Gransnet forums

Chat

Why are we no longer ‘sad’ ?

(98 Posts)
Whethertomorrow Thu 29-Oct-26 15:47:47

When I was reading about Prince Harry (not a bash at him) saying he was depressed for 2 weeks after leaving UK for Canada it started me thinking about being sad as opposed to depression.

Nobody seems to say ‘I was sad about…’ anymore. It’s always ‘I’m depressed’. I always thought depression was a long term thing where there is no light in your life, it’s hard to function and every day is a complete struggle. My poor BIL was depressed for years and ended up hanging himself because he couldn’t cope. That to my mind was depression.

When my husband died after 7 years of stage 4 cancer, I was devastated and sad, very sad but I don’t think I was depressed. Perhaps I’m hard headed but I had to keep going and fighting to get things done.

I’m sure grief is experienced differently for everyone but does describing it as sadness or depression make a difference to how you feel.

Does saying “I’m sad about X” make people regard you differently than if you say “I’m depressed about X”. Would they try to cheer you up, be kinder, softer to you, more amenable towards situations if you were sad rather than depressed?

Has depression become so common place that people almost dismiss it as a nothing really wrong diagnosis, much like a backache complaint is dismissed as malingering?

Just my own muddled thinking on a damp dull afternoon. I would love to hear your thoughts if you’d care to share them. Thanks for reading.

eazybee Thu 29-Oct-26 18:26:23

I agree. I would say I have been sad, miserable and unhappy at different times, but I don't think I have been depressed. Depression, to me, comes when there is no apparent cause, no death, loss, failure, regret, just an all enveloping cloud that seems impossible to leave, and with no end in sight.
I am very sorry for true sufferers as it is impossible to reach them.
It is an expression used far too regularly.

Luckygirl3 Thu 29-Oct-26 18:52:50

People suffering from depression are often also physically slowed down.

Many years ago I was on a tiny dose of an old fashioned antidepressants to control migraines. I had to go off it for surgery and suffered an appalling post operative depression. I felt desperately physically slowed down nauseous and weak as well as weepy and with no desire whatsoever to continue living. It was perfectly dreadful and lasted about 3 months. It truly was torture. Ever since I have lived in fear of it happening again.

I was very very sad when my OH died and I wept buckets, but it was entirely distinct in nature from the depression which was an illness as opposed to a normal reaction.

Wyllow3 Thu 29-Oct-26 19:00:19

Cossy

karmalady

I have ever been depressed, sad at times of course but I have taken sadness to be part of life emotions and a feeling that will pass. Depression must be like living in a black hole with nothing nice to look forward to

That’s exactly how I see and understand depression.

A big black foggy hole, with no future, no past and no visible escape.

Correct.

Best to talk of ........

As a diagnosis: Major or Minor depression. Minor depression is when you see a GP and anti depressants, or/and for some, counselling helps enough.

Major - well, as described, although bear in mind both major and minor can either be "cant get out of bed" sorts or "heavily laced with anxiety, cant sit down and worry all the time.

(People with. psychosis can be depressed as part of their diagnosis, but too big to deal with here)

People with depression may also be Bi-Polar

Bi-polar 1 is where you get OTT manic and psychotic, (lose tough with reality, spend money, sexual behavior, grandiose thoughts, and so on)

and this alternates at worst with severe not able to get out of bed stuff or respond at all to anything to sad but coping as long as medicated.

Bi Polar 2 has long often suicidal depressions as per black hole, alternating with elevated mood but not psychotic.

So mood stabilisers are used sometime in combination with anti depressants.

And Major Depression, even if not bi-polar, can be part treated with small mood stabiliser doses in addition.

and of course there are various personally disorders (recommend googling) where depression can be a feature.

And whatever label there is, everyone is totally and uppterly different.

Yes, the word "depression has become over used and confused with sadness, grief, anxiety we al have to live with...

.....the normal adversities life throws at us. And this is causing problems, both in terms of how we understand how to live with adversity, and the demands on GP's and MH services.

*I'd say on this what helps an awful lot is some decent counselling ie helps to understand the difference, coping and understanding strategies, for we do,, na certainly young people do, live in increasingly stressful and speedy world full of more uncertainties than for a long time.

Wyllow3 Thu 29-Oct-26 19:02:23

Sorry for typos! I was short of time but did want to chip in.

Plevey08 Thu 29-Oct-26 19:13:00

Is it usually younger people who say they are depressed rather than sad?
Sadness is a normal, temporary emotional response rather than a mental health condition.
However prolonged or intense sadness can be a trigger for clinical depression
Sadness, life events, bereavement, stopping activities or drinking more alcohol with sleep problems and hopelessness may have developed into depression.often from past traumas, low self esteem and being overly self-critical.
I think I've noticed, particularly with some younger people, that they are ill-equipped to deal with sadness and perhaps go on a downward spiral, because they don't have the tools to understand that sadness and disappointment are to be expected.

Moth62 Thu 29-Oct-26 19:16:01

Jane Austen used to describe the feeling as being “low in spirits”

Plevey08 Thu 29-Oct-26 19:24:52

I remember that Moth62. If you said that now you might get a nice bottle of tipple

Oldnproud Thu 29-Oct-26 19:33:33

I have been both sad and depressed, and agree that they are very different, BUT as we can't possibly know what other people are feeling, I would not like to judge them on their use of the word 'depression", whatever the apparent cause.
Once you have fallen victim to depression, things that would seem/sound very trivial to others can have a devastating effect on your mental health!

Iam64 Thu 29-Oct-26 19:46:11

Feeling sad is miles away from clinical depression. Clinical depression can follow what some may see as a ‘trivial’ incident. It’s known in clinical circles as -the presenting problem. The death of a pet may be dismissed as a minor issue but could be the straw that broke the camels back.

mrsmeldrew Thu 29-Oct-26 19:49:54

That is so sad. I shall be devastated when either of our two go. Worse for you as your dear doggy was young.

Wyllow3 Thu 29-Oct-26 21:02:57

Iam64

Feeling sad is miles away from clinical depression. Clinical depression can follow what some may see as a ‘trivial’ incident. It’s known in clinical circles as -the presenting problem. The death of a pet may be dismissed as a minor issue but could be the straw that broke the camels back.

That's a good point.

Its a complex irony that just as it becomes a matter of less shame to have MH problems

and therefore is discussed at school and so on, and young people use the terms,

and people have access to a language they did not before - (I was often suicidal in my teens, but didn't even know the word, "depression" to ask for help....)

that somehow - not quite sure why - they may be less well equipped than older people who have weathered adversity in substantial depth - it appears to be the case its not within young people range of coping skills.

Is it the isolation of wandering round, clutching mobiles and chatting away, that the ability to take time - and indeed the necessity - to get the real connection with others that enriches lives?

hollysteers Thu 29-Oct-26 21:12:48

Moth62

Jane Austen used to describe the feeling as being “low in spirits”

That’s how I describe myself when feeling down. I don’t like the term depressed in my case.

Like others here, I was devastatingly sad when my DH died, but not depressed.

orly Fri 30-Oct-26 13:43:36

Yes I get the OPs post about the difference between "sad" and "depressed" and believe it's what forms the foundation of what causes so many people go on benefits rather than working for a living. Real clinical depression is debilitating, sadness is something we all experience from time to time but manage to soldier on.

ruthiek Fri 30-Oct-26 14:06:36

I totally agree with you , I have lived with depression for many years and always try to be positive even if Inside I am falling apart . It makes me so mad when people I know who are just having a bad day say “ I Am depressed “

RillaofIngleside Fri 30-Oct-26 14:18:51

I have noticed in recent years that people have started to medicalise sadness and normal reactions to every day life like bereavement or debt anxiety. They will recommend that people go to the doctor to be given 'something to help' instead of acknowledging that these are normal human feelings. I think it's right that sadness is not the same as depression at all.

jakuss Fri 30-Oct-26 14:24:56

You are spot on, the same with accidents they don't exist anymore, it's always someone else's fault

Galaxy Fri 30-Oct-26 14:31:46

I think it was doodledog ( really sorry if it wasnt!) who used to raise concerns around the overuse of mental health terms, I remember at the time thinking that it was a bit harsh but she was 100 % right.

fancyflowers Fri 30-Oct-26 14:53:30

Feeling sad isn't the same as being depressed. In a state of depression you can't see any light at the end of any tunnel. It's all consuming, and nothing that anyone can say or do can make you feel better.
I've only been depressed once in my life, although I've been sad many times. There's no comparison.

Dontcallmelove Fri 30-Oct-26 15:14:56

My GP asked me if I was depressed, I nearly laughed! No, I’m just down in the dumps because of multiple symptoms of long covid. What he would’ve done if I had said yes, I don’t know. I’ve had students who suffered from depression, real depression, and my heart would break for them knowing how much they were missing out on life.

Bazza Fri 30-Oct-26 15:16:33

My take on the difference between feeling sad and depressed is that there is a reason to be feeling sad, whereas depression can hit you for no apparent reason and is truly horrible.

MT62 Fri 30-Oct-26 15:44:18

I feel sad that I haven’t seen Missadventure posting in a while. Someone said she doesn’t keep too well, so I am hoping she is ok.
I have pm her but heard nothing.
I do find her posts amusing 😊

Galaxy Fri 30-Oct-26 15:51:50

Oh. Yes. She was back but you are right I haven't 'seen' her for a while.

Oreo Fri 30-Oct-26 15:53:51

Plevey08

Is it usually younger people who say they are depressed rather than sad?
Sadness is a normal, temporary emotional response rather than a mental health condition.
However prolonged or intense sadness can be a trigger for clinical depression
Sadness, life events, bereavement, stopping activities or drinking more alcohol with sleep problems and hopelessness may have developed into depression.often from past traumas, low self esteem and being overly self-critical.
I think I've noticed, particularly with some younger people, that they are ill-equipped to deal with sadness and perhaps go on a downward spiral, because they don't have the tools to understand that sadness and disappointment are to be expected.

Very good post 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

Seapebble Fri 30-Oct-26 16:06:23

It's all part of the overuse of superlatives these days - as though the original word won't do on its own. Years ago, "excited" replaced pleased etc. I'm a coffee fan yet my niece described herself as "obsessed". She just means she's keen. I didn't correct her or even comment because we said similar things I bet which hurt adults' ears. Other examples - depressed instead of naturally grieving. My friend lost her little daughter and the GP was pushing antidepressants. She said "I'm beside myself with grief. I'm not depressed." Depression is a very particular mental illness. Yes, grief can cause people to end their lives but it's extreme and understandable sadness and not a mental illness. "Very nice" becomes "unbelievable". Even excited isn't good enough. It needs a "beyond" added to the front. Beautiful is now "breathtaking or beyond-gorgeous". A little hyperbole actually makes our vocabulary richer but where do we go when even the superlatives won't do? I'm super-eager to find out heheh.

HelterSkelter1 Fri 30-Oct-26 16:18:27

Awesome is another. Said about things which are OK or even quite good. Whats the next level. Very awesome?