Gransnet forums

Chat

Did your parents have a favourite child?

(207 Posts)
songstress60 Sun 17-Jan-21 15:27:18

I am interested in knowing if any of the people on this forum had parents who had a favourite child, and it if affected their life. Were you the favourite child? Were you the unfavourite child?

I come from a family of 3 daughters and the middle daughter was definitely my mum's favourite. In fact my mother told me that after her birth which happened when I was 2 years of age I became a "jealous little bitch". She said that I spoiled everyone's childhood, but I feel that she made a real favourite out of my sister right from the start. My dad actually told her off about it because when my sister was a baby she would put her to bed and nobody was to disturb her while she bonded with her daughter. He said I did not get a look in at all. She was resentful of my youngest sister who was an accident, and always favoured my middle sister who could do no wrong in her eyes. When my sister bought her first home my mother's housewarming present was a vanity unit, a fitted wardrobe, and a dressing table. My housewarming present was a set of cat ornaments from a charity shop which I got rid of after her death. After she had been married 3 years my dad bought her some new rings:- a new eternity ring, wedding ring, and engagement ring. You would think she would divide the 3 old rings between the 3 of us. No! She gave my middle sister her ALL 3 of her old rings. I know I am not the only unfavourite child. A friend and work colleague of mine deliberately only had one child because of all the favouritism her mother bestowed on her sister. My other friend was also the unfavourite child who decided to have no children after having a miserable childhood where she felt second best. I would love to hear of other gransnet readers eperience of this, and if any of them as parents actually have a favourite child themselves?

Judy54 Mon 18-Jan-21 13:57:41

No. There was only a year between myself and my late Brother and were were more like twins. Our Parents loved us equally and my Brother (my only sibling) and I loved each other very much throughout our lives. So sad to hear many of the stories about feeling less favoured than a Brother or Sister and the impact that it has had on lives into Adulthood.

NotANana Mon 18-Jan-21 14:02:53

Yes they did, and it was not me. My younger sibling was the beloved and indulged child.
We are not close even after many decades.

tictacnana Mon 18-Jan-21 14:08:03

My mum was the middle and extremely unfavoured child. A relative told me of the physical and mental abuse my mum suffered at the hands of her mother. As an adult the abuse continued in a different way. She bought presents and helped out with buying school uniforms for her other grandchildren but we didn’t even get birthday cards. My lovely mum must have been very hurt on our behalf. I would have been. For myself, I always felt that I was favourite but I dare say my siblings felt the same because she was such a wonderful amazing mother.

Helenlouise3 Mon 18-Jan-21 14:14:39

I'm the eldest of 3 girls. There's almost 6 years between the middle sister and myself and then just 18 months between her and the youngest. Growing up I can't say I noticed than any of us was treated differently, except that I was often told "take your sister with you" when I went out. I did get resentful of that in my early teens. The youngest had far more freedom as a teenager and moved away with her boyfriend when she was 17. From then on she was the favourite. Her children would come and stay for the whole of the Summer holidays etc while we were lucky to get a visit 3 times a year. She never took either my or middle sister's children even out for a day. My daughter never spent a night with them until she was 12. It's the same now. they live 10 miles from myself and middle sister yet we never see them unless we visit, yet they go hundreds of miles to visit our youngest several times a year. Even though we moan about it, you won't find 3 sisters closer than what we are,
as adults.

Buffy Mon 18-Jan-21 14:15:51

My father didn’t show favouritism but my mother always did. We are 3 girls and I am the middle one. The youngest could never, ever do any wrong. I spent my whole life trying to win my mother’s approval and when she died at the age of 100 she finally told me I had turned out the best of all 3. What she meant was that I doted on her until her dying day. I’m not proud of that, rather, sad that I needed her approval so much. Never a hug, a kiss or a cuddle

Esspee Mon 18-Jan-21 14:31:57

My only sibling was a twin and very premature. His brother didn't make it and it was a long time before he was able to come home. My mother's life revolved round him.
When I caught measles I was put outside in the pram so that he was protected. Even as teenagers he received much more pocket money than me. I didn't get the option to go to Uni. He was subsidised through to a PhD.
Strangely enough, although conscious of the bias, I never disliked my mother for it and my brother and I have always got on well.
It probably helped that I was a daddy's girl.?

Curlywhirly Mon 18-Jan-21 14:35:36

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Whatdayisit Mon 18-Jan-21 14:47:12

I really enjoyed this episode on The Crown!

With my mum the middle child second son is her favourite My eldest brother and i started calling him Goldenballs as adults.
I spent 40 years of my life trying to get DM's approval or to feel liked by her but it never happened.
I was the result of her affair with the local butcher's delivery man. Eventually she came clean to my brother's dad that i wasn't his - they had already split up. My brothers were horrible to me and she never stopped it. I always felt like a cuckoo.
I think she resented me for being born. Anyway i don't waste my energy on her now i have my own family.
Accepting that neither of your parents really liked you and putting that aside and getting on with your life is something that needs to be done at as young an age as possible.
My Grandad was like a father to me but i can't say i was his favourite grandchild. He was fair with us all and i spent most of my childhood at my grandparents.
I really don't think i have a favourite child myself; they all have qualities which i can either like or be irked by but i love them all equally and try my hardest to give all three as much of my time as i can.

AJKW Mon 18-Jan-21 14:48:07

I was my Dads Favourite and my brother was my Mums favourite, so it seemed very equal in our home.

BoBo53 Mon 18-Jan-21 14:55:10

So very sorry to read of the loss of your daughters Downtoearth makes other issues seem very unimportant!

sansa Mon 18-Jan-21 15:08:31

What a shame this bothers you. My mother’s favourite was my sister. I don’t think dad had a favourite but he told me once I was an adult that he always knew my sister was favourite. That was ok. I think it was because I always questioned what mum did and my sister didn’t so I became the awkward one! I determined from a very young age never to be like my mother and hopefully I’m not! Even when mum was dying and I visited her she’d say ‘ I only want Jill’. It made no difference to the relationship with my sister. We love each other very much and though mum left her jewellery to Jill she shared it with me. Mum missed a lot and I find that sad

Shropshirelass Mon 18-Jan-21 16:33:54

No, we were always treated exactly the same. However, in later years it was always me they turned to so maybe that says something. At least they knew they could rely on me.

specki4eyes Mon 18-Jan-21 16:36:21

I was the favourite child. I had an elder brother who resented me appearing when he was 5 years old. He was sullen and sulky or over excited and silly, constantly infuriating our parents with his behaviour. I think our father didnt bond with him and our mother tried to redress the balance by mollycoddling him, only to be disappointed when he rebuffed her. So finally they invested all their affection in me. Of course I revelled in this in a selfishly childish way. I adored my brother but he treated me badly, one time hurling stones at my feet in order to 'entertain' his friends.
I would have loved him to return my affection. In adulthood he was very kind and generous to our parents but somehow they had hardened their hearts against him and kept him at arms length. He took his own life at the age of 48 and it turned out that he had been diagnosed as bi-polar. Only his wife knew of the diagnosis and she revealed that he had stubbornly refused to accept it or take the medicine he needed to alleviate the symptoms.
So in my family's case, I was the favourite because I was easier to love.

Tabbycat Mon 18-Jan-21 16:37:27

My parents had a child before me, who died after only a few weeks. We went to live abroad and I was sent to boarding school aged six, which I hated.

They tried for another baby, but my mother found it hard to conceive and suffer several miscarriages, then when she was pregnant with my sister, she and I came back to England. I was sent to live with my maternal grandmother (who I didn't really know), my father was still abroad and I didn't see either parent for about six months. My sister was premature and quite a sickly baby, so she had most of my mother's time and attention. I spent a lot of time with my father - she said I was becoming a Daddy's girl and told him off for spoiling me.

Because of the gap in age my sister regarded me as an aunt - I left home to go to University when she was eight. My sister has since told me that my mother was always comparing her to me and she always felt she came up short!

We were both told separately by our mother that she was disappointed that we were both girls, because my father wanted a boy. He never said this to either of us and we both felt loved by him. He was the one who cuddled and played with us when we were little. He always told us how proud he was of us when we were growing up. She always seemed full of anger found it difficult to show any affection to either of us.

Now my sister lives in Australia and we keep in touch by letter, phone calls and Skype. My father died seven years ago and my mother is in her nineties. My husband and I do all her shopping, take her to appointments and for occasional days out. I phone her every day and, before this pandemic, took her out for lunch and to church every week. Yet she has said unkind things about my husband and two daughters and tells me she wishes I was in Australia and my sister was here. Sometimes she puts me down with cruel remarks and finds fault with everything I say or do - at which point I bring the conversation to a close and put down the phone or come away.

I'm sure a therapist would have a field day!

JaneR185 Mon 18-Jan-21 17:13:46

After a conversation with friends at a coffee morning, each of my three daughters came to me separately and whispered confidently, 'I'm your favourite aren't I Mummy?' Of course I said yes to each of them. And they still are! grin

Jillybird Mon 18-Jan-21 17:37:14

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Harris27 Mon 18-Jan-21 18:01:32

Well I was the youngest and my sister was my stepsister so it was her. I lost my mum when I was 3 and dad remarried and my step mum showed me little affection but I did keep trying. Even when she was dying she referred to me as ‘ the other one’
Love m sister though she’s great and we get on really well.

Seajaye Mon 18-Jan-21 18:28:16

My parents were so determined to show that they did not have a favourite out of their 3 children while growing up, almost to the point of of making us all feel like the least favourite!

nexus63 Mon 18-Jan-21 19:18:49

i was the eldest of 4, my youngest sister 10 years between us was the favourite, i was treated differently by my "dad", they would get sweets and crisps when he came home drunk, i was taken aside and given some money....because i was the eldest, never knew he was not my dad till i was 11, he started saying things and tried to do something...won't go into details, i was sent to stay with my gran and she stayed with him, since then i have had no love for her...she let me down, i never went to her when i had a problem or needed help, i never wanted children but had 1 son, she has never really bothered about him and said i only got pregnant because my 2nd sis had a baby, things changed last year when i had cancer, i think it frightened her and now every call ends with ...love you...i feel i have to say it bit i don't mean it, i think every mum has a favourite even when they say they don't.

homefarm Mon 18-Jan-21 19:30:59

An interesting thread.
My sister was 14 months younger than I, and was the favourite child. My parents were 16 and 18 when they married, presumably because of me.
My mother had me at 17 and my sister at 18 - to this day I think she was pretty stupid.
However, I was the lucky one, I went to live with my grandparents, and young aunt and uncle.
I had, to all intents and purposes, an older brother and sister who spoiled me and spent hours entertaining me with trips out, reading etc etc , as result I did well at school and so on.
Sadly they are now all gone, as are my parents, as for my sister we keep in touch but that is about all.

Naninka Mon 18-Jan-21 20:16:55

Well, mine is quite understandable but still sad. My older brother and I were both adopted (from different families) as my Mum and Dad couldn't conceive. Fast forward several years and my parents split up. Mum went on to marry again and conceived for the first time. This child (twelve years younger than me) became The Golden Child. He was given privileges that we didn't have (expensive school trips, big parties, holidays abroad). I went on to a successful career and met a wonderful man - together we have 4 children and 5 beautiful grandchildren, lovely home, etc. My older brother (he who was similarly adopted) has had comparable success, with children, grandchildren and happiness in all he has achieved.
The Golden Child, now in his late 40s, is alone, dependent on drugs and alcohol, has never had a 'proper' job. He lives in a seaside town which is desolate in the winter and, although he can pick up some work in the summer, he mostly lives off our now elderly mother, who still indulges him wholeheartedly. Am I bitter? No, I love both my brothers but I do wonder if the youngest would have made more of himself with less mollycoddling. What do any of my fellow GN peers think?

Grannyflower Mon 18-Jan-21 20:23:56

Yes and it was not me. Being the third daughter in quick succession, I was not planned and certainly one too many. DM had a “nervous breakdown” with all the stress. Sisters resented having me tag along and cramp their style and having to help look after me while Mum was too ill. 12 years later my brother arrived. He was like a living doll for me while the elder two were too busy excelling at school or getting into trouble with boys. Brother and I have remained close despite the age gap and the fact that as the man, he inherited everything while us girls had husbands.

Framilode Mon 18-Jan-21 20:29:23

My brother was definitely the favourite. We were brought up in Africa and when I was 9 I was sent back to the UK to boarding school. My brother went to boarding school locally. I only saw my parents a couple of times in 4 years. I was so excited when I flew out for the summer holidays but could tell within an hour or so that she was irritated by me.
Later when we were adults and I was a stay at home mum with young children she introduced us to someone by saying 'This is my son, he's a barrister and this is my daughter, she is just a housewife'.
I was always aware that she didn't really like me but I do think she loved me.
There was only 14 months between my brother and me but for my 2lst I was given a watch and £21. He got a brand new car.
He was always the golden child but as an adult he took no interest in them and it was left to me to keep in touch and provide care.
She was the same with my two girls. One was shown obvious favouritism.

shirleyhick Mon 18-Jan-21 20:35:55

Yes my middle sister and she still is so is her child you would think she was the only grandchild even though I have 3 children but I just think got nothing to thank her for it used to upset me but you get used to it

Hetty58 Mon 18-Jan-21 20:43:07

Yes - and it wasn't me. I felt relieved, though, to be somewhat out of the spotlight, under the radar etc.

When the favourite got married, I soon left home, before attention was turned in my direction!

Still, it's always been hurtful that I just didn't get equal treatment, consideration, funding etc.