Another poster asked if we would like to reverse our ages &I said no! What I would like is to turn back the clock to the week I started to take an antidepressant & sleeping drug. Knowing what I know now, I would have given both a wide birth. Stuck on both all these years later.
I think sadness you can gee yourself up, depression not so much 😞
Gransnet forums
Chat
Why are we no longer ‘sad’ ?
(98 Posts)When I was reading about Prince Harry (not a bash at him) saying he was depressed for 2 weeks after leaving UK for Canada it started me thinking about being sad as opposed to depression.
Nobody seems to say ‘I was sad about…’ anymore. It’s always ‘I’m depressed’. I always thought depression was a long term thing where there is no light in your life, it’s hard to function and every day is a complete struggle. My poor BIL was depressed for years and ended up hanging himself because he couldn’t cope. That to my mind was depression.
When my husband died after 7 years of stage 4 cancer, I was devastated and sad, very sad but I don’t think I was depressed. Perhaps I’m hard headed but I had to keep going and fighting to get things done.
I’m sure grief is experienced differently for everyone but does describing it as sadness or depression make a difference to how you feel.
Does saying “I’m sad about X” make people regard you differently than if you say “I’m depressed about X”. Would they try to cheer you up, be kinder, softer to you, more amenable towards situations if you were sad rather than depressed?
Has depression become so common place that people almost dismiss it as a nothing really wrong diagnosis, much like a backache complaint is dismissed as malingering?
Just my own muddled thinking on a damp dull afternoon. I would love to hear your thoughts if you’d care to share them. Thanks for reading.
I had to have my dearly loved spaniel put to sleep eight weeks ago, I’m heartbroken, wrapped in layers of misery, I’m not depressed but full of sorrow which is incredibly painful
Sago
You make a really good point.
I have been severely depressed 3 times in my life, I have been sad hundreds of times.
I find it very upsetting perhaps even insulting when people use the term depressed instead of sad.
I have suffered from depression as did my Grandmother. It is awful and you can’t see a way out. It is often due to loss of a loved one. I’d describe it as despair really. Sadness is different and usually temporary.
I am so sorry about your brother in law and your husband. I lost my own husband to cancer this year.
I think sad is a beautiful word. I do feel very sad.
At the moment I am not suffering from clinical depression or anxiety but I have at psst times in my life. In my experience there is no comparison between this illness and normal emotions be they positive or negative. It is the most awful state of constant anguish which is impossible to describe if you haven't experienced it and is as hard to bear as the most severe physical pain. There is a very strong impulse to take ones own life.
It is unfortunate that the same words are used for quite different experiences as it can confuse, as described here.
I agree that there is a huge difference between being sad and being depressed and it minimising those who suffer from depression. I have a friend who will describe herself as having been ‘depressed yesterday evening’ but is now perfectly fine today. I’d give my eye teeth to have had ‘depression’ which lasted a few hours instead of many dark months of wading through mud, wondering if there is any point to life.
So many emotions today are now interpreted as medical events instead of the normal ups and downs of life - my psychologist son gets very cross about this tendency to the pathologisation of human feelings. It’s as though a state that is anything less that 100% happy is considered a fault, and that we’re broken and need mending.
I am so sorry about your brother in law and your husband. I lost my own husband to cancer this year.
I think sad is a beautiful word. I do feel very sad.
At the moment I am not suffering from clinical depression or anxiety but I have at psst times in my life. In my experience there is no comparison between this illness and normal emotions be they positive or negative. It is the most awful state of constant anguish which is impossible to describe if you haven't experienced it and is as hard to bear as the most severe physical pain. There is a very strong impulse to take ones own life.
It is unfortunate that the same words are used for quite different experiences as it can confuse, as described here.
I totally agree with you. Unfortunately mental health suffering is loosely used to describe feeling sad or down but this is part of everyday life. Depression is completely different.
The problem in terms of definition is that it's not a sort of "either or". We experience emotional problems on a spectrum, so one can be borderline between clinical and "GP" depression".
Thats why it's so tricky, unless you know the details of any borderline symptoms that point towards enduring Clinical Depression.
I think people who suffer from depression know that it is very different from feeling sad. Depression feels almost physical to some. The black cloud pressing on the head; the sinking stomach feeling; the absolute certainly that nothing will ever feel good again. The feeling of being in a deep pit with no ability to climb out.
I was told by a doctor to think of it as being in a tunnel. No matter how short or long, you will eventually reach the end of the tunnel.
SueDonim
I agree that there is a huge difference between being sad and being depressed and it minimising those who suffer from depression. I have a friend who will describe herself as having been ‘depressed yesterday evening’ but is now perfectly fine today. I’d give my eye teeth to have had ‘depression’ which lasted a few hours instead of many dark months of wading through mud, wondering if there is any point to life.
So many emotions today are now interpreted as medical events instead of the normal ups and downs of life - my psychologist son gets very cross about this tendency to the pathologisation of human feelings. It’s as though a state that is anything less that 100% happy is considered a fault, and that we’re broken and need mending.
Excellent comments.
Depression is a terrible thing.I have never known it but have been frequently sad in my life, as you say normal for everyone.
Happiness is fleeting in most lives too.
Reading all these interesting and well balanced posts brought to mind another modern(?) word ... "triggered". No longer are we a bit worried or concerned, for example, but our anxiety is triggered
I use that term a lot, (having a background in Psychotherapy), its been in use for a very long time as in "official" Psychology language.
What it means in practice is a situation like: very strong loss or anxiety situations,
but an illness or state of being is "triggered" by something apparently small.
Its important then not to think, "why on earth am I/he/she upset by something so small"...
and being unable without help to identify the real basis for the condition.
It happens all the time in everyday life, doesn't it? Something small sets one off, and its seems illogical and a bit mystifying. But in serious depression or other conditions, the "trigger" may be earth shattering when it happens.
Sleepyhead52
Reading all these interesting and well balanced posts brought to mind another modern(?) word ... "triggered". No longer are we a bit worried or concerned, for example, but our anxiety is triggered
Very true, my anxiety is triggered by the realisation that dark chocolate Bounties have been withdrawn, another of life’s little pleasures gone😱
MT62
Another poster asked if we would like to reverse our ages &I said no! What I would like is to turn back the clock to the week I started to take an antidepressant & sleeping drug. Knowing what I know now, I would have given both a wide birth. Stuck on both all these years later.
I think sadness you can gee yourself up, depression not so much 😞
I know what you mean MT62. I was given sertraline an anti-depressant approx 12 years ago and within 6 weeks I developed Lymphocytic Colitis (I am prone to auto-immune conditions) I came off sertraline straight away. My GP said sertraline can cause this in some people. It's mostly in remission but can be triggered when another auto-immune conditions becomes active. I don't think I would ever take another anti-depressant again. Not everyone will get the more rare side effects of AD's and I know they can really help some people but I wouldn't chance it again. And I know some people who like you say have not been able to wean off them. I get the feeling that some GP's put people on them and just leave them on them.
There are a huge range of antidepressants and also meds that can go with to alleviate or enhance the drugs. It does depend on the prescriber taking the time to know their stuff: and thats a problem when time is short.
Let's however tackle the myth that someone with grave depression can cope without medication. It may lead to suicide or a life spent entirely in a dark tunnel.
If you are on medication and feel "well, I'm OK,why am I still taking the meds' then go and see the prescriber"
either it will be a case of gradually coming off them - and knowing how to:
Or, you discover after trying to come off s suitable one (and as I said, there are so many), your mood dips deeply, then yes, you may stay on them and thats the best alternative.
Many people do this - it's no different from needing meds for physical conditions - one does what is needful.
Yes I see what you mean Wyllow.
🙂
Wyllow3
There are a huge range of antidepressants and also meds that can go with to alleviate or enhance the drugs. It does depend on the prescriber taking the time to know their stuff: and thats a problem when time is short.
Let's however tackle the myth that someone with grave depression can cope without medication. It may lead to suicide or a life spent entirely in a dark tunnel.
If you are on medication and feel "well, I'm OK,why am I still taking the meds' then go and see the prescriber"
either it will be a case of gradually coming off them - and knowing how to:
Or, you discover after trying to come off s suitable one (and as I said, there are so many), your mood dips deeply, then yes, you may stay on them and thats the best alternative.
Many people do this - it's no different from needing meds for physical conditions - one does what is needful.
It’s trial & error. I’ve been on so many, I can’t handle the side effects.
I thought Prozac was one of the easier drugs to come off- boy was I wrong & I am only on 10mg.
Zopiclone is another, twenty odd years, many attempts to taper off.
My muscles just go into spasms.
My Gp says they have no experience of getting anyone off this drug.
Thing is if I was on street drugs the help might be there to help me come off them.
It’s an absolute nightmare.
Regarding Zopiclone , M262 , I went to my GP and I had to plead with him for them, as i was suffering with chronic insomnia, he let me have just 6 tablets as he said they where highly addictive,..... i then went on to have the best night's sleep.
My gp now allows me just 7 zopiclone every 3 months 🙄.
I've wondered if this was the case with most GP practices but by the sound of your post then maybe not ?
When I was about 8 I read in the "doctor's book" we always had lying around of the condition of "Melancholia" as it was written in the book and I immediately recognised the description of it as exactly how I felt which was a bit precocious yet tragic at such a young age.
I guess I had a very stressful childhood, I was a good kid but the easy target of a lot of blame when my mum had bad tempers and bad moods - probably hormone led herself - and lashed out at me.
It's something that's been with me all my life and I feel it as an intense sadness with the line blurring into a depressive state rather than a deep, full blown depression.
Karen22
Regarding Zopiclone , M262 , I went to my GP and I had to plead with him for them, as i was suffering with chronic insomnia, he let me have just 6 tablets as he said they where highly addictive,..... i then went on to have the best night's sleep.
My gp now allows me just 7 zopiclone every 3 months 🙄.
I've wondered if this was the case with most GP practices but by the sound of your post then maybe not ?
Yes you won’t get them now, or you might get a few.
I wasn’t issued a prescription one month a couple of years ago, a locum who was in for the afternoon, took me off four different drugs. I flew up to the surgery & was promptly put back on all my meds.
Just had a review, & I can stay on them.
I want to come off, but I need help.
I would plead with you to try something else Karen22
Yes, Karen
currently you are given a limited number of Zopiclone and ^advised to use them.
I'm sad, M62, that you didn't find a drug that was helpful and adequately clear of side effects. I say adequately, because of course most meds have side effects and it's necessary to balance the pros and cons.
Yes Prozac is considered easier than some other anti-depressants. What one has to be careful of is
feeling a bit better due to the drug
eventually deciding you don't need it anymore
but.. working out whether its the original condition returning, or the withdrawal from the drug, causing the symptoms is very very individual indeed and need talking over with a medic.
There is nothing inherently wrong with deciding to stay on antidepressants (as upped to Zopiclone and Diazepam) if needful,
just as people around our age have to take blood thinners or diabetes treatment or painkillers.
Sometimes a good pharmacist in a GP practice is able to be informative in the case of having to take say..painkillers and anti'd's and so on, especially when it comes to needing opioids.
(The only alternative to Zopiclone that I know of is a strong Antihistamines like Promethazine, but I need to make clear that this is not medical advice just letting people know it is in use (it may be contra-indicated for you)
Wyllow3
(The only alternative to Zopiclone that I know of is a strong Antihistamines like Promethazine, but I need to make clear that this is not medical advice just letting people know it is in use (it may be contra-indicated for you)
Tried them Willow3, they don’t work for me.
Just weaned off diazepam (put on that for chronic burping) after the first AZ jab,TBF was only given a few per month. Still have chronic burping. I’ve learned to live with it & do it quietly 🙄
The thing is the Psychiatrist put me on the zopiclone, then you are left to get on with it once you are discharged.
One Gp said ‘oh that’s easy’, ‘I’ll have you off those in two weeks’ 😳 when I asked to come off.
One says they have no experience on weaning a patient off them.
I am frightened as the side affects of weaning off are terrible.
I wouldn’t advise anyone going on these drugs, even if it’s only temporary.
Anyway thanks wyllow3
Join the conversation
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join the discussion, watch threads and lots more.
Register now »Already registered? Log in with:
Gransnet »

