Gransnet forums

Chat

“Shakespeare was a black woman” - now I’ve heard it all!

(168 Posts)
RosiesMawagain Sat 24-Jan-26 13:08:22

From today’s newspaper
William Shakespeare was a “black Jewish woman”, according to a new book
It claims that the truth of Shakespearean authorship has been hidden by centuries of “Western-centric and Eurocentric ideology”
The author contends that the real Bard was a cosmopolitan woman with a “multicultural identity
This woman is identified in the new work, titled The Real Shakespeare, as the historical figure Emilia Bassano – a poet with connections to the Tudor court
Bassano, it is claimed, used the pen-name “Shakespeare” and wrote the Shakespearean canon of plays, only for her work to be stolen by an uneducated interloper from Stratford-upon-Avon.
This interloper, whom we now know as William Shakespeare, was then revered by posterity because the idea of a “white” genius was preferred to a black female playwright, the book argues

I think I’ll give this one a miss!

Wyllow3 Mon 26-Jan-26 18:03:38

Oreo, in my opinion, that is extremely patronising - your "mock Paddy character a-setting out" song.

My gran was 100% Irish the whole family came over just like the Worried Well said, hardly anything on their backs in the 1890's.
And met of course with suspicion and much unkindness. My gran did everything top avoid any "taint":

sending my mum to elocution lessons and so on.

theworriedwell Mon 26-Jan-26 18:16:12

Maremia

How did it work out for your friend, the worriedwell? An awful situation

Her husband thought it was funny so it didn't cause any problems. Beliefs a out pregnancy and babies are interesting. I read about somewhere, maybe Papua New Guinea, where pregnancy was nothing to do with men, it was something that happened when you swam in the sea. One woman "proved" it to the researcher as her husband had been away on a long trip when she got pregnant, he got home to a new baby in the house. Might haved prevented a lot of angst.

theworriedwell Mon 26-Jan-26 18:19:43

Wyllow3

*Oreo*, in my opinion, that is extremely patronising - your "mock Paddy character a-setting out" song.

My gran was 100% Irish the whole family came over just like the Worried Well said, hardly anything on their backs in the 1890's.
And met of course with suspicion and much unkindness. My gran did everything top avoid any "taint":

sending my mum to elocution lessons and so on.

I remember my mum being angry as we were on a bus and one woman was saying the Irish are like animals and eat off the floor without plates. My mum stood up and said we don't eat off the floor but we could as our floors are kept clean. The woman looked shocked.

Lots of prejudice in the world.

Maremia Mon 26-Jan-26 18:26:42

Thanks theworriedwell, glad it worked out for them.

theworriedwell Mon 26-Jan-26 18:28:59

Maremia

Thanks theworriedwell, glad it worked out for them.

Thank you.

Oreo Mon 26-Jan-26 18:30:30

Don’t be silly Wyllow3 it’s a great song! In fact most Irish songs are.

Allira Mon 26-Jan-26 19:25:32

Wyllow3

*Oreo*, in my opinion, that is extremely patronising - your "mock Paddy character a-setting out" song.

My gran was 100% Irish the whole family came over just like the Worried Well said, hardly anything on their backs in the 1890's.
And met of course with suspicion and much unkindness. My gran did everything top avoid any "taint":

sending my mum to elocution lessons and so on.

Why?

It's a song written by an Irish man and has been sung by many Irish folk groups and others for years.

Not half as patronising as someone trying to steal our greatest playwright and claim it was a black female just to fit the present "wokeish" agenda.

Woke is not a word I would normally use but it seems appropriate as so many understand it.

theworriedwell Mon 26-Jan-26 20:21:50

The song might be great but it tells a tragic tale, one that has been repeated for generations.

My father's story is similar. As a teenager he cycled from the west coast across to Dublin where he sold his bike to raise his fare to Liverpool. He arrived in Liverpool penniless, remember he was still legally a child. He got directions to the nearest Catholic church where he asked for help. The Priest took him to a big Irish pub where they gave him bed and food for bottling up washing glasses etc .

When he was old enough he joined the Royal Navy and served through WWII.

Oreo Mon 26-Jan-26 21:33:25

Yes lots of Irish songs are sad but no less great songs for that.
Your Father had a happy ending theworriedwell.
Very many Irish people came to England to work and settled down here , just as very many in the past emigrated to the US.
You’ll find Irish pubs just about everywhere.

Oreo Mon 26-Jan-26 21:35:39

In Dublin’s fair city where the girls are so pretty…..(Molly Malone) another sad song.

theworriedwell Mon 26-Jan-26 21:37:58

Oreo

Yes lots of Irish songs are sad but no less great songs for that.
Your Father had a happy ending theworriedwell.
Very many Irish people came to England to work and settled down here , just as very many in the past emigrated to the US.
You’ll find Irish pubs just about everywhere.

He died in his early 40s leaving my mother with three schoolage children to bring up. He'd been I'll for years. It wasn't exactly a happy ending.

The reality is very sad.

I grew up in an Irish pub so you can't tell me much about them. It's the reason I'm teetotal.

Oreo Mon 26-Jan-26 21:41:37

Oh dear!

SueDonim Mon 26-Jan-26 23:36:12

Mary Slessor, a Scotswoman, brought about an end to the killing of twin babies in part of Nigeria. She is still revered there. She was more social worker than missionary, when you read about her life.

Twin babies are not uncommon in Nigeria, some families having multiple sets. There has been some research into why this is. Both a genetic tendency and also a diet of yams, which contain phytoestrogens, are thought to contribute to the high rate of twins being born.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-tayside-central-30577100

theworriedwell Tue 27-Jan-26 02:38:32

SueDonim

*Mary Slessor*, a Scotswoman, brought about an end to the killing of twin babies in part of Nigeria. She is still revered there. She was more social worker than missionary, when you read about her life.

Twin babies are not uncommon in Nigeria, some families having multiple sets. There has been some research into why this is. Both a genetic tendency and also a diet of yams, which contain phytoestrogens, are thought to contribute to the high rate of twins being born.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-tayside-central-30577100

My friend experienced this in the late sixties in Nigeria.

Glennic Tue 27-Jan-26 03:43:55

Hi everyone! 👋
My name is Glen, and I’m excited to be here! I’m a bit of a newbie, still learning the ropes, but I’m really looking forward to meeting amazing people, sharing stories, and having some great conversations. I’ve always believed that the best connections come from genuine chats, laughter, and even the small moments that make life memorable.
A little about me: I enjoy learning new things, exploring different perspectives, and connecting with people who have interesting stories to tell. I’m someone who loves a good laugh, meaningful conversations, and creating moments that make life brighter.
I’m really hoping to make some friends here, exchange ideas, and just enjoy the positive energy of this group. I may be new, but I promise to bring a friendly vibe, curiosity, and an open heart to every conversation.
Looking forward to getting to know all of you and being a part of this wonderful community! Feel free to say hi, I’d love to chat. 😊

David49 Tue 27-Jan-26 06:06:37

theworriedwell

Oreo

Yes lots of Irish songs are sad but no less great songs for that.
Your Father had a happy ending theworriedwell.
Very many Irish people came to England to work and settled down here , just as very many in the past emigrated to the US.
You’ll find Irish pubs just about everywhere.

He died in his early 40s leaving my mother with three schoolage children to bring up. He'd been I'll for years. It wasn't exactly a happy ending.

The reality is very sad.

I grew up in an Irish pub so you can't tell me much about them. It's the reason I'm teetotal.

Years ago there were a lot of migrant Irish construction workers in the UK, when I first started I was the digger driver, working with a gang. Highlight of the day was breakfast time at around 10am Seamus a wiry little guy from Donegal would stoke up the brazier and cook breakfast for everyone, on his shovel!! .
They were great to work with, but I only went drinking with them on a Friday night once, lesson learned

M0nica Tue 27-Jan-26 08:55:02

the worriedwell your story is that of many of us of Irish descendant. My grandfather, catholic and illegitimate (although he had a cover story that was not broken in his lifetime.) enlisted in the army when still underage.

In his case it worked out well. He worked his way up through the ranks, was commissioned as an officer just after WW1 and was awarded an OBE. On the other side my family came over to London at the end of the Great Famine. Two generations of young widows struggled to survive, but did.