Gransnet forums

Chat

Enjoying anticipation, or a complete surprise!

(30 Posts)
Schnackie2 Mon 03-Nov-25 14:54:42

I have never liked to be 'surprised' whether a party, or visit from someone. My late mum was the same, and my 44 yr old DD is as well, so maybe it runs in the family. But I love the period of anticipation leading up to a happy event, whether it is a party, day out, or visit from family. I think about what I will wear, if I need to visit the hairdresser, etc. Fortunately we are a small family so surprises rarely occur.

Now, in the past year my DD and DSIL have gotten divorced. Very amicable, not able to discuss details, but good relationship. They live close to each other and DGS 12 and DGD 11 spend a week with each parent. Yesterday my daughter told me that her mother-in-law who lives across the country (USA) has announced that she is bringing her other 3 grandchildren ( who live near her) to visit her son and my (our) 2 grandchildren, and she wants it to be a surprise!! This will occur during the week between Christmas and New Year, and the children will all have a wonderful time. Unfortunately it just happens that it would normally be the week that my daughter has the children, and on top of that, she works at a university and will be off that week. I should add, that DSIL asked my DD if this would be ok with her, and she told me that she replied quickly 'of course', and since then has thought more about it.

OBVIOUSLY I am keeping my nose out and I'm sure it will be fine, as my DD gets along with her former in-laws and the cousins, so she will get to spend time with the kids, and she and DSIL will make alternate arrangements to make up for the time. It has just caused me to wonder, if others think a big surprise like this is a great idea, or do you prefer the anticipation. Sorry for the long post.

Cabbie21 Tue 04-Nov-25 19:53:05

I don’t like surprises. Fortunately my family have never sprung any on me. Sometimes I have pre-empted the possibility by arranging something myself.

Casdon Tue 04-Nov-25 20:11:39

M0nica

Casdon

I’m talking about surprises where you know on the day M0nica, for example when I get a message saying ‘we’re out tonight, wear jeans and a warm coat’. I would like a surprise party too, I’d find that much less stressful than thinking about it for months in advance. It’s not a surprise, as you say, if you get given tickets for something weeks or months ahead. Obviously unexpected bad things happen too, and nobody likes those, but I took the original thread to mean events.

But what happens when the surprise is jumped on you when you are already committed to something else that evening and you cannot reorganise, or even an evening when you were actually looking forward to a quiet evening at home because you were really tired, or feeling slightly less than well?

I can deal with the unexpected and I do not lack spontanaity, but I hate surprises.

It’s not happened, because they find out what I’m doing without me realising I’ve been sounded out I guess. I can’t imagine turning down the chance to do something because I’m tired, because once I’m out I forget about the tiredness until I get home. I’m sure I can’t be alone in this?

CanadianGran Tue 04-Nov-25 20:38:29

I have mixed feelings. I always do enjoy them when they happen to me, but then I have a few very organized family members who would make sure everything was taken care of, and that you were dressed for the event (some other excuse made up).

For instance, I retired at the end of March. I had a nice luncheon at work, and knew DH had planned a dinner with friends. I didn't realize that the dinner included all the family, some friends, and some of the long time work mates came as well. There was a lovely speech and some gifts. It was unexpected, but I still think of it with warm memories.

On the other hand, for my late MIL's 90th birthday, my SIL planned a surprise party for her. I was against it, just because it can be so overwhelming, and because of her age. Once again, she knew she was going out for a nice lunch at a fancy hotel, but didn't expect all her neighbours, church group, etc. She had a lovely time; was the belle of the ball, so to speak. So I was wrong to be against it, just because it was so well planned.

sazz1 Wed 05-Nov-25 12:35:16

I love surprise visitors who just knock the door without phoning or messaging. As a child we never had visitors and often weren't allowed to answer the door to anyone for reasons I can't go into here. All my family have an open door policy except my DIL who is on the appointments system. One friend is also on appointments often a week in advance. Can't really be bothered with that.
I visit to see people not how nice their home is, and my visitors accept me as I am or don't need to bother coming.