Germanshepherdsmum
The programme schedules are full of this sort of inane rubbish. The ‘off’ switch is much used here.
Oh, if you've ever seen WILTY with Bob Mortimer on you'll not think its inane. He is beyond funny. 🤣
Sign up to Gransnet Daily
Our free daily newsletter full of hot threads, competitions and discounts
Subscribe
Why does being good at and well known for one thing qualify so-called “celebrities” for a range of entertainment on TV?
Looking at what’s on TV tonight I see the following
Would I Lie to You? With panellists Shirley Ballas, Steven Bartlett, Josie Gibson and Chris McCausland (S)
8.30
Amanda & Alan's Italian Job Amanda Holden and Alan Carr set about renovating the bathrooms (AD) (S)
So Shirley Ballas is a dancer and “judge” on Strictly. Why should that get her a place on a panel show? (It’s all scripted anyway I imagine. )
Amanda Holden is a TV presenter. “media personality” , occasional actress, and Alan Carr is a rather camp comedian .
What is the attraction in watching them hamming up “renovating” a bathroom in Italy?
Then there are the endless travel progs with the likes of Susan Calman, Sue Perkins, Joe Lycett etc
At least Monty Don knows something about gardens
Monty Don's Adriatic Gardens The presenter visits the city of Trieste (AD) (R)
Love them or loathe them, I still find myself mostly asking “Why” ?
Germanshepherdsmum
The programme schedules are full of this sort of inane rubbish. The ‘off’ switch is much used here.
Oh, if you've ever seen WILTY with Bob Mortimer on you'll not think its inane. He is beyond funny. 🤣
I feel Charlene White has gone down in my expectations. She was a serious news reader. Now she’s here, there and everywhere.
Equally puzzling is why the online version of the Daily Mail has so many pictures of these "celebs" showing off their "toned abs" in swimsuits. I have no idea why half of them are "celeb".
What makes a talentless person into a celebrity?
That has baffled me for a long time.
What I don’t understand is how a reality TV appearance alllows people to then be described as ‘stars’ of TOWIE/Love Island etc. Even worse are the influencers.
I suppose we live in a changing world. However, I think the old world where actual talent as an actor, musician or as an orator was used when considering whether someone deserved that accolade.
As regards Stacey Solomon - I think she does have many talents but is what we use to call a personality rather than a star. It’s fact that some people work hard and fortune smiles upon them.
Presumably it's all about the money. Boy George was (allegedly) paid around £800,000 for appearing on I'm A Celebrity. Other celebs receiving less according to their celeb 'status'. I believe the minimum they get is £75,000 which is why the 'serious' journalists are happy to become less serious.
I think it depends to be fair. I wouldn’t have missed Michael Palin’s travels around the world for anything. Some celebrities from one field go on to have genuine alternative careers and are very good at what they do. (I like Susan Calman’s,, she makes me laugh because she’s quirky and genuinely funny). I more dislike the relentless round of celebrity exposures on poor quality reality shows and quiz programmes, they are just boring.
I wonder if anyone else watched the Alan Carr and Amanda Holden renovation show? I thoroughly enjoyed it. They bought 2 apartments for 1 Euro each in Sicily and did them up with a view to sell and donate the proceeds to a UK charity. The work was done by local people and helped the local economy. It was well done and we learnt a lot about the area too. I am now interested in visiting, it looked wonderful. So don't dismiss it all as simply rubbish.
I must admit to enjoying Motorhoming with Paul Merton and Suki Webster, it's not shouty like of the celebrity programmes and they seem to have a very normal relationship gently teasing each other at times.
annsixty
What makes a talentless person into a celebrity?
That has baffled me for a long time.
One of my pet “wonder about” is Stacy Solomon, she of the perpetual wide mouthed grin.
I have never seen her apart from in the Manchester Evening News which is obsessed with unknown “celebrities “.
Stacy Solomon was one of the runners up on X Factor, she has her own decluttering programme and is sometimes on Loose Women.
In the heatwave last summer she opened up her garden and pool so that the village children could play and stay cool.
I'm not keen on either Amanda Holden or Alan Carr nor on 'Sleb' programmes so wasn't going to watch their Italian house renovation but it just happened to be on 😁 and it turned out to be much better than I thought.
They have a rapport and in fact Amanda seemed to get really stuck in, demolishing walls etc.
The ones that annoy me are the endless travel programmes presented by Celebs who get to see lovely places courtesy of our money.
I don't mean serious presenters like Simon Reeves and I like Michael Portillo.
Michael Palin was excellent too.
And the Arctic chap
Chris McCausland - he's very funny
Oh, and Bob and Paul going fishing
I must be easy to please 😂
CallmeEsme
Well I totally agree with Maw. I avoid this kind of show.
How does being a tennis coach and mother to a tennis star make you a celebrity. In my book it doesn’t. She appears to be as boring and as stiff as a plank of wood.
Makes you wonder what’s happened to the real talent these days.
I can guess who you mean and agree. Her talents are certainly not in dancing but the fee would certainly add to the family's accumulated wealth.
We the public make them celebrities by reading about them in Magazines like O.K. Or buying Newspapers where they are front page.
Even a certain Royals mother and sister tried it for a time but seem to be lying low at the moment all to the good of their relation.
Kate1949
I think of it as a sort of a club - you come on our show and we'll come on yours. It's usually the same celebrities on most things. They are usually promoting a book or something, especially in shows like Graham Norton.
Oh yes, some of the shows, like The One Show are just advertising.
Book, TV show or film?
They should rename it the Charades Show.
So many so called ‘celebrities’ are just talentless people who make a lot of noise and are in the right place at the right time or have the right promoters
I ve never watched Michael Portillo or Susan Calman who I ve never heard of before (is she a celebrity? ) and I don’t like seeing the likes of Ed Balls Anne Widdecombe etc make bigger fools of themselves than they already are
And my pet hate is actors or personalities who now get their children involved in banal programmes Bradley Walsh, a talented man in his own right who is now everywhere with his son, and Martin Kemp, Danny Dyer etc etc why can’t ordinary kids without famous fathers get a chance
Surely there are many up and coming people (actors, stage school etc) WITH talent who really need a break
What’s WILTY by the way ?
WILTY = Would I Lie to You?
BlueBelle
What’s WILTY by the way ?
Is it ‘Would I Lie To You?’
I don’t know, but the initials fit!
x posts volver”
They all seem to be on a sort of pass the parcel merry go round.
I quite enjoyed Jane McDonald doing cruises because singing on cruise ships was how she found fame but now Susan Calman’s doing them and Jane’s doing holidays.
Fern Britton’s doing Cornwall - Who hasn’t done Cornwall? New game shows are being invented at the speed of light to provide a vehicle for hardly known comedians and the DIY bandwagon is also being well and truly jumped on.
Who is going to be the next one to renovate a chateau now that Dick and Angel are packing up?
I think there is a glut of quiz shows as they are cheap to produce. Similarly, the only was is Essex type / Housewives of... shows. I don't mind a quiz but TOWIE and Housewives - wouldn't watch them if you paid me. They feel like very dumbed down viewing to me.
The so called celebrities on I'm a Celebrity - I have never heard of most of them
I am happy to watch travel programmes etc. presented by established comedians / celebrities / personalities. I especially like Richard E Grant's shows.
Stacey Solomon was on X Factor. She seems to have done well on the decluttering /craft type of programme. She must have a very good manager! She seems to be a genuinely nice person but her voice grates on me.
She has a beautiful singing voice.
If it's got 'celebrities' in the title I don't watch it.
^why can’t ordinary kids without famous fathers get a chance
Surely there are many up and coming people (actors, stage school etc) WITH talent who really need a break^
Yes a thousand times!
Bradley Walsh's son was even in The Larkins with his Dad although there won't be another series.
Fern Britton’s doing Cornwall - Who hasn’t done Cornwall?
How dare they - it's not just Cornwall, it's Fern Britton's Cornwall - My Cornwall as she calls it!
Although she did work as a presenter for Westward TV and Spotlight South-West
I havent done Cornwall
Everyone else has, Galaxy 😁
Devon and Dorset are feeling left out 
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join the discussion, watch threads and lots more.
Register now »Already registered? Log in with:
Gransnet »Get our top conversations, latest advice, fantastic competitions, and more, straight to your inbox. Sign up to our daily newsletter here.