Gransnet forums

Chat

Were you aware animal testing of cosmetics is now permitted for many cosmetic ingredients?

(52 Posts)
25Avalon Mon 23-Oct-23 10:05:10

I’ve just completed an opinion survey. One of the questions was on animal testing for cosmetics. I always thought this was completely banned in 1998. However, earlier this year the government admitted that the full ban was changed in 2019 and now covers only 20% of cosmetic ingredients. I shall certainly be looking more thoroughly before I buy, even my favourite items.

Grannybags Mon 23-Oct-23 10:10:02

I thought it was banned too. I'll be looking more closely now.

Thanks for the warning

farview Mon 23-Oct-23 10:18:52

I stopped using l'occitane products because I heard they were testing on animals in China.

Anniebach Mon 23-Oct-23 10:20:17

I too thought it was banned, thank you

Aveline Mon 23-Oct-23 10:27:46

Oh dear. I'd always thought Occitane was a good French company.

25Avalon Mon 23-Oct-23 10:30:50

Looking at Somerset Toiletries they have a rabbit emoji and the words cruelty free next to it, so presumably that’s what to look for.

Theexwife Mon 23-Oct-23 10:31:23

Here is the list.

nightowl Mon 23-Oct-23 10:47:25

The leaping bunny is as good a guide as it gets Avalon.

Companies are very good at obfuscating on their packaging and even when asked directly. They use statements such as ‘we are against animal testing and support research into alternatives’ and ‘our products are not tested on animals except where required by law’ ie usually in China. The ban was always selective and it has always been a minefield.

25Avalon Mon 23-Oct-23 11:02:55

Theexwife

Here is the list.

That’s a real shock.

Aveline Mon 23-Oct-23 11:04:15

The list is shocking. All the big names. Poor animals.

Germanshepherdsmum Mon 23-Oct-23 11:08:32

Always look for the bunny logo. If it’s not there, the product has been tested on animals. Any company which sells to, amongst others, America and China, can only do so if the products have been tested on animals. Much testing is carried on in China. I’m not in the least surprised by the list.

Jess20 Wed 25-Oct-23 11:23:46

There's a lot of animal cruelty issues fudged like this, live export being one of them. Some factory farming methods are beyond horrific and baby calves torn away from their poor mothers is just awful. So sad that we can't treat animals kindly and so much suffering is hidden from the pubic eye.

NotSpaghetti Wed 25-Oct-23 11:36:56

Towards the end of September the application for a Judicial Review of UK animal testing laws was allowed to move forward.
I don't think this has happened yet.

NannyC1 Wed 25-Oct-23 11:51:27

Also
The Truth About Nivea's Animal Testing Policy
Although Nivea does not test finished products on animals themselves, they’re not a cruelty-free company. They did allow their products to be tested on animals in mainland China.

Don’t let brands like Nivea trick you: even though it’s the Chinese authorities that performed the animal testing, it’s the brand that pays for these tests. Since Nivea allowed their products to be tested on animals by third parties in China, they can’t be considered cruelty-free.

Nivea also didn’t provide any information about their ingredients or suppliers.

From Nivea’s Website
Nivea’s animal testing policy can be found directly on their website. In Their FAQ, they have a section for “animal welfare, sustainability, and the environment”. Here’s a screenshot of their answer:

The brand also dedicates a page to “Honesty and Transparency”, with a section about animal testing. Here’s the section (click the image to enlarge):

Don’t Be Fooled: Nivea Tests On Animals in China
Don’t be fooled by the wording on Nivea’s website, as it isn’t very honest nor transparent. Nivea is putting their best face forward, while minimizing their role in animal testing.

Nivea is also listed as a brand that tests on animals by PETA. Here’s a screenshot:



About Nivea
Nivea is a German person care brand which is sold worldwide. They mainly offer skin and body care, and their products can be found in most drugstores. They’re owned by Beiersdorf, who also owns Eucerin, Labello, and Aquaphor.

Is Nivea owned by a parent company that tests on animals?
Nivea is owned by Beiersdorf, a company that tests on animals. Not only is Nivea not cruelty-free but neither is their parent company.

In the beauty industry, it’s common for brands to be owned by a larger company. These are called parent companies, and they’re often global corporations such as L’Oreal, Estee Lauder, or Procter & Gamble.

Most of these parent companies are not cruelty-free, since they test on animals to some degree. They might also own several brands that are not cruelty-free.

However, some of the brands owned by these parent companies are cruelty-free and have strict policies against animal testing.

There are pros and cons to supporting cruelty-free brands owned by parent companies that aren’t.

You can either:

Choose to boycott them since they’re a part of a larger conglomerate that engages in animal testing.
Choose to support some of them based on the individual ethics of each parent company, or only purchase from them if there are no independent alternatives.
Choose to support them since they are 100% cruelty-free even though their parent company is not, therefore showing their parent company that consumers are favoring their cruelty-free brands.
In the cruelty-free community, the majority of conscious consumers purchase from cruelty-free brands even if they’re owned by a parent company that tests on animals. This is our stance at Cruelty-Free Kitty as well. We believe that supporting all cruelty-free brands is the only path towards a cruelty-free and more ethical beauty industry.

It’s also worth noting that subsidiary brands of parent companies are unique corporations by themselves. They act as independent branches and operate independently from the parent company, and can also be sold to other companies including cruelty-free ones.

Another aspect to consider is that many parts of the world only have access to limited brands, so their only cruelty-free options are owned by large corporations. This is a concern we hear about constantly from our international readers. Given this complex landscape, we believe that supporting all cruelty-free brands is ethical as well as practical.

A minority of shoppers choose to boycott brands owned by a parent company that tests on animals.

At Cruelty-Free Kitty, we make it easy for all of our readers to know which brands are owned by a parent company that tests on animals. At the top of each brand page, you’ll see a “parent company” note if that’s the case.

You can also filter our list of cruelty-free brands to only show brands that are not owned by any company that tests on animals.

Finally, for a list of brands owned by a parent company that tests on animals, click here.

Is Nivea sold where animal testing is required by law?
Yes, Nivea is available for sale in countries with mandatory animal testing. This means that their products were likely tested on animals.

You can trust Cruelty-Free Kitty to be on top of the most recent changes in China’s animal testing laws. As of 2023, the vast majority of beauty brands available in China have had their products tested on animals.

Mainland China still requires these mandatory animal tests for most companies. Is it possible for brands to bypass them? Yes, however it’s currently extremely rare as brands need to “jump through several hoops”.

One way to bypass these animal tests is to only have their products available only online, and not in physical stores. Another way is to manufacture the products in China while making sure to adhere to strict regulations.

In all other cases, beauty brands need to pay for cruel animal tests to be performed using their products. It’s estimated that close to 100,000 rabbits are used in animal testing for cosmetics each year in China alone.

Even though the company itself isn’t executing these animal experiments, they bear full responsibility. Not only does the company sign off on the experiments, but they’re also funding them.

ADVERTISING

Is Nivea certified cruelty-free by any organizations?
No, Nivea is not certified by any organizations.

While companies can be fully cruelty-free without being certified, it’s still a good indicator of their ethical practices. Leaping Bunny and PETA are the two organizations giving out cruelty-free certification.

ADVERTISING

Is Nivea vegan?
Nivea might offer some vegan products, however because this company is not cruelty-free, we recommend avoiding any products they offer even if they are vegan.

Brands can be cruelty-free without being vegan, and claim to be vegan without being cruelty-free. This is because “cruelty-free” refers to the animal testing aspect, while “vegan” refers to the ingredients.

A “vegan” product contains no animal-derived ingredients, such as Beeswax (made by bees), Carmine (a red pigment made from crushed beetles), or Collagen (from mammal or fish skin).

A company is “cruelty-free” at company level, meaning they can’t have cruelty-free products unless the whole company is cruelty-free. However, a company can offer vegan products even if not all of their products are vegan. If all of their products are vegan, then we refer to the brand as “100% vegan”.

We have a list of 100% vegan brands, and you can also filter our official list of cruelty-free brands and choose to show vegan brands only.

Looking for vegan products from cruelty-free brands? Visit our Product Database and make sure you use the vegan filter.

ADVERTISING

How do you determine that brands like Nivea are not cruelty-free?
Most brands don't publicly display their full animal testing policies. We contact brands directly with our questions in order to get their complete policy. If any brand states that they, their suppliers, or any third party test on animals, the brand is listed as "not cruelty-free."

We ask all conscious consumers to be mindful of misleading statements from brands. Companies that test on animals try to minimize their involvement in animal testing, and understandably so—if a brand were to proudly claim to perform cruel tests on animals, their customers would surely reconsider being a loyal fan.

What they do instead is use clever language that shifts the blame away from themselves and makes the public believe that they’re not responsible for the animal testing, or that the animal testing performed on their products is “an exception”.

If a brand is listed as “not cruelty-free” in our database, you can rest assured that their products were tested on animals in recent years.

We monitor every change and constantly post updates. The changes in our database, list of cruelty-free, and brand pages are reflected in real time as soon as we become aware of new information.

ADVERTISING

Is Cruelty-Free Kitty reliable?
Founded in 2014 by Suzana Rose, Cruelty-Free Kitty is the largest and most trusted cruelty-free shopping platform.

We vet every single brand added to our database by contacting them directly and ensuring they adhere to our strict criteria we call "The Cruelty-Free 5".

For a brand to be listed as cruelty-free, it must satisfy the following:

The brand itself does not test on animals, for either finished products or ingredients.
Suppliers do not test on animals for products, raw materials, or ingredients.
No third parties test on animals on the brand's behalf.
The brand does not test on animals when required by law.
The brand does not sell cosmetics in physical stores in mainland China.
At Cruelty-Free Kitty, we have an unwavering commitment to accuracy. The landscape of cosmetics animal testing is constantly evolving globally. Our team is diligent about staying current on changing laws, brand acquisitions, and policy updates that impact cruelty-free status.

To date, we’ve vetted over 1200+ brands and helped millions of conscious shoppers choose products that aren’t tested on animals. Please feel free to contact us with any questions by using our contact form.

Explore Body Care Brands
Explore For Men Brands
Explore Hair Care Brands
Explore Skincare Brands
Share to spread awareness.
Help spread the word by clicking the buttons below to share with your friends on Facebook, Twitter, Pinterest, or Reddit.

Share:
Related Brands

Gold Bond
May 12, 2022
Official Site
Amazon

Attitude
Feb 27, 2021
Official Site
Amazon

The Green Beaver Company
Jul 6, 2020
Official Site
Amazon

Pacifica
Jul 6, 2021
Ulta
Target
Amazon

Blume
May 12, 2021
Ulta
Amazon

Something More
Mar 1, 2022
Official Site

C.O. Bigelow
Jul 2, 2020
Official Site
Amazon

JASON
Feb 13, 2021
Target
Amazon

Natura Siberica
Mar 8, 2021
Official Site
Amazon

Ethique
May 12, 2021
Official Site
Amazon

Get our free 2023 guide and go cruelty-free for good.
Includes the complete and updated list of 350+ cruelty-free brands.
How to shop cruelty-free at drugstores, Sephora, and more.
Bonus: How to find out if a brand is cruelty-free.
Click the button below to join our mailing list and download our guide.

Get The List
Thank you for going cruelty-free and making a difference.
Explore
PRODUCTS
BRANDS
SEARCH
Read
RESOURCES
BLOG
FAQ
Connect
ABOUT
CONTACT
GET LISTED
Menu Item
Menu Item
Menu Item
Menu Item
Cruelty-Free Kitty
© 2014-2023 Cruelty-Free Kitty
Disclaimer
Privacy Policy

Jaxjacky Wed 25-Oct-23 12:12:59

I haven’t used any cosmetics for over twenty five years, my sunscreen, deodorant and shampoo are from Garnier, not tested on animals.

Germanshepherdsmum Wed 25-Oct-23 12:15:41

What about soap, shower gel, moisturiser ?

Hollyhock1 Wed 25-Oct-23 12:23:26

I think most of my cosmetics have the leaping bunny - it's what I look for. Most of my other household stuff - shampoo, washing up liquid, laundry detergent, etc also have the symbol (I buy waitrose, sainsbury, aldi home brands). The testing is still allowed in China. I was a big Liz Earl fan but she sold out to ? (Another big name) who test in China, although the LE brand says cruelty free.

Athrawes Wed 25-Oct-23 12:28:58

Thanks for posting this information. I've just been through the Cruelty-Free Kitty list and am pleased that I recognised many of the brands I use. This information will be very useful when I start Christmas shopping!

lizzypopbottle Wed 25-Oct-23 12:49:11

I've heard that any cosmetics that are marketed in China have to be tested on animals so certain manufacturers do animal testing so they can sell there. I think Max Factor do. I always used their mascara till I found out. The simplest thing is to search for companies that don't do animal testing and boycott the others.

Oldbat1 Wed 25-Oct-23 14:47:49

Yes please do remind me which Government permitted this to restart????

Mollygo Wed 25-Oct-23 15:34:09

Oldbat1

Yes please do remind me which Government permitted this to restart????

I think you know. Hopefully we’ll see Labour reverse the decision. It’s on my list of things to keep a check on.

Germanshepherdsmum Wed 25-Oct-23 16:53:36

I take the view that what was done by the government of 2019 was not done by the current government. They may have been formed by the same party but as far as I’m concerned that’s where the similarity ends.

Tillygumbo Thu 26-Oct-23 09:02:16

Thank you 25Avalon. I too thought all animal testing for cosmetics was banned. I shall be buying carefully from now on!

Sennelier1 Thu 26-Oct-23 09:22:29

I think there is a certain nuance, at least there is here in Europe - maybe different for you in the UK since Brexit. I like Yves Rocher, the French brand of care products and cosmetics. They themselves do nót test on animals, but their products are re-tested before coming on the market in China, and the Chinese test on animals. Now excuse me, but who can help what the Chinese do?

Quokka Thu 26-Oct-23 09:28:28

Germanshepherdsmum

I take the view that what was done by the government of 2019 was not done by the current government. They may have been formed by the same party but as far as I’m concerned that’s where the similarity ends.

What colour is the sun on your planet?