Gransnet forums

Chat

Manual or Automatic car?

(164 Posts)
Chrisks Sun 25-Feb-24 11:46:56

Im approaching 70 and am about to buy a car, maybe my last, lol!
Undecided whether i should go for a manual or automatic.
Any views on the subject?
Thank you.

SueDonim Thu 29-Feb-24 18:13:20

I used to have a yellow car, too, Marydoll. I loved it.

Lots of those MG’s round here seem to be driven by ‘school gate’ mums. I guess they’re a good price and very handy for carting round multiple children and their accoutrements. smile

Marydoll Thu 29-Feb-24 19:01:04

I used to drive big cars but no need for one now I don't work.
DH's is too big for scooting around our already congested town.

I set a budget because as DH said without thinking what he was implying: You won't get your money's worth from an expensive car. Because you probably haven't long to go. 😱

Treebee Thu 29-Feb-24 19:16:02

We have a yellow car too, we will be sorry to see it go. It’s great to be so visible!
It’s a Honda Jazz and our new automatic will also be a Jazz. The new one will be a hybrid.
Wish there was a yellow option, but it’s likely to be red. The only other available colours are black, very deep blue or a greyish white.

Marydoll Thu 29-Feb-24 19:54:57

Mine is yellow Honda Jazz too, the only one in town. Everyone knows it is me!
I was driving behind a Royal Mail van this morning and a hand waved out of the driver's window.

DH tracks me from the golf course, --especially when I am not supposed to be out-'. 🤣

Marydoll Thu 29-Feb-24 20:42:04

What I should have said is that he can see my car leaving the drive from the golf course, it is so distinctive.

SueDonim Thu 29-Feb-24 21:27:36

It’s not possible to have a secret love affair when you own a yellow car! 😂

Your dh’s comment reminds me of a friend’s husband, Marydoll. Once they reached about 50-ish, whenever they bought anything new he’d say ‘That’ll see us oot’! My friend always then commented ‘Not if I have my way, it won’t.’ And she get a..y did get her own way. grin

Marydoll Thu 29-Feb-24 21:31:51

It’s not possible to have a secret love affair when you own a yellow car! 😂

Hence the true reason for changing my car! 🤣

Tenko Thu 29-Feb-24 21:40:30

I drive both and find both easy to drive. My polo is manual but my dhs truck is automatic and I easily jump from one to the other .
My AC both live in London and driving up to see them is much easier in an automatic .

crazyH Thu 29-Feb-24 22:16:37

You ladies seem to know so much about cars 🚙 🚗 🚘👍

SueDonim Thu 29-Feb-24 22:21:53

You’ve been rumbled, Marydoll! 😂

Marydoll Thu 29-Feb-24 23:54:17

SueDonim

You’ve been rumbled, Marydoll! 😂

Unfortunately! 😉

Katie59 Fri 01-Mar-24 20:11:32

I love cars and driving, we do a lot of road trips and touring at home and abroad, I’ve driven trucks, tractors, even a combine harvester.

Chrisks Sun 03-Mar-24 11:51:11

So many replies to my question! Thanks everyone.
I test drove an automatic yesterday and loved it!
Always liked a Honda Jazz so I’ll be the proud owner of a shiny black automatic one next week!

Witzend Sun 03-Mar-24 11:59:05

I’ve had both, and at times used to swop between them, no problem.

My current newish (well, newish 3 years ago!) is a manual, but dh would go for an automatic every time. I’m honestly not bothered, though admittedly an automatic is easier if you often drive in heavy urban traffic.

Farzanah Sun 03-Mar-24 13:42:51

Automatics take some stress out of long trips too.

Witzend Sun 03-Mar-24 19:02:14

Chrisks

So many replies to my question! Thanks everyone.
I test drove an automatic yesterday and loved it!
Always liked a Honda Jazz so I’ll be the proud owner of a shiny black automatic one next week!

Mine’s a Jazz - but I picked a colour that'd be easy to spot in the car park when I’ve forgotten where I left it!

silverlining48 Mon 04-Mar-24 08:37:08

It does help to have a car which stands out colourwise, making it easier to spot in a crowded car park

Marydoll Mon 04-Mar-24 08:44:28

When I was buying my new car last week, DH was panicking, when he saw me looking at an orange car! It certainly would stand out! wink

silverlining48 Mon 04-Mar-24 08:48:41

I like yellow cars

silverlining48 Mon 04-Mar-24 08:53:10

My 11 year old automatic fiesta is bright blue, not so unusual but rare enough to stand out. Saves 😱

Parsley3 Mon 04-Mar-24 09:02:16

Talking about love affairs and yellow cars, my friend thinks that private number plates are also a curb to shenanigans. Better behave if you have one of those Marydoll.

Marydoll Mon 04-Mar-24 09:10:38

I have a yellow car and a private registration! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
People always wave as I drive past, no hope of an affair. Anyway, I can't be bothered. wink

Marydoll Mon 04-Mar-24 09:18:16

My new car is a quite distinctive bright blue. I really should have picked a black one, like DH always does.

One of my previous cars was a two seater Renault Wind covertible, it was very unusual, but not very practical especially if you were having an affair. wink
I do like a quirky car.

Greyduster Mon 04-Mar-24 09:18:53

Our last two cars were automatic, the second one a hybrid. DH set his face against automatics for years (we hadn’t had one since the late seventies) until I eventually persuaded him it would be easier on his legs on long journeys. I had never driven an automatic until he became ill and I had to step up to the plate in our CRV hybrid. Loved it! I now have a Mini Cooper automatic and it’s a joy to drive. I particularly like the way you can hear it moving throatily up through the gears! Gives me a buzz!

flappergirl Mon 04-Mar-24 10:56:44

I've only ever driven manual cars (40 odd years) but did once have a test drive in an automatic. I hated it, the seeming lack of control and of course I kept reaching for the gear stick. As another poster said, I like "proper driving" and I enjoy it.

However, if my knees give up then I can totally see why an automatic is favoured by older drivers. Horses for courses.