Gransnet forums

Chat

Why are we no longer ‘sad’ ?

(98 Posts)
Whethertomorrow Thu 29-Oct-26 15:47:47

When I was reading about Prince Harry (not a bash at him) saying he was depressed for 2 weeks after leaving UK for Canada it started me thinking about being sad as opposed to depression.

Nobody seems to say ‘I was sad about…’ anymore. It’s always ‘I’m depressed’. I always thought depression was a long term thing where there is no light in your life, it’s hard to function and every day is a complete struggle. My poor BIL was depressed for years and ended up hanging himself because he couldn’t cope. That to my mind was depression.

When my husband died after 7 years of stage 4 cancer, I was devastated and sad, very sad but I don’t think I was depressed. Perhaps I’m hard headed but I had to keep going and fighting to get things done.

I’m sure grief is experienced differently for everyone but does describing it as sadness or depression make a difference to how you feel.

Does saying “I’m sad about X” make people regard you differently than if you say “I’m depressed about X”. Would they try to cheer you up, be kinder, softer to you, more amenable towards situations if you were sad rather than depressed?

Has depression become so common place that people almost dismiss it as a nothing really wrong diagnosis, much like a backache complaint is dismissed as malingering?

Just my own muddled thinking on a damp dull afternoon. I would love to hear your thoughts if you’d care to share them. Thanks for reading.

Wyllow3 Mon 02-Nov-26 21:26:55

I think they are really important for crisis, but to be treated with caution. There are times when quick chemical intervention, carefully used, can save getting into a worse state.

But I am very cross with your GP and coming off Zopiclone. Hopeless advice!!!!!!! Me, when I'm ready - I use a nail file over a long time to file a bit off each night. Like, as in 6 weeks. And you can have mini breaks in that time if it's a bad day. but there should be a bit more support.

MT62 Mon 02-Nov-26 22:26:17

Wyllow3

I think they are really important for crisis, but to be treated with caution. There are times when quick chemical intervention, carefully used, can save getting into a worse state.

But I am very cross with your GP and coming off Zopiclone. Hopeless advice!!!!!!! Me, when I'm ready - I use a nail file over a long time to file a bit off each night. Like, as in 6 weeks. And you can have mini breaks in that time if it's a bad day. but there should be a bit more support.

Been there with the pill cutter, then on to nail clippers to nip a little off.
I have a program to reduce over 26 weeks, that is transferring over to Diazepam at a higher dose, (because zopiclone is a lower dose it’s harder to cut that down over those 26 weeks.
Trazodone was better for me, I slept better. It’s an older drug & can affect the heart.
I asked to come off that as I felt too groggy at work. At least I got it in liquid form, & could eventually micro dose.
Listen to me I sound like a blinking addict- well technically I am, but will the GPS have it, will they hell.
I am no better than those in the gutter- maybe that’s a wrong way of putting it, but that’s how I feel.

MT62 Mon 02-Nov-26 22:34:03

Wyllow3

I think they are really important for crisis, but to be treated with caution. There are times when quick chemical intervention, carefully used, can save getting into a worse state.

But I am very cross with your GP and coming off Zopiclone. Hopeless advice!!!!!!! Me, when I'm ready - I use a nail file over a long time to file a bit off each night. Like, as in 6 weeks. And you can have mini breaks in that time if it's a bad day. but there should be a bit more support.

Are you on zopiclone? Or was that last bit just advising me when I am ready?
If I had the full support of of NHS who knew what they talking about, that they wouldn’t just stop them stone dead, I would gladly come off tomorrow- well maybe next week when I’ve took myself off into a corner for a good chat 😂

MT62 Mon 02-Nov-26 22:43:12

Sorry I sound like I am taking over this thread, but desperate to know if anyone has had a problem with this drug, or struggled with any other prescription meds? I’d be interested to know & grateful for any advice.
Someone mentioned self help. Books on another thread. I have stacks of them. Did they help?- not a bit, tbh.

JenniferEccles Mon 02-Nov-26 22:51:12

The stories on here about how addictive these antidepressants are, has made me wonder if GPs routinely warn patients about the dreadful side effects involved once they want to come off them.

There have been several newspaper articles highlighting this problem and warning people of the dangers these pills pose.

I believe studies have shown that cognitive behaviour therapy is a far better treatment for depression with none of the awful side effects.
I guess NHS waiting lists are long though.
Not easy for those feeling low.

Karen22 Tue 03-Nov-26 01:35:45

Im so sorry MT62 for what you're going through 💐.
I just take 1 zopiclone 7.5mg when im sick, ive a rare blood disorder which can cause immense anxiety when iv overdone stuff. TBH if I take another tablet the following night I find it has no effect in helping me sleep.....I guess I've a tough nut 😅 .

Nannee49 Tue 03-Nov-26 08:12:57

MT62 I so feel for you, I've long ago given up any hope of a cure/help/ support/anything! from my GP to ease this thing which has blighted my life for so long, I've made it my business to do as much research as I can to help myself.

I have recently come across this and, as a fellow sufferer, I can say it's definitely worth giving it a go...it's ridiculously simple but it's been really really effective in calming me down and helped me taper off amitriptyline.

When you're in bed settling down to try to drop off to sleep breathe in deeply through the nose for 3 counts, hold for 7 visualising the numbers counting down then breathe slowly out of the mouth for 8 again visualising the numbers counting down. Try 5 repetitions and try not to get intensely irritated, as I did at first, that the effort of doing it is seemingly keeping you awake rather than lulling you off.
(The science behind it is regulation of the vagus nerve - the fight or flight response that becomes jammed on & causes massive mental health problems)

Sincerely hope this is of some use to youflowers

Wyllow3 Tue 03-Nov-26 08:39:53

Yes I am addicted to Zopiclone M62 and Diazepam, it goes back a long way.

In different ways, both of those are sedatives, although clearly Karen has been described them for a more complicated condition

but these are different drugs from anti-depressants, all of which are different.

But what I described,

as I am slowly dropping my diazepam bit by bit

in terms of filing off a bit of a tablet over a long period, or reducing by a tiny amount each time, is the way to come off.

Coming off anti depressants I've always taken medical advice as to whether I am really ready (yes I have done that too, as they tried lots of different ones)

but its still a bit by bit endeavour to check its OK and the original condition isn't still overwhelmingly there.

Jennifer, I feel that anti-depressants are getting a s bit of a bad press here. I know a lot of people who take them, tolerate side effects, and it's turned their lives around, and some declared as such on GN

As they are not in the same category as Zopiclone and Diazepam we cant lump them together.

CBT is actually often offered alongside anti depressants in the hope that after CBT the person will understand enough about inner troubles to be able to reduce the anti-depressants.

But many also do a course of CBT (and yes it is hard to get on the NHS) and stay on anti-depressants but with far better lives.

Just as CBT alone is enough for some people:

And some may want or need to do psychotherapy instead.

Cognitive Behavioural Therapy deals with the present. Understanding thought patterns enables many to change them.

A key concept is Catastrophising, which is a mental habit where your mind immediately jumps to the worst-case scenario in any given situation.

Psychotherapy is often if CBT doesn't work, or a choice.

Psychotherapy looks back into the past and looks at factors that may have made us as we are, and by understanding for example aspects of one's difficult childhood, thought habits learned long ago, cope better and move on.

I've done both, and when they were more available on the NHS, I have been fortunate in that respect.

(if anyone wants to ask, well how come you know all this, it because Ive straddled both sides of the MH situation - worked in it, qualified in it, and needed help from it:

over a long period of time have been on many different meds and been fortunate enough to always have had them explained to me, and if they were not, to google but then ask)

Wyllow3 Tue 03-Nov-26 08:40:34

and a flowers for you M62 or others navigating this difficult time

Franbern Tue 03-Nov-26 08:52:26

Depression and sadness are totally different.
Feel sad for so many reasons, end of a wonderful visit, holiday, experience. Death of family pet, etc. Desperately sad for those poor people trying to live their lives in war zones.

But depression is very, very different. Fortunately, only a few times I have actually experienced this, and can only describe it like a black cloud hanging over me throughout my waking hours. Not really able to function normally on anything.

MT62 Tue 03-Nov-26 11:29:05

JenniferEccles

The stories on here about how addictive these antidepressants are, has made me wonder if GPs routinely warn patients about the dreadful side effects involved once they want to come off them.

There have been several newspaper articles highlighting this problem and warning people of the dangers these pills pose.

I believe studies have shown that cognitive behaviour therapy is a far better treatment for depression with none of the awful side effects.
I guess NHS waiting lists are long though.
Not easy for those feeling low.

Quite the opposite.
I asked when I was put on Zopiclone was it addictive, was told no with a brush of a hand.
Twenty odd years later….!
Had CBT for my OCD helps in the short term but then you revert back to how you was in the first place as there is no follow up!
GPS are probably more aware of the side affects of these drugs now & that is why they are reluctant to give them out now.

Boadicea Tue 03-Nov-26 12:18:50

HelterSkelter1

Awesome is another. Said about things which are OK or even quite good. Whats the next level. Very awesome?

My partner and I were in a restaurant:
"If I could take your order now, that would be amazing"!
Actually I would have thought it pretty run of the mill and what should be expected in a restaurant!

Wyllow3 Tue 03-Nov-26 14:35:50

MT62

JenniferEccles

The stories on here about how addictive these antidepressants are, has made me wonder if GPs routinely warn patients about the dreadful side effects involved once they want to come off them.

There have been several newspaper articles highlighting this problem and warning people of the dangers these pills pose.

I believe studies have shown that cognitive behaviour therapy is a far better treatment for depression with none of the awful side effects.
I guess NHS waiting lists are long though.
Not easy for those feeling low.

Quite the opposite.
I asked when I was put on Zopiclone was it addictive, was told no with a brush of a hand.
Twenty odd years later….!
Had CBT for my OCD helps in the short term but then you revert back to how you was in the first place as there is no follow up!
GPS are probably more aware of the side affects of these drugs now & that is why they are reluctant to give them out now.

CBT didnt work for me either, MT62, even tho I had the best on offer. It as him who said you need to do - I will refer you to - Psychotherapy.

Because like you said, sometimes understanding a problem isn't enough

But not everybody wants - or can cope with "opening the Pandora's box" of the past.

I had already done some years before and I was judged OK to do this, and yes it worked for me:

Its not a"solve it all" therapy, rather, gives one the tools to ry and solve it oneself and with other?

Hard to get not - mine started in 2008.

But you are spot on about Zopiclone. When it came out there were the same claims - "oh it's not addictive" - well there is a whole lot of us that know it isnt,

but we can sound the warning to others, "it works, but only take one in three nights"

which you have done.

(As I said, anti-depressants are each a different ball game, and not sedative as such, tho anti-anxiety help comes with some anti'D drugs)

Wyllow3 Tue 03-Nov-26 14:37:20

sorry for typos - any sentences not understood please take a good guess! mea culpa.

MT62 Tue 03-Nov-26 16:11:01

Wyllow3

sorry for typos - any sentences not understood please take a good guess! mea culpa.

Ahh yes totally got all that.
Many years ago when my grandfather died I cleared out his meds, there was a bottle of nearly a 100 Valium tablets. He was totally confused, not dementia, but off his tree.
Another lady my mum use to visit was on Ativan?been on them for years. new gp took her off & she was literally climbing the walls.
I don’t think these general practitioners get enough training that cover the in & outs of these types of drugs.
Like I said, a young locum took me off four, three which were quite addictive, without looking at my gp notes probably. Had she had looked at my records she would have seen just how long I had been on them, & said wow this person is going to need help to come off this drug.
I could cry when I see people begging outside shops, obviously drug addicts & maybe homeless.
I have a lovely partner, lovely house but technically I am an addict end of.

MT62 Tue 03-Nov-26 17:13:10

Wyllow3

Yes I am addicted to Zopiclone M62 and Diazepam, it goes back a long way.

In different ways, both of those are sedatives, although clearly Karen has been described them for a more complicated condition

but these are different drugs from anti-depressants, all of which are different.

But what I described,

as I am slowly dropping my diazepam bit by bit

in terms of filing off a bit of a tablet over a long period, or reducing by a tiny amount each time, is the way to come off.

Coming off anti depressants I've always taken medical advice as to whether I am really ready (yes I have done that too, as they tried lots of different ones)

but its still a bit by bit endeavour to check its OK and the original condition isn't still overwhelmingly there.

Jennifer, I feel that anti-depressants are getting a s bit of a bad press here. I know a lot of people who take them, tolerate side effects, and it's turned their lives around, and some declared as such on GN

As they are not in the same category as Zopiclone and Diazepam we cant lump them together.

CBT is actually often offered alongside anti depressants in the hope that after CBT the person will understand enough about inner troubles to be able to reduce the anti-depressants.

But many also do a course of CBT (and yes it is hard to get on the NHS) and stay on anti-depressants but with far better lives.

Just as CBT alone is enough for some people:

And some may want or need to do psychotherapy instead.

Cognitive Behavioural Therapy deals with the present. Understanding thought patterns enables many to change them.

A key concept is Catastrophising, which is a mental habit where your mind immediately jumps to the worst-case scenario in any given situation.

Psychotherapy is often if CBT doesn't work, or a choice.

Psychotherapy looks back into the past and looks at factors that may have made us as we are, and by understanding for example aspects of one's difficult childhood, thought habits learned long ago, cope better and move on.

I've done both, and when they were more available on the NHS, I have been fortunate in that respect.

(if anyone wants to ask, well how come you know all this, it because Ive straddled both sides of the MH situation - worked in it, qualified in it, and needed help from it:

over a long period of time have been on many different meds and been fortunate enough to always have had them explained to me, and if they were not, to google but then ask)

You could be me wyllow with how you are describing yourself. I’ve also worked in MH.
What I have come across, that there is a lot of people in this field that have chronic poor MH & that includes doctors & nurses.

MT62 Tue 03-Nov-26 17:13:58

Wyllow3

and a flowers for you M62 or others navigating this difficult time

🫂

MT62 Tue 03-Nov-26 17:17:54

Nannee49

MT62 I so feel for you, I've long ago given up any hope of a cure/help/ support/anything! from my GP to ease this thing which has blighted my life for so long, I've made it my business to do as much research as I can to help myself.

I have recently come across this and, as a fellow sufferer, I can say it's definitely worth giving it a go...it's ridiculously simple but it's been really really effective in calming me down and helped me taper off amitriptyline.

When you're in bed settling down to try to drop off to sleep breathe in deeply through the nose for 3 counts, hold for 7 visualising the numbers counting down then breathe slowly out of the mouth for 8 again visualising the numbers counting down. Try 5 repetitions and try not to get intensely irritated, as I did at first, that the effort of doing it is seemingly keeping you awake rather than lulling you off.
(The science behind it is regulation of the vagus nerve - the fight or flight response that becomes jammed on & causes massive mental health problems)

Sincerely hope this is of some use to youflowers

Thanks nannee49. Yes I have tried that, it does help. I also massage the back of my ankles, there are pressure points either side & that too helps.
Up for any ideas 😊

Wyllow3 Tue 03-Nov-26 20:54:39

Yoga, M62, yoga. Well, that's been my life line/go to since I was 25. Body aware, calming, and in the end I became a teacher, late in life. it hasn't prevented what I described, but my goodness it's been helpful. It's particularly the breathing and centre-ing grounding affect.

Yes, I know a dear psychiatrist who in 2006 put me onto therapy not all drugs, drugs, drugs, and even a course of ECT in 2005. she has had a mood affective disorder (which is what I have, tho a very different kind) all her life and it all caved in later in life. I've known nurses who became MH nurses after conquering depression adequately. They were sometimes the most helpful in a kind supportive way.

They are under such strain atm, resources being so slim. It's always been a "cinderella" service. Having said that, the consultants are getting much more non just meds, more people centred.

You are right in that many GPs simply do not know enough -but then they have to deal with every condition under the sun. It's generally helpful if, in a medium size practice, one can identify the ones that are "best" on MH. I do believe that experiencing both sides is generally helpful not of course essential.

The best thing I ever heard very early on was a GP who was very wise. She said, "I can't make "everything all right"
But I can walk with you

Now everyone isnt the same. she people genuinely just want to be told what to do, like my sis: but I've always wanted to be informed, but not pushed.

Ssuggestions "oh why don't you try this or that activity etc" go done like a lead balloon. As in, "if I were Weller then I would be doing x,y,z.

But OCD is a bummer, I know. Its sort of "built in" and intractable.

My lovely cleaner has it, you might say she is splendid in her job, she loves making everything neat, tidy, and clean!
She manages it well, for her, the right anti-D has made it manageable.

My way of managing it is to not take on Big Responsibilities like professional work and even a promising career as an artist (as soon as you get known, you face a lot of criticism) despite high levels of Education. Eventually, having given up so much, I am grateful for what there is, rather than what there is not. Are we not always a work in progress?

Over time I have found those in a similar situation. More people talk about more, these days.

MT62 Thu 05-Nov-26 09:15:59

Wyllow3

Yoga, M62, yoga. Well, that's been my life line/go to since I was 25. Body aware, calming, and in the end I became a teacher, late in life. it hasn't prevented what I described, but my goodness it's been helpful. It's particularly the breathing and centre-ing grounding affect.

Yes, I know a dear psychiatrist who in 2006 put me onto therapy not all drugs, drugs, drugs, and even a course of ECT in 2005. she has had a mood affective disorder (which is what I have, tho a very different kind) all her life and it all caved in later in life. I've known nurses who became MH nurses after conquering depression adequately. They were sometimes the most helpful in a kind supportive way.

They are under such strain atm, resources being so slim. It's always been a "cinderella" service. Having said that, the consultants are getting much more non just meds, more people centred.

You are right in that many GPs simply do not know enough -but then they have to deal with every condition under the sun. It's generally helpful if, in a medium size practice, one can identify the ones that are "best" on MH. I do believe that experiencing both sides is generally helpful not of course essential.

The best thing I ever heard very early on was a GP who was very wise. She said, "I can't make "everything all right"
But I can walk with you

Now everyone isnt the same. she people genuinely just want to be told what to do, like my sis: but I've always wanted to be informed, but not pushed.

Ssuggestions "oh why don't you try this or that activity etc" go done like a lead balloon. As in, "if I were Weller then I would be doing x,y,z.

But OCD is a bummer, I know. Its sort of "built in" and intractable.

My lovely cleaner has it, you might say she is splendid in her job, she loves making everything neat, tidy, and clean!
She manages it well, for her, the right anti-D has made it manageable.

My way of managing it is to not take on Big Responsibilities like professional work and even a promising career as an artist (as soon as you get known, you face a lot of criticism) despite high levels of Education. Eventually, having given up so much, I am grateful for what there is, rather than what there is not. Are we not always a work in progress?

Over time I have found those in a similar situation. More people talk about more, these days.

That’s just it GPs don’t have time to walk with their patients unfortunately, though a nice thing for that GP to say.

The ocd thing I have had since I was nine years old- people think it’s about germs, cleaning & hand washing. I can tell you I have had many variations of the annoying condition.
I’ve learned to manage it, especially through my working life.
MH services are overstretched now. Waiting times can be up to 18 month, or longer.
I like cooking, so try to focus on that as can’t get down any longer to do yoga- you are right though any excercise is good for lifting the endorphins. 👏

petra Thu 05-Nov-26 09:27:39

Nanna49
I was introduced to breathing techniques and the vagus nerve 40 years ago.
I’ve used it on a few people as well.

Wyllow3 Thu 05-Nov-26 10:57:21

👏 all good stuff - mind/body. Creative cooking sounds great, you are welcome any time M62 🤣.