Gransnet forums

Chat

One upmanship

(192 Posts)
GagaJo Tue 23-Mar-21 09:27:58

So, over the last few weeks I have seen one upmanship on GN about the following:

Curtain v plantation shutters
Paint v wallpaper
Sausages (cheap and fatty v butchers)
Easter eggs
Holidays (2nd home v beach and poool)
Houses (detached v anything else)

Have I missed anything?

Maggiemaybe Tue 23-Mar-21 12:56:09

Maggiemaybe

Surely not. I’d expect gold dust and sparkles for that price. Rose scented.

Whoops. That was to Ellianne and her dog poo post.

Maggiemaybe Tue 23-Mar-21 12:54:59

Surely not. I’d expect gold dust and sparkles for that price. Rose scented.

annsixty Tue 23-Mar-21 12:54:23

Someone said a few days ago that although she had a very quiet wedding ,the media were there and they got free champagne at the hotel as her husband was recognised.
Now that truly is oneupmanship.
She actually is a regular and genuine poster.

Ellianne Tue 23-Mar-21 12:53:15

And my pedigree dog cost over a thousand, but still poops like any other mut.

Maggiemaybe Tue 23-Mar-21 12:50:16

cornishpatsy

I have read comments where people are sneered at for their choice of reading or TV programmes watched which is as bad as the one-upmanship.

I do not believe everything I read on here about what people have. There was a photo of a house and garden on a thread with the poster saying about the view from her window that day, as I recognised the area I googled the image. It was a stock photo of a house in 2003.

Now that is interesting, cornishpasty. I’ve seen a few members outed in a similar way on Mumsnet. Perhaps it was someone who decided to move over to give us all view envy.

Ellianne Tue 23-Mar-21 12:47:21

That's funny Cornish putting up a magazine picture!

Maggiemaybe Tue 23-Mar-21 12:46:51

MerylStreep

So, to conclude. The OP is a load of codswhallop. That’s my polite word so as not to offend ?

But it has led to an amusing conversation. And goodness knows, there are enough laughs to be had at the moment.

Ellianne Tue 23-Mar-21 12:45:55

And what about the decadent poster who said they get Cornish fish boxes delivered every week? Now that is something I envy!

hazel93 Tue 23-Mar-21 12:45:54

How ridiculous !
I could not care remotely what other people may, or not have in terms of wealth. How superficial is that ? I either like you or I do not, no thought of some outmoded scale of hierarchy.
You buy Farrow and Ball, I buy Dulux . I buy Joseph , you buy Primark, - who cares ????
In these times of such turmoil the last thing thing we should be thinking about is any kind of envy or oneupmanship.

Riverwalk Tue 23-Mar-21 12:45:00

cornishpatsy

I have read comments where people are sneered at for their choice of reading or TV programmes watched which is as bad as the one-upmanship.

I do not believe everything I read on here about what people have. There was a photo of a house and garden on a thread with the poster saying about the view from her window that day, as I recognised the area I googled the image. It was a stock photo of a house in 2003.

That definitely wasn't me! grin

How interesting Cornish

Ellianne Tue 23-Mar-21 12:40:45

Lucca there have been a few interesting car threads started by people asking about makes to buy. Inevitably it went from minis to Range Rovers. That's why mine got mentioned. Not that I ever paid for it outright! Some of us confessed to being speed junkies

JaneJudge Tue 23-Mar-21 12:35:25

I have missed all this, what on earth happened re Easter eggs? grin

cornishpatsy Tue 23-Mar-21 12:31:59

I have read comments where people are sneered at for their choice of reading or TV programmes watched which is as bad as the one-upmanship.

I do not believe everything I read on here about what people have. There was a photo of a house and garden on a thread with the poster saying about the view from her window that day, as I recognised the area I googled the image. It was a stock photo of a house in 2003.

MerylStreep Tue 23-Mar-21 12:26:40

So, to conclude. The OP is a load of codswhallop. That’s my polite word so as not to offend ?

Riverwalk Tue 23-Mar-21 12:23:22

To be honest I see very little boasting on GN - it would be silly anyway as, with a few exceptions, we are all anonymous.

Must admit though, I live in a shoe-box and do at times get utility room, paddock, library, extensive gardens, orangery, front drive-envy! grin

Redhead56 Tue 23-Mar-21 12:20:50

We own a cottage in Wales we bought it with inheritance money. We enjoyed the freedom of going there as a family. Now our family (when we can eventually see them) is our priority. We decided to put it on the market because what time we have is family time.
We ran a small business passed on from FIL it gave us a good living but we worked hard for it. I appreciate what we have but don't feel the need to boast about it. What's the point we all live different lives that's what makes us unique.

Pantglas2 Tue 23-Mar-21 12:09:44

I never see oneupmanship as I’ve always realised that choices can be made within any budget, large or small.

I came from a council house booze fags and bingo childhood and now own a small home in Wales and another in Spain and have friends and family who earned more and have neither.

I share what I have with them as others with more have done for me over the years and that’s the point of ‘stuff’ - it’s not for coveting, it’s for sharing!

Anyway, I’m not sure anyone would envy someone with a holiday home abroad at the moment - we can’t go there and it’s costing money!

M0nica Tue 23-Mar-21 12:03:32

Ah, yes, the sneering references to 'First world problems'

There is only one solution. We should all have to fill in a form when joining GN saying what our income is and what we own and then we can have half a dozen GN's based on sociodemographc indicators. That way those less well off will not feel excluded if someone admits to buying a new car, and those of us with a drive full of Maserattis and Ferraris, will not have to communicate with people who spend less on their car than we would on a car service.

Wouldn't it be boring.

janeainsworth Tue 23-Mar-21 12:01:51

Here’s some reverse oneupmanship
m.youtube.com/watch?v=VKHFZBUTA4k

ayse Tue 23-Mar-21 12:01:31

Sausages - rarely buy them but if I do they are generally the most tasty and meaty (the label). I’d rather not eat the pork slurry sausages. It’s definitely not one-upmanship, more a case of trying to stay relatively healthy.

No second home, expensive car etc. but very happy to have tastier, less processed food.

Blossoming Tue 23-Mar-21 11:59:55

I haven’t noticed any oneupmanship myself but I’m happy to start some if it’s what people want.

My house is messier than your house grin

Lucca Tue 23-Mar-21 11:59:53

Agree J A
If I did see boasting I would think it funny to be honest,

janeainsworth Tue 23-Mar-21 11:57:04

I don’t see any one-upmanship.

What I do see, with depressing frequency, is someone asking a question, getting honest answers, and then someone else(not referring to any particular poster) who doesn’t have those things and possibly has a chip on their shoulder as well, makes a snarky comment about other people boasting and complaining about their own lot in life.

One of the less pleasant aspects of gransnet.

Oldwoman70 Tue 23-Mar-21 11:56:20

MerylStreep

Oldwoman70
I trump your butler and pool with my tennis court and stables.

The tennis courts and stables are the other side of the house, out of sight of the orangery and just past the 4 car garage grin

Lucca Tue 23-Mar-21 11:55:51

Puzzler61

Lucca I think SLK is referring to a convertible Mercedes sports car. ?

Oh I see ! Why would that even be mentioned ? Oh maybe on one the competitive cleaning threads .....