Gransnet forums

Chat

Does anyone else feel like we’re living like a dystopian novel?

(121 Posts)
FriedGreenTomatoes2 Fri 11-Jul-25 10:31:51

The government Ministers this week said they were trialling new state-funded restaurants that would serve meals for as little as £3 in Nottingham and Dundee. The diners, which have received £1.5m of taxpayer funding, will resemble the subsidised civic kitchens of the 1940s.

Peter Kyle, the Science and Technology Secretary, said the aim was to “actively explore the best ways to get healthy food into the mouths of those who need it”. The trial could lead to the launch of similar schemes if successful.

Taxing companies out of business and replacing them by a highly inefficient wasteful government alternative? Wait... That's not socialism. That's communism!

What do you think about this latest ‘initiative’?

GrannyGravy13 Fri 11-Jul-25 12:21:41

Whitewavemark2 yes honestly, there is so much information out there regarding nutrition and food preparation unless someone is disabled (mentally or physically) it’s surely better to be cooking and preparing yours and your family’s food.

The UK shouldn’t need to nanny state meals in the 21st century.

Elowen33 Fri 11-Jul-25 12:25:01

Great idea for the many families that are in temporary accommodation and only have access to a shared kitchen with limited facilities.

Whitewavemark2 Fri 11-Jul-25 12:26:45

Of course there is, but we are talking about children in abject poverty living with mouldy food and rats and no different to the poverty you would find in Victorian Britain.

They can’t afford a book! Let alone the ingredients or fuel.

I agree that some people eat a poor nutritional diet through choice or ignorance, but this is not what I am talking about, and neither are those setting up the restaurants.

TillyTrotter Fri 11-Jul-25 12:27:33

PS welcome back fgt have missed you. Hope your DH is on a treatment which will give him quality of life again 🍀

Whitewavemark2 Fri 11-Jul-25 12:29:09

And I absolutely agree about no nannying in such a rich country.

Therefore I propose that the minimum wage be raised to a living wage.
Rents capped
And benefits sufficient to sustain those needing to use them.

Galaxy Fri 11-Jul-25 12:32:41

Yes I had a different opinion to the experts on 'gender affirming' care for children, I was also quite worried about the idea that vaping was a solution to smoking without having any issues of its own, its quite useful to question ideas. That isn't to say I have all the answers (although obviously I do 😃) but in particular those who are experts on nutrition have over the years had ideas that would have really benefitted from some level of challenge.

Skydancer Fri 11-Jul-25 12:42:51

GrannyGravy13

I could say, but I would rather not be banned 🤬

Same here. Who dreams up this stuff!

nanna8 Fri 11-Jul-25 12:43:43

We go to one of the student run restaurants here from time to time. It ain’t cheap,though. Went to one with some friends last week and it was lovely food and cocktails but at market prices. I remember in the 70 s the Hare Krishnas used to run a restaurant in town that was very,very cheap and very healthy food,too. We used to go there when the kids were very young and you got a big feed which we would not have been able to afford normally.
Are they talking about soup kitchens ? They are usually free and many towns have them.

windmill1 Fri 11-Jul-25 12:55:58

Whitewavemark2

And I absolutely agree about no nannying in such a rich country.

Therefore I propose that the minimum wage be raised to a living wage.
Rents capped
And benefits sufficient to sustain those needing to use them.

Hear! Hear!

windmill1 Fri 11-Jul-25 12:58:28

And it hardly seems fair for The Commons and The Lords to have a choice of subsidised restaurants on top of the lavish salaries.

Usedtobeblonde Fri 11-Jul-25 13:00:35

Last Christmas I went with a friend to a Christmas meal at Trafford college of Further Education.
They have a lovely restaurant called Aspire.
As well as cooking it for other aspects of hospitality.
Everything from being greeted, shown to a table, orders being taken and meals served was by advanced students.
It was all superb.
It was less than £30 for a three course meal.
Drinks were also available.
This particular occasion was organised by the local Rotary club ,who I am assured gave a very good tip to the college staff who supervised, for the students.
I do not suppose anyone was out of pocket so decent meals can be provided at decent cost.
Of course you still need money to go!,

Homestead62 Fri 11-Jul-25 13:03:57

I thought it was what community centre cafes already did.

nanna8 Fri 11-Jul-25 13:05:51

Just curious but if you go out to say an average restaurant, how much would it normally cost in the UK? 🇬🇧
It varies here because some places have cheaper ‘senior’s meals’ which are about 2/3 the normal price or less. Average would be around $40 a head for a full cost meal plus drinks which are quite expensive these days, though you can often BYO and just pay corkage of a couple of dollars.

Calendargirl Fri 11-Jul-25 13:08:34

I think back to school dinners in the 50’s and early 60’s.

5 shillings a week, (25 pence), unless, like my DH from a large and poorish family, you were entitled to free school meals.

A proper meat and veg main meal, plus pudding, and water to drink. No junk or processed food.

Yes, I know they were subsidised, but you didn’t hear about food banks and hungry children so much back then.

Fast forward 60 or so years, and this is progress?

🤷‍♀️

nanna8 Fri 11-Jul-25 13:14:06

Yes, I was never given fruit juice or cordial as a child. Always water or very milky coffee ( mum was a ‘coffee snob’ and ground her own ) The food was very plain, though, compared with now.

Whitewavemark2 Fri 11-Jul-25 13:15:17

Calendargirl

I think back to school dinners in the 50’s and early 60’s.

5 shillings a week, (25 pence), unless, like my DH from a large and poorish family, you were entitled to free school meals.

A proper meat and veg main meal, plus pudding, and water to drink. No junk or processed food.

Yes, I know they were subsidised, but you didn’t hear about food banks and hungry children so much back then.

Fast forward 60 or so years, and this is progress?

🤷‍♀️

There was much less inequality during that period

Granatlast007 Fri 11-Jul-25 13:15:51

Whitewavemark2

And I absolutely agree about no nannying in such a rich country.

Therefore I propose that the minimum wage be raised to a living wage.
Rents capped
And benefits sufficient to sustain those needing to use them.

I love your posts WW2 and usually agree with them but are you really confident that the money given out through a higher living wage would be spent on food?
There are so many outlets selling cheap, highly unnutritious food and the temptations of vaping, drugs, cheap plastic imports of stuff none of us need and so on.

I get a bit annoyed about people not knowing how to cook, I think they still teach cooking in the National Curriculum?
As to access to cooking fuel and equipment, yes, the housing market needs to be well and truly sorted out.
I do feel I live in a dystopian world, all the above plus people enjoying the heat while the earth burns!!

HelterSkelter1 Fri 11-Jul-25 13:17:46

I so agree windmill1. Subsidised meals and drinks for MPs is laughable. And sooo unfair. I expect certain MPs would not see the irony when they declare "nanny state".

I will read the rest of the informative and balanced posts with my lunch which I am lucky to be able to prepare in a kitchen with cooking facilities unlike many families living in temporary accommodation for whatever reason.

Teazel2 Fri 11-Jul-25 13:25:50

windmill1

And it hardly seems fair for The Commons and The Lords to have a choice of subsidised restaurants on top of the lavish salaries.

Good point.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Fri 11-Jul-25 13:33:41

👋 TillyTrotter I’m enjoying being back again. 😁

Whitewavemark2 Fri 11-Jul-25 13:35:26

Granatlast007

Whitewavemark2

And I absolutely agree about no nannying in such a rich country.

Therefore I propose that the minimum wage be raised to a living wage.
Rents capped
And benefits sufficient to sustain those needing to use them.

I love your posts WW2 and usually agree with them but are you really confident that the money given out through a higher living wage would be spent on food?
There are so many outlets selling cheap, highly unnutritious food and the temptations of vaping, drugs, cheap plastic imports of stuff none of us need and so on.

I get a bit annoyed about people not knowing how to cook, I think they still teach cooking in the National Curriculum?
As to access to cooking fuel and equipment, yes, the housing market needs to be well and truly sorted out.
I do feel I live in a dystopian world, all the above plus people enjoying the heat while the earth burns!!

No of course I am not and neither is anyone else, but that can’t possibly be an argument for not giving people a living wage.

In fact NGOs are beginning to understand that £for£ it is much better spent giving people the cash rather than stuff, as they (the poor) are in a much better position to know what they need and what to spend the money on.

And yes I agree the domestic science education in the U.K. is abysmal.

I also think our culture has something to do with it.

I was watching children of all ages eating in French restaurants and almost everything on the daily menu would not have been deemed suitable for our children. How after do you see “children’s” menus with fish fingers, chicken nuggets and baked beans.
I have also seen a television programme detailing the French children’s s school lunches. My goodness what a world of difference.

The French children were digging into the plat de jour with gusto - piled high with salads, various fish and pudding considered far too sophisticated for our children who generally make do with ice cream etc.

Of course there will now be posters come on to say what fantastic food their grandchildren eat, but we are not talking about those children, but children from a poor snd disadvantaged background.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Fri 11-Jul-25 13:41:05

windmill1

And it hardly seems fair for The Commons and The Lords to have a choice of subsidised restaurants on top of the lavish salaries.

Definitely agree with this comment windmill! They get paid a wage (or an allowance). When we were all at work we had to buy our own lunches didn’t we?

Illustrates the gap though between the haves and the have nots.

At this rate going forward it’s going to be like that book/film “Hunger Games”. Elites in safe gated communities away from the rabble outside their compounds.

nanna8 Fri 11-Jul-25 13:59:48

The Handmaid’s Tale recycled ? I used to think Orwell’s 1984 was bad but now we have surpassed it in many ways.

Granatlast007 Fri 11-Jul-25 14:02:10

WW2, if I say that the French do everything better, I'll probably get it in the neck but I do admire them.
They don't eat snacks, they sit at tables and TALK, the children sit up and eat with knives and forks and are taught early to speak politely to adults.
A admirable nation in so many ways.

Norah Fri 11-Jul-25 14:24:22

Perhaps the minimum wage should be raised, at less cost to taxpayers.