Gransnet forums

Chat

Manual or Automatic car?

(164 Posts)
Chrisks Sun 25-Feb-24 11:46:56

Im approaching 70 and am about to buy a car, maybe my last, lol!
Undecided whether i should go for a manual or automatic.
Any views on the subject?
Thank you.

Marydoll Wed 06-Mar-24 19:04:52

I picked up my new automatic today and after forty five years of driving manual cars, I wish I had changed years ago.

silverlining48 Thu 07-Mar-24 07:51:14

Completely agree Marydoll. Happy motoring.

FoghornLeghorn Thu 07-Mar-24 10:57:08

welbeck

so many cases of elderly people stamping on the gas in automatics, thinking it's the brake.
i was nearly impacted by one such years ago, as it mounted the pavement and literally described an arc, embedding itself into a lamp standard.
if it was a manual, it would lurch and then stall, but autos just keep on going . . .
if they survive, the drivers say, believe that the brakes failed.
examination of the vehicle proves there to be no mechanical fault, rather it was driver error.
something goes wrong, they try to brake, get flustered, press the gas in error, then press it harder, as the car is still moving . . .
i have driven autos , for work, and can see they might be easier, but i wouldn't buy one.

I agree with everything you say. Whenever you see a report in the media about somebody ‘losing control’ of their car and driving through a shop front or worse, into a bus queue you can just guarantee they were driving an automatic.

Marydoll Thu 07-Mar-24 10:59:25

I have weighed up the pros and cons. I am happy I have changed to an automatic. Horses for courses.

SueDonim Thu 07-Mar-24 14:26:52

Have fun, Marydoll! 🚗 🚙

Marydoll Fri 08-Mar-24 09:17:20

I came home last night to a note through the door from the postman. Nice car!, it said. 🤣

This morning I am going out for teh first time, I am a nervous wreck!

Janetashbolt Sat 09-Mar-24 16:41:40

Automatic. I do have a manual licence but haven't driven manual for years. We had an automatic when both my daughters got to 17 and learnt to drive. As they practised on our car they both passed an automatic test, so only drive automatics themselves and I am a named driver on both their cars

Ailidh Sat 09-Mar-24 19:36:43

This has been very helpful!

I've driven a manual car for 40 years and am just beginning to contemplate one last vehicle. It'll be second hand, can't afford a new one; plus I fancy a Mercedes Smartcar, and they've stopped making them. I'd never considered an automatic but it seems sensible from the future proofing point of view. 🚘

polomint Sat 09-Mar-24 20:12:43

Good for you marydoll. Enjoy your new car. I'm sure you won't regret driving an automatic

Marydoll Sat 09-Mar-24 20:15:45

I am loving it, but can't quite come to grips with the automatic braking system. I don't trust it yet! 🤣

SueDonim Sat 09-Mar-24 21:52:17

Marydoll

I came home last night to a note through the door from the postman. Nice car!, it said. 🤣

This morning I am going out for teh first time, I am a nervous wreck!

Ho, there’s your invitation to an affair right there, Marydoll! 😂

Marydoll Sat 09-Mar-24 22:13:25

SueDonim

Marydoll

I came home last night to a note through the door from the postman. Nice car!, it said. 🤣

This morning I am going out for teh first time, I am a nervous wreck!

Ho, there’s your invitation to an affair right there, Marydoll! 😂

He actually said I couldn't have an affair, because this car was as distinctive as the previous one and there was no hiding place in our town! 😂

Nightsky2 Sat 09-Mar-24 22:24:28

JaneJudge

I think the main advantage for me is it is easier to pull out onto busy roads

👍
Particularly if you’re a fast driver like me. Automatic every time.