Gransnet forums

Chat

Burlesque? Am I just out of touch?

(84 Posts)
Granatlast007 Fri 14-Nov-25 09:37:13

I was a bit surprised recently to find our local WI had invited a young woman called Ivy Malice to do a presentation. I googled her and and struggled to understand what the difference was between burlesque and a nicer version of stripping.

Her performance was all about corsets, 'tasteful' stripping to show stockings, suspenders, high heels, lots of make up and lots of flesh while prancing about. I couldn't be bothered to go to the meeting on the basis of what I googled but after the event, members I have asked seemed to have loved it and want to ask her back.

I suppose it's not for me and as a once ardent feminist, I thought we women had rid ourselves of dressing up in attire which is surely about attracting men in the most basic way possible?

Apparently though burlesque now is about 'body positivity and self-love and about self-expression in the most vulnerable way possible. I am puzzled, perhaps I need to get out more! Anyone else?

AmberGran Sat 15-Nov-25 14:18:11

Galaxy

We don't get to choose but we do get to analyse whether it is a feminist choice. The same nonsense is said about all sorts of things S & M,
prostitution, etc. The thing about choices is they are rarely done in a vacuum.

What the heck is a feminist choice???? Who gets to choose? And why do they get to choose?

kittylester Sat 15-Nov-25 14:32:54

And who said we all had to be 'feminist' what ever that might mean.

Mollygo Sat 15-Nov-25 14:52:52

StripeyGran

WI didn't work for me. Nothing to do with sex. More to do with bags on seats and " My sister sits there"

That’s so irritating.
Likewise, shopping this morning, I‘d just collected a small trolley when this woman rushed up and made to grab it, saying, “That’s my trolley!” confused

Galaxy Sat 15-Nov-25 15:06:50

We aren't choosing we are commenting. You don't have to be feminist I couldn't care less. But many feminists comment on these issues from that perspective.

Jackiest Sat 15-Nov-25 16:17:17

I have decided I am not a feminist I am a personist. I don't want to look at things just from my point of view.

StripeyGran Sat 15-Nov-25 17:13:58

Mollygo

StripeyGran

WI didn't work for me. Nothing to do with sex. More to do with bags on seats and " My sister sits there"

That’s so irritating.
Likewise, shopping this morning, I‘d just collected a small trolley when this woman rushed up and made to grab it, saying, “That’s my trolley!” confused

I think t'is rapidly approaching the season for this type of thing.
Am extremely old lady ( yes more than me) once practically wrestled a bag of sprouts from my grip in M and S.

Kamiso Sun 16-Nov-25 14:14:02

StripeyGran

WI didn't work for me. Nothing to do with sex. More to do with bags on seats and " My sister sits there"

That’s what the local U3A meetings were like. L found them irritating but amusing at the same time until I came across a woman with tears in her eyes. Widowed six months ago and her first lone venture out told three times she couldn’t sit in certain seats. Very off putting!

AuntieE Sun 16-Nov-25 14:23:10

It certainly sounds an odd choice for WI.

It might go down better with a younger age group.

Recently, I went to a concert, where a young woman (in her thirties) sang popular songs quite well, but interspersed her program of songs with jokes that I not only found unamusing but embarrassing.

And no, they were neither blue, nor sexy. She told jokes about greasy hair, blackheads , etc.- all turned towards herself, admittedly. People, mainly those her age or under fifty, were laughing their heads off, but I failed to see what is remotely amusing about dirty nails, blackheads, dandruff or greasy hair.

Came to the conclusion that I am just an auld wife wi' no sense of humour.

hollysteers Sun 16-Nov-25 14:36:12

I agree with you eazybee. I don’t find burlesque at all offensive, in fact I find it erotic and sensual and I’m straight! Same with a good belly dancer. More erotic than complete stripping, porn or nudity.
I loved my visit to the Moulin Rouge in Paris where the dancers looked fabulous and left a lot to the imagination.
With forward thinking views, we need to watch out we don’t end up against more than we are for, tending towards narrow mindedness.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Sun 16-Nov-25 14:58:35

I loved my visit to the Moulin Rouge in Paris where the dancers looked fabulous and left a lot to the imagination

Me too hollysteers!
The imagination is a thing of wonder.

sandelf Sun 16-Nov-25 14:58:36

Oh what have we come to. The WI being 'entertained'?! by burlesque.... (Head in hands).

icanhandthemback Sun 16-Nov-25 15:01:42

I went with the local Trefoil group because my mother had a spare ticket. It wasn't what I expected and I didn't really enjoy it but the other ladies seemed to love it. To be honest, quite a lot of women seem to like a strip show by males but I can't quite get my head around that either. I don't object to anybody removing their clothes if it is something they enjoy doing but I just find it that enjoyable to watch!

Maremia Sun 16-Nov-25 15:32:05

Those women who became famous as the Calendar Girls, were they WI?

StripeyGran Sun 16-Nov-25 15:32:11

Kamiso

StripeyGran

WI didn't work for me. Nothing to do with sex. More to do with bags on seats and " My sister sits there"

That’s what the local U3A meetings were like. L found them irritating but amusing at the same time until I came across a woman with tears in her eyes. Widowed six months ago and her first lone venture out told three times she couldn’t sit in certain seats. Very off putting!

Poor lady.

Angelafeet Sun 16-Nov-25 15:51:21

I think it speaks for itself…the WI group want to invite her back…not a man in sight..but women enjoying women. Not necessarily sex, but an art form. I DO NOT have the figure for it , never have…but would have a go if I did…for me not for a man

mabon2 Sun 16-Nov-25 15:58:28

Yes indeed

keepingquiet Sun 16-Nov-25 16:03:22

Sounds really boring to me- would rather watch paint dry...

David49 Sun 16-Nov-25 16:18:37

Personally I’ve never been impressed by sexy clothing but if it makes a woman feel good then why not, it’s nothing to do with pole dancing clubs where women are paid to perform.

suelld Sun 16-Nov-25 19:30:16

Oreo

WI?!
Sounds like a load of tripe, what woman wants to watch that?

Why on earth not … we are sexual beings too surely?
I’m 80 next year and would really enjoy that!

suelld Sun 16-Nov-25 19:48:24

Kamiso

StripeyGran

WI didn't work for me. Nothing to do with sex. More to do with bags on seats and " My sister sits there"

That’s what the local U3A meetings were like. L found them irritating but amusing at the same time until I came across a woman with tears in her eyes. Widowed six months ago and her first lone venture out told three times she couldn’t sit in certain seats. Very off putting!

You must have a bad U3a! How sad. But maybe persevere? Of course there are cliques in every group/ organisation, hierarchy abounds everywhere, but my local U3a ( South West Wales) is full of generally lovely people! It does take a bit of courage to lone join any group. I was initially just looking for a Scrabble group as I missed playing. Not an expert, just an average player and my regular partner had died and my family no where near, but perhaps I was lucky and when I took the plunge a few years ago I was pretty hesitant, but I met another lady joining on the same day at the monthly meeting, and we started chatting and both relaxed then. I subsequently ventured out and joined other groups. Overall they are very varied nice people, men and women, and now the few groups I belong to I really enjoy! My problem is finding the time to attend. I could be doing something everyday with the variety of groups available!
Maybe give them another go, and ignore the bags! Have you a friend or acquaintance you could join with? Those ‘huggers’ will not be ALL the people there, I’m sure there will be lots of others who you WILL like! The WI is more insular as being all women in my view. Try the U3a again and start, as I did, with the one group doing something you really enjoy?

Tenko Sun 16-Nov-25 20:06:17

Interesting comments on here about the WI. My boss is a trans woman and was asked to give a talk at a local WI . And why not ? She’s fully transitioned and I find her story very sad but very interesting.
I’ve also seen a Burlesque show and loved it. It was set in America when alcohol was banned and we drank cocktails from tea cups .

WithNobsOnIt Sun 16-Nov-25 20:28:31

Burlesque, Smurlesque.

What a load of old codswallop.

The stuff l have seen on the Tele and You Tube is definitely bordering on soft porn. Same for pole dancing.
Some nice outfits but still cringeworthy and low class and originally designed for the literal titillation of the male gaze

Burlesque has moved in leaps and bounds since the Tiller Girls, The Can Can and Fifi the Fan Dancer. Dear Me.

I bet Ru Paul and the Drag Race Girls could do the best tacky version of Modern Burlesque by a mile

Women can do whatever they want is the new mantra.

As Annie Lennox sang

Sweet dreams are made of this
So who am l to disagree?

I rest my case.

grannygranby Sun 16-Nov-25 20:30:11

No you are not out of touch. They are deluded. It’s a step back. How we fought against gender stereotypes etc etc . Nothing more stereotypical than pandering to porn images of women teasing men.

jocork Sun 16-Nov-25 22:04:28

Each to their own, but it doesn't appeal to me. However there are those who pole dance for men and others who pole dance as a form of exercise. Again not for me but I knew a couple of colleagues who did some years ago. I guess it is a similar thing if it's about body positivity.

FranP Mon 17-Nov-25 00:04:22

I am really old fashioned - so much emphasis on self-indulgent sex and sexual orientation. My attitude is "Sorry, but I do not care who you sleep with and what you do in the bedroom, but PLEASE keep it to yourself, and have you not got better things to get on with than make it central to your life?"

I would not put pole dancing (strengthening exercise) in the same group as burlesque, which I would put with stripping, but hey! if you want to do either take it home.

I see it as a general lowering of standards, but yes I am old fashioned. I also see a contradiction between girls feeling safe on our streets and them going out dressed in their underwear, and our pop singers and "stars" virtually baring all. It is small wonder that our immigrants think our girls are easy and available. And indeed learning the type of dancing that is specifically designed to excite (Not that the probably older, ladies of the WI might not appreciated learning how to get grumpy a bit more interested <lol>) if they so wish.