Gransnet forums

Chat

Why do Interviewers talk over Interviewees ?

(59 Posts)
NotSpaghetti Mon 03-Jun-24 10:13:58

Marmin

I suspect it might be a reaction to interviewees that are clearly not answering the question.

Exactly this!

maddyone Mon 03-Jun-24 10:09:52

Fiona Bruce on Question Time does this all the time, particularly to Conservative panel members, or more right wing panel members. The Labour panel members are allowed to speak freely. I noticed last week that she was particularly bad with the Conservative politician. We want to hear all the points of view, even if we disagree with them.
I dislike her on Question Time and wish she would be removed and replaced with someone who would let all the panel members speak.

Marmin Mon 03-Jun-24 10:00:30

I suspect it might be a reaction to interviewees that are clearly not answering the question.

PamelaJ1 Mon 03-Jun-24 09:56:58

I think it must be a memory problem.
They have forgotten what their job description is.
Very irritating.

Sparklefizz Mon 03-Jun-24 09:46:41

Naga Munchetty on BBC Breakfast is one of the worst. I can't stand her.

eazybee Mon 03-Jun-24 09:44:35

You have answered your own question.
It is a tried and tested technique of the Today programme, and other BBC interviewers, to ask a question and then deliberately talk over the interviewee so that their answer is not heard and/or deliberately interrupted. Emma Barnett did exactly that on Woman's Hour; as far as she was concerned it was an audition for Today.

Nick Robinson, who considers himself the BBC's greatest asset, wrote in newspapers posing the same question to try to discover why listener numbers were falling without the slightest inking that he, and others of his ilk, were the problem.
We are not interested in the interviewer but they they are; making themselves the story is the biggest crime in journalism.

BigBertha1 Mon 03-Jun-24 09:43:43

I always thought Michael Parkinson was guilty of this. Never understood his appeal.

Germanshepherdsmum Mon 03-Jun-24 09:40:42

They all want to be the next Paxman I think.

NanKate Mon 03-Jun-24 09:27:41

I was trying to listen to an interview this morning on BBC Sounds between Mishal Husain and Kemi Badenoch, about the Conservatives pledging to rewrite the equality laws to define sex as biological, an important subject. It was a total disaster imo. Questions were asked and Kemi started to reply and was constantly spoken over for the rest of the interview.

Even Emma Barnett, who was so good at interviewing on Woman’s Hour, now uses the same technique on the Today programme.