Robbie Williams and surrogacy

Does it matter as long as the child is loved and cared for?
Families come in all shapes and forms nowadays. It’s lovely for them both ?

Well yes it does matter. I think it's incredibly sad for the rent a womb.

Lovely for them. Not so much for the child being ripped away from its mother.
A child who has no say in what’s happening.

Are they having a child through surrogacy ?

Grey it appears we share the same views on surrogacy.Both children and women are commodified through the process of surrogacy.

A woman chooses to have the child , ripped from the womb ?
how dramatic

Old news, the child is over one years old.

www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbiz/article-8005283/Robbie-Williams-wife-Ayda-Field-welcome-son-Beau-Benedict-Enthoven.html

Not old news. The surrogate mother has carried two children for them.

No GG13 that was Coco, born Sept 2018. This new baby boy was born today. There are 4 children in the family now.

Sorry I had not seen that they had a second surrogate child. I am sure these children will be loved and have a wonderful life.

Very old idea. James Taylor did it years ago twins born in 2001. www.deseret.com/2001/4/11/19580110/surrogate-mom-brings-taylors-bundles-of-joy
There is a slight difference as a surrogate mother can be paid in the US but not in the UK.

Of course it's not a new idea but their sense of entitlement and ego is unpalatable to me.

Nobody's business but theirs

The children are biologically theirs

Lovely life for them

Loved and wanted

I believe the objectification of women and the damage forced upon children to be everyone’s business

What damage here Bibbity?

They make it everyone’s business don’t they ?
Unfortunately I ve always found him an extremely arrogant man and didn’t like his behaviour in the delivery room when one of the children were born (naturally) don’t know which one
Good luck to them but does it need to be ‘news’

So a woman’s choice is respected for abortion but not for
Surrogacy

Would you give up a newborn?

No I wouldn’t, my elder daughter agonised over being a surrogate for my younger daughter but knew she would not be
able to give up the child.

I wouldn’t abort a child either

Why do we move heaven and earth to keep children with their mothers except in these cases.

Right with you Bluebelle
Arrogant couple ....got fame... got money so have whatever they want Seem like fakes to me but really do hope children have a nice life.

@Galaxy, perhaps because in these cases (certainly in this one) the surrogate is not the child’s mother.

Yes they are. Women are not carriers or hothouses, every cell in the child's body is made by the mother, the importance of the fourth semester is only now being understood. Children should not be for sale.

There was a study conducted that showed that children born of surrogates exhibited the same trauma as adopted children.

We have proof of the 4th trimester. Proof that a newborn needs to stay with its mother. The woman who created and carried them.
It’s traumatic for a newborn to be removed from its mother.