Gransnet forums

Chat

How much would you pay for a coat?

(153 Posts)
Cabbie21 Sun 19-Jan-25 11:38:56

Actually, please don't answer that. This is not an inquisition nor is it meant to be judgmental.

There is an old saying "Cut your coat according to your cloth" which is said to mean Live within your means, or Make the most of the money you have. I agree with both interpretations.

My son recently spent over £400 on a coat. He can afford it. So could I if I wanted to, I suppose, but, to use an old Yorkshire word, I couldn't thoil to do so ( = couldn't bring myself to ). I paid just £40 for one recently, as it was heavily discounted in the sales.
My daughter paid £10 for a Vinted one, good quality, as new.
We are all happy with our purchases.
In this case, it was not a question of " You get what you pay for".
Could you bring yourself to spend £400 on something you could get for £40 or even £10?

( Yes, I know some people cannot afford even £10. This is not a about poverty ).

GrannyGravy13 Sun 19-Jan-25 19:07:31

escaped

I'm coming back as a handbag designer!

I will join you 👜

Maybe that’s why my daughter-in-laws are so nice to me 😹😹😹

Pantglas2 Sun 19-Jan-25 19:07:10

Over the last decadeI spent so much time in Spanish markets and never spent more than 25€ on a handbag but I don’t blame GG for her affordable indulgence!

I once paid £120 for a stunning ivory raincoat but it worked out at less than 50p on a cost per use - I gave it to a charity shop after it went out of fashion but wish now I’d altered it into a more up to date style.

escaped Sun 19-Jan-25 19:01:59

I'm coming back as a handbag designer!

GrannyGravy13 Sun 19-Jan-25 19:00:36

Claremont

I could spend 400 on a coat- perhaps. Actually, no, I dont think so. On a handbag? No, absolutely not- whether I could or not afford it. I find is obscene.

How much would you be prepared to pay for a handbag?

I have one which cost four figures 16 years ago.

It is in pristine condition, still with original dust bag and receipt.

It is now worth three times what I (DH) paid.

Claremont Sun 19-Jan-25 18:57:16

I could spend 400 on a coat- perhaps. Actually, no, I dont think so. On a handbag? No, absolutely not- whether I could or not afford it. I find is obscene.

How much would you be prepared to pay for a handbag?

ViceVersa Sun 19-Jan-25 18:57:00

Doodledog

I'm sure there is a parable from economics or politics called something like 'the good boots theory', which means that a good pair of boots will last for years, but cost a lot so a poor man can't afford to buy them, and instead buys cheap ones which wear out quickly. Over the life of the rich man's boots the poor man has to buy several pairs, which cost him far more in the long run. It is used to illustrate that poverty can deny the poor 'sensible' economic choices and keep them poor.

The same applies to coats.

Yes, that's the 'Vimes Boots Theory' from Terry Pratchett's Discworld series.
"The reason that the rich were so rich, Vimes reasoned, was because they managed to spend less money. Take boots, for example. ... A really good pair of leather boots cost fifty dollars. But an affordable pair of boots, which were sort of OK for a season or two and then leaked like hell when the cardboard gave out, cost about ten dollars. ... But the thing was that good boots lasted for years and years. A man who could afford fifty dollars had a pair of boots that'd still be keeping his feet dry in ten years' time, while a poor man who could only afford cheap boots would have spent a hundred dollars on boots in the same time and would still have wet feet."

escaped Sun 19-Jan-25 18:54:10

I recently bought a coat for a special Christening, (well all Christenings are special actually!), but I'm not saying the price. It is made from virgin wool, which comes from the first shearing, so is very soft and warm. It also has some angora in it. It was made in Serbia, and the wool was dyed in Italy, so I think I've got what I paid rather dearly for. I've not long retired, so it will have to see me out. My dog walking coats are ancient.

Doodledog Sun 19-Jan-25 18:51:03

I'm sure there is a parable from economics or politics called something like 'the good boots theory', which means that a good pair of boots will last for years, but cost a lot so a poor man can't afford to buy them, and instead buys cheap ones which wear out quickly. Over the life of the rich man's boots the poor man has to buy several pairs, which cost him far more in the long run. It is used to illustrate that poverty can deny the poor 'sensible' economic choices and keep them poor.

The same applies to coats.

dogsmother Sun 19-Jan-25 18:44:44

A sale bargain for less than £100 about three years ago, a long black duvet style coat from thought. Love all they do.

Kim19 Sun 19-Jan-25 18:44:37

I once spent silly money on a mohair dressing gown from France. However here it is still worn daily after 27 years. It is so cosy and classy and I love it. Not so expensive after all but I really had no idea it would last this long. A treasure indeed.

petra Sun 19-Jan-25 18:43:28

When friends mention that they’ve seen something expensive but feel guilty for buying it I say, can you afford it ( it’s always yes)
I say to them: Get it and forget it.

HelterSkelter1 Sun 19-Jan-25 18:28:06

Wyllow3. Check your Seasalt labels. I too thought my wool sweaters, tee shirts and 2 waterproof coats were made in the UK.
But the coats are made in Vietnam, the sweaters in Bangladesh and the tees in India.
They are still lovely..but not made in Cornwall as I did think once upon a time.

ViceVersa Sun 19-Jan-25 18:13:09

Barleyfields

If you don’t buy cheap clothes you can save money for better ones. Buy well, buy once. Buy cheap, buy twice (at least). So many people seem to buy a lot of cheap clothes. Just stop and save the money for something better. You won’t regret it.

That's all well and good, but says something happens to your only coat and you desperately need a new one. You may not have any option other than to buy a cheap one. Most of my clothes were very cheap and have lasted me for years. I'm currently wearing a top I got from Matalan which is older than my son, and he's 30 this year. I will literally wear things until they are falling to pieces.

JamesandJon33 Sun 19-Jan-25 18:09:25

A good winter coat ,I suppose between £100-200. But look on ebay or other such sites. Two years ago I bought a wonderful Loden coat, practically new for £80. from eBay.

Barleyfields Sun 19-Jan-25 18:07:21

If you don’t buy cheap clothes you can save money for better ones. Buy well, buy once. Buy cheap, buy twice (at least). So many people seem to buy a lot of cheap clothes. Just stop and save the money for something better. You won’t regret it.

ViceVersa Sun 19-Jan-25 18:01:38

The problem with that is that you have to be able to afford the 'good' coat in the first place.

M0nica Sun 19-Jan-25 17:59:39

crosstitchfan
I am lucky enough to be able to afford nice things but would never spend that much! Why would I when there are plenty of lovely coats about that are much cheaper.

Thats the problem, if you want a good quality 100% wool coat, then it is going to cost a lot. There are not any available at lower pices. I have several quilted coats/jackets, which cost substanatially less than £100. One of them I have had for well over 15 years, but I do like, and want one good quality coat and it was a shock to me when I went to buy one this year to find how much the price had shot up.

But one is in a quandary, buy something really low price and it could be being made by sweated labour or children working 60+ hours a week in China or Bangladesh., alternatively the quality can be so bad, it only lasts a year or two. A new cheap coat every 2 years costs as much as one good coat every 10 years.

MissAdventure Sun 19-Jan-25 17:47:10

Here's hoping for a long and healthy life for your coat. smile

Mikkima Sun 19-Jan-25 17:42:17

My last winter Coat was £ 40.OO from Asda, it lasted 5yrs before looking a little thin and worn around the edges .In December I bought a new winter coat from M& S for £90.00 I hope it lasts a long, long time. I haven't suddenly become wealthy, I had a big birthday and was lucky enough to receive vouchers and cash which enabled me to buy it. It's the best coat (and most expensive )I've ever bought. It was a shock to see it at half price in the post-Christmas sales but when I realised they only had sizes 6+8 left I felt better. I've not been that size since I was in primary
school !grin

Labradora Sun 19-Jan-25 17:13:09

GrannyGravy13

Cabbie21 I have a weakness for handbags, I am fortunate that I can afford them, I also drop very unsubtle hints to DH, leaving pictures of bags I have an eye on.

Would I buy one on vinted or eBay? only if the provenance was indisputable.

No disrespect intended , Granny Gravy as your hard-earned is yours to spend as you see fit, but one thing that has struck me as absolutely barking in the past roughly 20 years is the price some people are prepared to pay for handbags.
e.g. £4000 for a "a handbag"(Lady Bracknall voice🤣😘).
Who pays thousands of pounds for a handbag ......
😕 ??????

NanKate Sun 19-Jan-25 17:05:38

I like the colourful clothes from Sahara but they are very expensive. Two years ago I popped into their sale and bought a half price top for £64 ! I have worn it time and time again and don’t regret a penny of it.

Norah Sun 19-Jan-25 16:46:08

I like quality coats, own many. Price is not a deciding factor, I know we're lucky in that regard. I'm quite careful, result many are ancient.

MissAdventure Sun 19-Jan-25 16:42:18

I'm less and less interested in clothes as time goes on.

As long as I put something on, and it goes around me, I don't even look at myself, these days.

So, no point at all paying for anything fancy.
An anorak will do.

Whitewavemark2 Sun 19-Jan-25 16:36:06

In the past I have paid quite a bit for my coats and have long 3/4 and short coats of various colours - but all cashmere and wool. Consequently I shall probably never need to buy a coat again!

I do however, buy what were walking the dog coats and now just walking coats 😥.

My latest one was a padded red/brick corduroy from poetry.

I am really in the market for a wet weather waterproof. Haven’t really looked much though.

NonGrannyMoll Sun 19-Jan-25 16:33:47

I hate being fleeced for over-priced "quality" items, be it clothes or anything else. (And no, I'm not a Yorkshire woman, I'm from London, argh, hold up the garlic!) If I have spare cash I try not to fritter it away. And why tell someone how much a thing cost? Is that a kind of my-thing's-bigger-than-your-thing kind of boasting, or what?