Gransnet forums

Chat

Possible “nappy tax” on disposables

(115 Posts)
Ealdemodor Tue 31-Aug-21 19:13:12

Well, as most new mums are now in their 30s, knackered before they start, having worked up until the last minute, then put under pressure to return to work ASAP, I can’t see much future for cloth nappies!

GagaJo Tue 31-Aug-21 19:17:18

Nappy service is always an option. Might be more popular if the price came down.

MaizieD Tue 31-Aug-21 19:17:54

If those mums want their children to have a decent future on a planet which is hospitable to human life I think they'll have to come to terms with cloth nappies.

aggie Tue 31-Aug-21 19:18:01

My granddaughters aged from 8 to 17 were all reared in cloth nappies , so the idea isn’t that new
The first “disposables” are still mouldering in various landfills

Galaxy Tue 31-Aug-21 19:25:35

Yes always the wonens job to save the planet.

Galaxy Tue 31-Aug-21 19:25:52

Or women even grin

Gwyneth Tue 31-Aug-21 19:27:55

I used terry nappies for my children but I believe re-useable nappies are far more user friendly and easier these days. We cannot continue to throw away three billion nappies into landfill every year.

Smileless2012 Tue 31-Aug-21 19:31:15

I agree Gwyneth. I had no idea they amounted to "three billion nappies into landfill every year"shock.

Riverwalk Tue 31-Aug-21 19:37:19

Galaxy

Yes always the wonens job to save the planet.

Indeed - unfortunately women still do the lion's share of domestic work.

If I were a young mother I wouldn't be using reusable nappies.

Have there been any serious studies to show they really are more eco-friendly - taking into account manufacture, plus plastic cover, detergent, electricity?

Lots of families live in flats with no outside space, so you can forget about snowy white nappies blowing in the wind, which many on here wax lyrical about!

grandMattie Tue 31-Aug-21 19:38:26

3bn nappies p.a.is an awful lot to put into landfill. DD used ready shaped terry nappies, with integral plastic pants, all held together with Velcro. Her then London borough offered cheap ones for new mums so they didn’t use disposable.

tippytipsy Tue 31-Aug-21 19:47:42

If the baby or toddler is with a childminder or in a nursery all day, can staff be expected to deal with various types of cloth nappies in large quantities?

Germanshepherdsmum Tue 31-Aug-21 19:56:14

I was in my 30s, knackered, had to return to work after 11 weeks and used cloth nappies.

GrandmaKT Tue 31-Aug-21 20:25:06

I am 62 and my parents reliably inform me that I had disposable nappies. I tried to use terry nappies with my first born, but am ashamed to say I never got the hang of it and quickly turned to disposables. Now my grandchildren are in cloth nappies. They are much more user-friendly than the old terry nappies, being brightly coloured little 'pants' with poppers on them. The big advance we need is flushable nappy liners as the whole mess could then be lifted off the nappy and plopped in the loo. Atm the worst bit is scraping the poo off the nappy liner (sorry if anyone is eating!)

M0nica Tue 31-Aug-21 20:30:48

I found cloth nappies far less hassle than disposables.

Nonogran Tue 31-Aug-21 20:32:49

I used terry nappies. It’s an easy routine to get in to with a bit of application & aforethought. I used nappy liners and just lifted the contents away into the loo. My baby never got nappy rash which I think was avoided because I washed her properly at every nappy change, & given my time over again, I’d do the same.

JaneJudge Tue 31-Aug-21 20:35:35

why can't there be clinical waste bins for feminine and nappies etc? it is a service offered so if we have to pay, why not via a service that is already offered?

vegansrock Tue 31-Aug-21 21:36:29

Plenty of eco conscious mums use reusable or eco friendly disposables. If Henry VIII had been in disposables they would still be in the ground. Definitely encourage reusables, reduce the price of the biodegradeables, and tax the eco unfriendly ones.

GagaJo Tue 31-Aug-21 21:41:46

Nappy services could make a killing. Provide clean nappies each week. Provide a 'smell free' container for the dirties. Take away when delivering the clean ones.

It was a service around in the 80's. Would be the best of both worlds now too.

MerylStreep Tue 31-Aug-21 21:43:22

As much as I am against disposables I understand why mums use them but thank goodness there are environmentally friendly brands out there.

moralfibres.co.uk/eco-friendly-disposable-nappies/

midgey Tue 31-Aug-21 21:44:07

But it’s not just nappies for babies is it? What about all the ‘products’ for women of all ages? They are very similar just not so bulky.

Ro60 Tue 31-Aug-21 21:45:32

My DD has just worked up to the last minute in the thick it.
She uses eco cloth nappies as do many of her friends. They're all the rage & very pretty these days.
We went travelling with her first, with only cabin baggage - it's certainly do-able.

sodapop Tue 31-Aug-21 22:01:19

Yes I would imagine that today's cloth nappies are far removed from the thick terry towelling we used in the 60s and 70s.
So many things to consider with this as Galaxy said.

Chardy Tue 31-Aug-21 22:14:13

Surely it's just the plastic bit of the disposables that is environmentally unfriendly.

Chardy Tue 31-Aug-21 22:18:38

Apologies - posted too soon.
My dog's poo bags are biodegradable and I promise you, they're waterproof.

(And the reusable ones use a lot of hot water.)

Witzend Tue 31-Aug-21 22:54:59

My dd used cloth nappies for her 3rd but after about 6 months found that they weren’t absorbent or ‘containing’ enough. And TBH with 2 other quite little ones she always had mountains of washing anyway.

I seem to recall that even with 2 of the good old terry nappies at night, folded into the ‘kite shape’, my dd1 was still sodden in the morning, so I’m not sure how the much smaller new cloth nappies would have coped.