Gransnet forums

Chat

If you can manage financially - would you pay more tax, for better public services?

(279 Posts)
Applegran Wed 29-May-24 14:11:35

I know tax is a challenging topic and both the main parties keep their heads down and say that they will not raise taxes, or will cut them further. I know few people love paying tax - but I have read more than one extremely rich person saying 'tax the rich more! We need better public services, roads, schools, environmental care.......and more!' This is a rich person asking to contribute more for the sake of the country they live in.
I am not extremely rich! but I am ok and grateful that I have a roof over my head, and do not worry about having enough food. And I would be glad to pay more tax. Tax which could give young children a better start in life, which could help people living in poverty, older people who are struggling to make ends meet, caring for the environment......we could all make a long list of things we'd like to see. And they (mostly) cost money - money from tax payers. So I'd vote to pay more tax. And also to go all out to get money from the rich tax evaders, who get away with paying too little tax, because they can. Do they ever think about the needs of others who have too little? Maybe they will........if we have any fabulously rich people on GN reading this!

Grandma70s Wed 29-May-24 16:50:32

Yes, I would pay more tax. It would be nice if I could choose what my contribution was spent on.

Germanshepherdsmum Wed 29-May-24 16:53:29

Of course, politicians could be reading this thread. They do monitor social media. Be very careful what you say …

Grandma70s Wed 29-May-24 16:57:00

Most European countries have higher tax rates than the U.K. - and better services. In Denmark it’s nearly 56%.

GrannyGravy13 Wed 29-May-24 16:57:19

Germanshepherdsmum

Of course, politicians could be reading this thread. They do monitor social media. Be very careful what you say …

They definitely read mums net as there is an article doing the social media rounds regarding what they think of Rishi Sunak…

Vintagewhine Wed 29-May-24 17:04:55

OH and I both pay 40% on part of our pensions and consider we are comfortably off. Even if we have to pay for care in the future our children will inherit a decent amount and they are treated generously whilst we're alive. We both give to our chosen charities. We think we're lucky. We've had good educations, decent jobs but we've made lots of money from our homes and the homes of our parents. I'm very happy to pay more tax and to contribute to society. Much of what we have wasn't the result of hard graft but just being born in the right place at the right time to the right parents. Inheritance tax creates such a divide between those who have and those that don't. I'd like to raise it considerably.

Katie590 Wed 29-May-24 17:38:57

Whether we like it or not, if we want to maintain services, those with wealth will have to pay, the only alternative is to cut services, maybe means testing.

We’re not going to get a choice.

winterwhite Wed 29-May-24 17:48:31

Yes.
Council tax should be rebanded with at least one prob two upper tiers. Essential, because public services financed by local councils need a broader tax base.
Health and social care need restructuring and this will cost in itself but should not be shirked and be given to a competent team who’ll stay to see it through. Dusting down the Dilnot Report might be a start. A restructured system will then need more money of course

Kim19 Wed 29-May-24 17:50:35

No because I do not believe any politician would honour the promised direction of the extra funds they raised. Promises, promises.........

Germanshepherdsmum Wed 29-May-24 17:50:57

What’s the problem with means testing Katie, if people are being given taxpayers’ money?

Cabbie21 Wed 29-May-24 17:51:38

If there were a levy to pay extra direct into the NHS, yes, rather like the Social Care levy on Council Tax.

rafichagran Wed 29-May-24 17:54:18

No is the short answer.

Applegran Wed 29-May-24 18:03:20

GSM thank you - I do already give to various charities and I agree it is an important thing to do. However, I would still be glad if all of us who can afford it were asked to pay a bit more tax. No government gets everything right - or acts just how I would choose - but it is the government which should be taking an overview to take appropriate action for the wellbeing of the whole population and acting to help people in need, and the NHS and schools and more - and all this means money. And I would prefer them to raise money from tax rather than doing more borrowing or more private finance initiatives.

Germanshepherdsmum Wed 29-May-24 18:09:57

Do you pay additional rate tax Applegran? Or just basic rate? Or none?

growstuff Wed 29-May-24 18:20:10

Germanshepherdsmum

Whitewavemark2

It is called “pulling up the ladder”

No it isn’t. It’s called having provided the ladder for more years than you care to remember, and dare I say far more of the rungs than most, and being unwilling to pay more than what is currently still demanded and will be until my last breath - when inheritance tax will rear its ugly head.

How have you provided a ladder?

growstuff Wed 29-May-24 18:21:02

`You have provided a service and charged your clients for doing so. What have you actually produced?

hollysteers Wed 29-May-24 18:32:43

Grandma70s

Most European countries have higher tax rates than the U.K. - and better services. In Denmark it’s nearly 56%.

This.

Germanshepherdsmum Wed 29-May-24 18:37:20

I have paid additional rate tax for years and I have employed people, from cleaners to secretaries to solicitors. I have trained legal executives and solicitors. I and those I have employed have also done a lot of pro bono work at an inner city law centre and mentored kids at an inner city school. Is that enough or do you want more blood?

HelterSkelter1 Wed 29-May-24 18:44:27

I would certainly pay more for road tax if it were ring fenced for pot hole repairs. Petrol/diesel prices could be increased and the increased amount ring fenced again for pot hole repairs. So those who use the roads more pay more. And it would also pick up a contribution from foreign lorries and tourists. Also using our roads. And the enormous lorries given our roads a battering.

Witzend Wed 29-May-24 18:46:34

I’d be happy to pay a bit more - if I could be 100% sure it wasn’t going to be wasted. Or spent on fashionable ‘frills’ rather than basic services.

Joseann Wed 29-May-24 19:06:59

The money has to come from somewhere, so yes, I would.
Inheritance tax, no, over my dead body.

mumofmadboys Wed 29-May-24 19:12:13

I would be happy to pay more tax towards public services.

Applegran Wed 29-May-24 19:21:16

GSM you ask about my tax and I pay basic rate income tax.

Allsorts Wed 29-May-24 19:24:33

I’ve never paid 40 per cent tax but paid my dues. All donations gratefully received. I worked since I was 15 so I’ve given enough,

silverlining48 Wed 29-May-24 19:26:59

Yes I would. For the greater good.
Those in other European countries pay a lot more tax than us which is probably why their public services are better.

GrannyGravy13 Wed 29-May-24 19:27:08

I have zero confidence in any of the current cohort or those hoping for office to spend in a way which benefits the people of the UK.

None of the parties are showing that they have the cajunas for much wanted reorganisation of services here, including NHS.