Gransnet forums

Chat

National Trust really does not help itself

(49 Posts)
infoman Sun 04-Jan-26 01:45:41

volunteer banned for pointing out spelling mistakes.
metro.co.uk/2026/01/02/national-trust-bans-man-pointed-spelling-mistakes-website-26005554/

Madgran77 Mon 05-Jan-26 09:55:07

So more to this than meets the eye, as suspected!

Magenta8 Mon 05-Jan-26 10:05:44

As I have posted on other threads "Never let the facts get in the way of a good story." The Telegraph is becoming notorious for this since it dumbed down.

Lathyrus3 Mon 05-Jan-26 10:58:44

Well, I do think it’s one of those sensational stories made out of nothing and that he sounds quite obnoxious.

But I a,so gave to say that when I wrote to the National Trust pointing out that the food in their cafe was not labelled with allergens and that the staff had been unable to help me with the contents of what was on offer, I was totally ignored.

When I sent a second email it was passed along the line three times, until it eventually arrived with the Catering staff at the venue - who had been unable to help me because the food is ordered centrally by National Trust and they have no idea what it contains. That information is held centrally!

I do think the National Trust has become predominantly a commercial organisation operated for the benefit of the highest employees.

theworriedwell Mon 05-Jan-26 13:18:40

HelterSkelter1

I think Galaxy was joking?

Thanks. It seemed odd but I obviously wasn't with it this morning. Arthritis glaring up so I'm sleep deprived drugged up and still in pain.

Witzend Mon 05-Jan-26 13:34:52

Must say I have sympathy for anyone pointing out a mass of spelling mistakes on an official website. Any organisation as big as the NT really should have someone reasonably literate to check.
And before anyone disagrees, yes, these things DO still matter to a good many people.

From experience, the majority of people who aren’t remotely bothered about spelling/grammar mistakes, are those who just don’t ‘see’ them, because their own SPAG is sadly lacking.

Magenta8 Mon 05-Jan-26 20:03:20

I agree Witzend. I am one of those people who just doesn't 'see' mistakes as I am sadly lacking in SPAG.grin

theworriedwell Mon 05-Jan-26 20:06:13

Witzend

Must say I have sympathy for anyone pointing out a mass of spelling mistakes on an official website. Any organisation as big as the NT really should have someone reasonably literate to check.
And before anyone disagrees, yes, these things DO still matter to a good many people.

From experience, the majority of people who aren’t remotely bothered about spelling/grammar mistakes, are those who just don’t ‘see’ them, because their own SPAG is sadly lacking.

Spelling mistakes or making offensive remarks about someone from another country, which is worse, let me think.

Galaxy Mon 05-Jan-26 20:11:20

Yes I was joking. But if it is true that they said 'farmers heard sheep' then there is no saving them.

theworriedwell Mon 05-Jan-26 20:44:32

Many many years ago I started my career in police admin. For the first few years I spent a lot of time typing statements. They had to be the same as the written version so spelling mistakes bad grammar crossings out were all duly typed. Working on a major incident room, investigating a murder or other serious crime I might be doing it for 10 or 12 hours seven days a week. One day a colleagues finger suddenly went ping and started to swell like a balloon inflating. She was rushed to hospital where her finger was cut to release all the blood from where the vein had burst open, pounding on an old manual for days on end can do that.

I'm pretty impervious to spelling and grammar mistakes as long as I understand what it means. Calling me Oirish instead of Irish is a whole different matter.

Seapebble Tue 06-Jan-26 14:42:02

flappergirl

He sounds like an incredibly rude man and the "Oirish" comment was racist. I doubt this was the first time he'd been a pain in the arse.

Absolutely! I know the type. Am I making assumptions about someone I've never met? Yes! I know this kind of old school bigot. If the part about cancer is true, that's really sad but looks like he left the NT of his own will. If the respondent took two months to even acknowledge the email that's rude. However, I wouldn't last long on a team with this person. I'm not saying NT is perfect by any means. Their volunteers are mostly lovely from what I can tell on our visits.

FranP Tue 06-Jan-26 14:56:30

theworriedwell

oirish not Polish. I wish my phone didn't think it knows what I mean more than I do.

I do hate having my spelling corrected by a machine that is not great , and assuming words I did not intend.

I worked for an Education Authority and every time I typed Bushfields MS changed it to Beautified.

SueDoku Tue 06-Jan-26 15:01:45

Witzend

Must say I have sympathy for anyone pointing out a mass of spelling mistakes on an official website. Any organisation as big as the NT really should have someone reasonably literate to check.
And before anyone disagrees, yes, these things DO still matter to a good many people.

From experience, the majority of people who aren’t remotely bothered about spelling/grammar mistakes, are those who just don’t ‘see’ them, because their own SPAG is sadly lacking.

Surely the obvious solution could have presented itself to the NT high-ups? Simply thank the volunteer for pointing out the mistakes - and ask him if he would care to volunteer as a proof-reader for the website..! He'd have been thrilled (& had something to boast about to his friends) and the NT wouldn't make itself look ignorant by having misspellings on public view.!! 😁
Or is that too simple..? 🙄

crazygranmda Tue 06-Jan-26 15:22:18

I have decided not to renew our membership this year.

We used to regularly visit Knowle Park. However, once Covid was over they still insisted on a booking even though we only wanted to walk in the parkland and not visit the house. I just don't see the logic; it's not a small parkland area or a small carpark.

WithNobsOnIt Tue 06-Jan-26 16:23:06

Besides the real truth behind this story. Which none of us know.

I personally find many of these websites and other media presentations put forward by a lot of these Charities and even business to be full of errors and factual mistakes.

They are badly written, hard to navigate, omit important facts and information Also written on the cheap and/or by well meaning Volunteers.

Whatever happened to good comprehension skills?

Dumbing down is now a way of life.

Allira Tue 06-Jan-26 17:30:32

SueDoku

Witzend

Must say I have sympathy for anyone pointing out a mass of spelling mistakes on an official website. Any organisation as big as the NT really should have someone reasonably literate to check.
And before anyone disagrees, yes, these things DO still matter to a good many people.

From experience, the majority of people who aren’t remotely bothered about spelling/grammar mistakes, are those who just don’t ‘see’ them, because their own SPAG is sadly lacking.

Surely the obvious solution could have presented itself to the NT high-ups? Simply thank the volunteer for pointing out the mistakes - and ask him if he would care to volunteer as a proof-reader for the website..! He'd have been thrilled (& had something to boast about to his friends) and the NT wouldn't make itself look ignorant by having misspellings on public view.!! 😁
Or is that too simple..? 🙄

Or is that too simple..? 🙄
Yes!

DrWatson Wed 07-Jan-26 05:51:27

We used to be members of the NT, stopped several years ago after witnessing the absurd 'PC' burblings of their leading lights trying to rewrite history, and/or apologise for this country's colonialist past.

Most of the developed countries in Europe some 4 or 5 hundred years ago went round the world exploring, sometimes conquering and colonialising. It's what people did back then, they didn't know any better.

Trying to apologise to visitors that a certain property had a history of family/ies that were associated with such activity is utterly pointless . . . and trying to erase that history because it makes some 'PC' pen-pusher feel better is also pointless. . . .and wildly misleading to younger visitors, whose history 'education' may be in any case lacking due to schooling failures in recent times.

It's like trying to make WW1 & 2 history go away by air-brushing it out of books, doesn't alter that it really did happen.

NB -- for those who haven't heard of it, consider a National Art Pass, we consider it much better value than NT membership now, gets you discounted or free entry into a great many venues?

Allira Wed 07-Jan-26 09:55:21

Most of the developed countries in Europe some 4 or 5 hundred years ago went round the world exploring, sometimes conquering and colonialising. It's what people did back then, they didn't know any better.

They still don't!!
As well as invading and taking over, we're exploring space, early day so far.

I think it's what humans do.

Witzend Wed 07-Jan-26 10:11:22

Talking of ‘official’ mistakes, I once picked up a leaflet about a taught MA that was being offered by our local university.

There were at least two very basic mistakes in the blurb.
The taught MA in question was for English literature!

Maremia Wed 07-Jan-26 10:56:23

Any word yet, about who is buying the Telegraph?

infoman Mon 12-Jan-26 04:59:14

There is a free offer in some of Monday newspapers to visit NT properties,they are the in the Daily Mirror Daily Express Daily Star.

TillyTrotter Mon 12-Jan-26 08:31:21

On the face of it, it sounds petty.
Sometimes it’s not the words spoken which offend but the way in which the speaker responded.
It seemed like he was on a mission.

Grantanow Mon 12-Jan-26 10:16:46

I like the NT's new idea of providing seating for visitors and allowing visitors to use historic house libraries instead of merely gazing at the books. Lack of opportunity to sit down must grate with older members like me.

RosiesMawagain Fri 06-Feb-26 08:37:03

It was obvious to me, from her name, that English was not her first language yet she managed to get a senior position in an important department

Primrose how on earth can you make that assumption?
Just as a for instance- where do you reckon Kwasi Kwarteng was born - judging by his name?
Give up?
Born London 1975
Education: University of Cambridge (2000), Harvard University, Eton College, Trinity College, St Paul's Juniors
Never judge a book by its cover or a person’s grasp of language by their name.