycombs. It was a hit record at a time when my mum and dad took me on holiday. It was the first holiday we’d had for a long time as we were really poor and I got it in my head that I must be seriously ill with something and they’d taken me on what would be m last ever holiday. Yes, even at the age of 20 I was a hypochondriac. It was only a caravan in Evesham: not even the seaside. The song totally depresses me!

Callistemon Thu 26-Nov-20 11:54:51

(I agree Elton John is overrated too)!

Nooooo!

Rosieroe Thu 26-Nov-20 12:02:16

Remember Harry Nilsson ‘I can’t live if living is without you’? I loathe that dirge. Thankfully it’s not played too often these days.

Callistemon Thu 26-Nov-20 12:02:59

And I don't like Imagine either (how hard did you have to try to imagine no possessions John?)
'Imagine'
Thank goodness, Nannarose and FannyC, I thought I'd get shredded if I said that grin

most things by Barry White.
Me neither although they're ok sung by someone else

Hey Mr Tambourine Man played endlessly by a boyfriend one summer, he was very nice but as boring as the song.

I'm enjoying this thread.

Nannarose Thu 26-Nov-20 12:14:29

I love Mr. Tambourine Man - when my son was in his teens, he got a picture of a surfer, and wrote out the words 'to dance beneath a diamond sky......' on top of it, as a gift to me, which I treasure.

And Seasons in the Sun is a really interesting song - badly translated from the original which I love.

And this is why I'm loving this thread!

A musician said to me that he thinks that the divide is between those who love the words and those who love the music. Not sure if he's right, but I do know people who tell me they like a song, but if I say that I don't like the words they say 'oh, I never listen to them'. That's why I have mixed feelings about Mack the Knife - great tune, very evocative - about a serial (or contract) killer! Fine in context, but otherwise ?!

MissAdventure Thu 26-Nov-20 12:16:42

I love Mr tambourine man, too.
It has a lovely feel to it.

3nanny6 Thu 26-Nov-20 12:37:45

Those terrible songs by the Cheeky Girls one of them called
we are the cheeky girls. what a load of rubbish.
Fairytale of New York the Pogues.
Crazy Horses by the Osmonds
My Boy Lollipop by Millie I hate that song.

FannyCornforth Thu 26-Nov-20 12:58:56

Nannarose 'the daft woman' Clapton wrote Wonderful Tonight about was Patti Boyd.
He also wrote Layla for her when she was married to George Harrison.
Can you imagine having a song like that written for you? Wow.

Callistemon Thu 26-Nov-20 13:14:38

MissAdventure

I love Mr tambourine man, too.
It has a lovely feel to it.

You didn't spend a summer hearing it on a loop with a voiceover grin.

It is an earworm though.

Nannarose Thu 26-Nov-20 14:10:45

FannyCornforth - I shouldn't perhaps have called an individual 'daft', but what the singer seems to be saying is that whatever he wants to do, this woman enables him to do it, unquestioningly (whilst looking beautiful).
You ask if I can imagine having a song like that written for me - no I can't imagine it at all!
By 'wow' do you mean that you would have liked to be the subject of the song?
Why I like this thread so much is how we all read different things into these songs!
But you do raise an interesting question - maybe for another thread - about the song you would have liked written about you.

Desdemona Thu 26-Nov-20 14:12:57

'Jolene' by Dolly Parton.

yggdrasil Thu 26-Nov-20 14:24:46

I hate that stalking one by the Police. The one that goes I'll be watching you

Lucca Thu 26-Nov-20 14:26:57

Callistemon

^(I agree Elton John is overrated too)!^

Nooooo!

“Daniel” takes me instantly back to a summer in early 70’s possibly 1972, when I fell in love ......

sharon103 Thu 26-Nov-20 14:32:03

I love Fairytale of New York. It's my favourite Christmas song.

I don't like, Chirpy Chirpy Cheep cheep. Middle of the Road
Brown Girl in the ring by Boney M
Mouldy old dough Lieutenant pigeon
Welcome home, Peters and Lee
Shout, Lulu
Seasons in the Sun, Terry Jacks
Fire, Arthur Brown.

sharon103 Thu 26-Nov-20 14:35:50

Lucca

Callistemon

(I agree Elton John is overrated too)!

Nooooo!

“Daniel” takes me instantly back to a summer in early 70’s possibly 1972, when I fell in love ......

Aww, I love that too Lucca.
I have a son Daniel. It reminds me of him although he didn't arrive until 1994.
So does Danny boy.

Callistemon Thu 26-Nov-20 15:28:29

yggdrasil

I hate that stalking one by the Police. The one that goes I'll be watching you

Oh yes, I was trying to remember that one then got distracted.

If hear it, I think 'Creepy'
I don't like Gordon Sumner anyway.

Curlywhirly Thu 26-Nov-20 15:48:59

Some songs disliked by others are my favourites - Dance the Night Away by the Mavericks always gets me on the dance floor; Nilsson's Without You is a classic as is Hey Jude and Imagine!
Absolutely detest Empire State of Mind by Alicia Keys - she absolutely screams some of the Lyrics - I always rush to turn it off the radio, it just sets my teeth on edge. Don't like Vera Lynn's We'll Meet Again (sorry!) the tune is just so miserable, though the words aren't. Don't like anything by Abba or The Carpenters either. Also detest with a passion any Rap songs - lyrics are meant to be sung!

LadyBella Thu 26-Nov-20 23:39:07

And what's that awful one that goes... "Driving home for Christmas"? Yuck.

Elrel Thu 26-Nov-20 23:58:37

Oh dear, I love Mr Tambourine Man, Fairytale ofNew York, Mac the Knife and Hallelujah. And Every Step You Take, no hope for me I guess.

Trying hard to recall a song I dislike. My Way, Lady in Red, Imagine.

DanniRae Fri 27-Nov-20 07:38:15

Oh LadyBella when my daughter lived a long way from us I used to love "Driving Home for Christmas" because it reminded me that she would indeed be "Driving Home for Christmas" smile
Happily she is just a little way from us now........as is my son who also lived a long way from us back then. smile