Gransnet forums

Chat

Trad Wives

(34 Posts)
Cossy Mon 16-Nov-26 08:38:08

So I’m at my DD’s new home every day currently, for various periods of time, to help settle and comfort three confused sausage dogs, so the girls can concentrate on both work and their precious baby, who’s still in hospital.

I’ve been watching rather more TV than I normally would.

Today’s offering is a BBC hour long study, filmed entirely by an independent female journalist, called “Young, British and Tradwife”.

It’s a combination of very interesting, pretty shocking, quite sad and this life is most definitely NOT for me.

It’s well worth a watch. I don’t object at all to the faith side of these lives, but I most certainly do object to the idea that somehow God man man first so he is the leader.

Mmmmmm

If you get the chance to watch this, please do.

The biggest thing which struck me, was the three families filmed all seemed middle class, great income, lovely home families.

I simply cannot get my head around how women fought so hard for our rights, rights to bank, rights to vote, rights to be paid equal amounts for doing the same paid job roles, are then happy to throw this all away.

However, they do have a choice, which women fought so hard to get.

However, their husbands would like all their daughters to be brought up to be trad wives, that’s not a choice is it? I’d call that conditioning, coercion and control, these husbands call it protection and the right way.

🤷🏻‍♀️🤷🏻‍♀️🤷🏻‍♀️🤷🏻‍♀️

Cossy Mon 16-Nov-26 11:28:48

DD1 was born in 1997, prior to having her sister 3 years later, I still worked in London and her misery cost me £100 a week, plus nappies. It was a huge chunk of my income and then there was no help with childcare costs. Many families now, even on average+ incomes, are eligible for help with childcare costs.

Cossy Mon 16-Nov-26 12:03:35

Nursery! Not misery!

Dickens Mon 16-Nov-26 12:05:06

As other's have pointed out, being a SAHM does not by default make you a trad-wife.

I cannot imagine any of the SAHMs on here ever agreeing to being submissive or obedient to their husbands grin which is, I think, what being a true trad-wife demands.

A genuinely progressive society will exploit the talent, skill - both physical and intellectual, of all its members.

Graphite Mon 16-Nov-26 12:25:41

King's College London has conducted research into this:

A survey of 1,000 young women aged between 18-34 found that what attracts them to tradwife [social media] content is less the male-breadwinner female-caregiver model and more the aesthetic of simplicity, leisure and escape from the pressures of increasingly demanding yet insecure work. The authors highlight that high childcare costs and intensive parenting norms have also put pressures on parents, especially mothers to balance work with family life. In other words, the popularity of tradwife content reflects growing frustration with a labour market that demands ‘ideal workers’ without accommodating family life.

The phenomenon and its popularity have risen so much that the Cambridge English Dictionary has officially included tradwife as one of the new words in the English language for 2025. But the study suggests it reflects exhaustion with today’s work/life pressures, not nostalgia for a bygone era.

Many younger women engaging with tradwife content may have little historical awareness of the realities faced by women in eras when financial dependence left them vulnerable - without legal or economic power and often trapped in relationships marked by inequality or even domestic abuse. Forgetting this history risks romanticising a past that, for many women, was neither safe nor empowering. This is why the growing popularity of tradwife content should not be dismissed or trivialised as something pertained to young women and their light frivolous interest. Shiyu Yuan, Research Assistant at King’s Global Institute for Women’s Leadership

That’s the worry here, that it’s the very tough labour market and an ignorance of the past that could push women into a lifestyle that isn’t right for them and could have serious consequences for them in later in life.

www.kcl.ac.uk/news/the-tradwife-phenomenon-isnt-a-return-to-tradition-its-a-plea-for-balance

Full report: Tradwife: between myths and realities here:

www.kcl.ac.uk/giwl/assets/giwl-tradwife-report.pdf

If I can pick out one paragraph from that:

The evidence in this report is unequivocal. Young women hold progressive attitudes toward gender equality. They reject the idea of male decision-makers and female submission. They want both parents contributing to household income and both parents involved in care. Yet, they also want meaningful work and time with their families. These aren't contradictory desires, but reasonable expectations that our current systems fail to meet.

Casdon Mon 16-Nov-26 12:34:27

I think the consumer society is to blame for the treadmill young couples put themselves on. It’s quite possible to work and spend lots of time with your children, as long as you aren’t constantly striving for bigger and better, and spending your leisure time maintaining a perfect home full of possessions that need looking after.

Luckygirl3 Mon 16-Nov-26 12:44:06

I don’t object at all to the faith side of these lives - I do - this is where the patriarchy stems from - it is entrenched in all mainstream religions.

I was a SAHM full time for 5 years then part time. At no point did obey enter into it!!!

Shelflife Mon 16-Nov-26 13:42:17

Let's not confuse SAHM s and Trad wives !

Oldnproud Mon 16-Nov-26 13:59:57

I very much hope that the husband of any British Tradwife is making adequate provision for his wife's future pension right from the start . The contributions covered by the State while children are under a certain age certainly aren't going to give them a big enough income at retirement age to live on.
It is one thing relying on one's husband to provide for you while raising children, but quite another thing in later life.