Gransnet forums

Chat

What if we'd had to do National Service?

(42 Posts)
Glorianny Wed 05-Jun-24 20:36:28

My older brother just missed out on having to do NS. But I was wondering if we had had to do it, and had a choice, as Sunak seems to be saying they will offer young people, what would I have done? I was an even more passionate pacifist then so the forces would have been out. I don't think the NHS would have benefitted from my rather incompetent abilities and wouldn't have liked my ability to break things. I suppose I might have helped with children, but couldn't have handled any real problems.
If you'd had to do it what would you have done and did you have skills at that age that would have been useful?

M0nica Thu 06-Jun-24 21:34:59

The forces do have quite high eyesight standards, and it applies to everyone, even those in jobs where they are never likely to see action. I toyed with the army for a career, but then realised my eyesight was too bad, ditto DS in his one short deviation from the career he chose at the age 4. DH had intended to join the Royal Navy Ship Design Branch. They all resided in an office block in Bath, but aagain he was turned down because of his poor eyesight.

LOUISA1523 Thu 06-Jun-24 21:39:45

When I did my nurse training in Portsmouth in the 80s we had 4 girls on our cohort training to be nurses with the Navy .... their uniforms were nothing like ours ....they looked very smart though ....and they were paid more than the rest of us!

annodomini Thu 06-Jun-24 22:40:49

I'd always wanted to fly. If I'd had the chance to join the RAF, I'm sure I'd have grabbed it with both hands! Just as well that National Service ended just as I left school.

biglouis Fri 07-Jun-24 01:47:00

I cannot see myself doing any of these "civic" activities. I was always far too independent and bolshy to take easily to being told what to do by so called "authority figures" . When I meet a set of rules my reaction is to look for ways to manipulate them to my benefit.

I dont like children so anything involving them would be out.

Cant stand hearing about other peoples ailments so caring would be out.

It would have to have been something involving research, fine detail or analysis.

Dingleberry Fri 07-Jun-24 05:02:59

In the late 50's and early 60's many of my friends were conscripted into the forces for two years. I was a bit younger than they were so missed out. I did think of voluntary joining the airforce with another friend but my parents said no. I was losing so many friends to conscription so decided I wanted to help in other ways, to become a police woman, my parents said no, I then decided to work at a mental hospital due to staff shortages, my parents said no.

I honestly think I was just looking for something to fill the time as the friends who were conscripted were treated like heroes when they came home on leave in their lovely uniforms, looking so smart and important. Then I discovered the Town Hall Saturday night rock n roll dances, I settled down in my 9 to 5 jobs as a shorthand typist and never looked back. My friend who had voluntarily joined the airforce, met her boyfriend there and they married and she said joining up was the best thing she ever did and she had a fantastic experience.

Perhaps in this era now when war could be looming once again, I would dread our grandchildren being conscripted but it sounds as though it is not the type of conscription that happened so many years ago. To be honest, it sounds a bit of a mess really, they can go if they want or not go and do community service instead. If they do bring back conscription then every person of a certain age is affected and do not have the right to refuse to go.

mae13 Fri 07-Jun-24 09:30:26

I think Pam Ayres used to be in the WRAF. Just an irrelevant point.

Curtaintwitcher Fri 07-Jun-24 09:32:13

I think I would have enjoyed it. My father was in the forces and I grew up on military camps, so it was what I was used to.
When you enlist, your skills are assessed and you are assigned the section most suited to you.
Military life is well organised and disciplined. It gives young people a good foundation for their adult lives.

Maggiemaybe Fri 07-Jun-24 09:48:26

I applied to join the Wrens, thinking I’d be off to see the world. When I found out that I’d likely be UK office based, I took myself off to live in Germany instead.

I don’t think a year before that doing some sort of community service would have done me any harm. Whether I’d have been an asset at that age is another matter.

Elusivebutterfly Fri 07-Jun-24 11:27:33

I read recently that National Service was a 2 year nightmare for nerdy, PE hating kids, so that would be me, if I had to serve in the forces. I would have been happy to serve in the NHS, or other caring role. As a child I wanted to be a nurse, and I later worked in the NHS.
National Service would actually have been good for me as it would have stopped me marrying at 19, which was not a good idea in the long run.

Grantanow Fri 07-Jun-24 15:19:41

Perhaps a spell of National Service would keep Sunak out of trouble.

Glorianny Fri 07-Jun-24 15:30:37

Grantanow

Perhaps a spell of National Service would keep Sunak out of trouble.

grin

Grandma70s Fri 07-Jun-24 15:53:42

The thought of anything to do with the armed forces fills me with horror, so that’s out. I have no practical ability, so nursing is out. I have quite a good academic brain, so I suppose I could have used that in some way, but the thought of being told what to do by officious people is horrible.

hollysteers Fri 07-Jun-24 18:21:44

In my teens, my best friend tried to persuade me to join the WRENS with her. I so admired her, she was my exact opposite, but decided not to. Just as well I think, as my arty nature I’m sure would not have taken to it.

This reminds me of an Israeli guide in Jerusalem who said he could never envisage marrying a woman who had not served in the army.

biglouis Fri 07-Jun-24 18:31:14

I always hated anything to do with sport and PE so I would probably have found some Machiavellian way to avoid being "conscripted".

Grandma70s Fri 07-Jun-24 18:38:43

biglouis

I always hated anything to do with sport and PE so I would probably have found some Machiavellian way to avoid being "conscripted".

Me too, biglouis.

Cumbrianmale56 Mon 10-Jun-24 15:12:40

I considered the RAF, had enough qualifications to be an officer, but a weak chest prevented me from joining. Probably for the best as I had an asthma attack when I was 25 that would have ended my career. It could have been a good career as the pay was good, the RAF still had stations in exotic places like Hong Kong, and you could leave with a pension at 37. Had a mate at work who did 22 years, reaching the rank of fligh sergeant, and said it was the best career he ever had.