Gransnet forums

Coronavirus

Indian variant

(168 Posts)
Daisymae Thu 13-May-21 17:48:08

Getting a little concerned about the mood music that seems to be in the air regarding this variant. There are over 700 confirmed cases, it seems to spread 60% more rapidly. I notice that in some areas well over 50% of new cases are of this variant and SAGE are having an emergency meeting this afternoon to discuss. Just when you thought it was safe to go back into the water??

donnab31 Fri 14-May-21 14:30:04

MayBee70

donnab31

Sorry if I come across as angry, it just scares me, the thought of living under all these restrictions for goodness knows how long.
Having a British government tell us when we can hug our children or have our families in our own homes would have been laughable 2 years ago.
Now we're all walking around with muzzles on, scared of anyone we might walk past, just in case they might be carrying the virus with no symptoms (there's still no proof of this) and so many of us aren't even questioning it.
It terrifies me that people are happy to accept this as the new normal.
The deaths and hospitalisations are level now, even though the Indian variant has been here for weeks.

Can you please show me the scientific evidence that shows that people are not asymptomatic carriers please? And can I point out that hospitalisation and deaths follow several weeks after infection rates rise. By the way, I’m quite happy to wear a ‘muzzle’ to protect you and others if I happen to be a carrier, symptomatic or asymptomatic.

I didn't say there was evidence to say people aren't asymptomatic, I said there was no evidence to say we are.

I'm as entitled to dislike wearing a mask as much as you are to think it's fine.
I'm also entitled to question whether they actually work, when they were introduced long before we had the winter spike but didn't prevent it.
The experts spent the first few months telling us they had very little impact, then when they were originally made compulsory, Sky News reported it was to give people confidence to spend money in shops.
I think it's very sad that we can't even see someone smile at us now and I do believe that until we start questioning how long these rules continue for, we're very quickly drifting into a world we won't like.
Again, just my opinion.

donnab31 Fri 14-May-21 14:35:14

We are going to have lots of new variants going forward but if we all think the country should shut down every time there's a new one, what hope is there of a happy future?
It wasn't my intention to offend so I'll sign off now.

MayBee70 Fri 14-May-21 14:54:02

Well, you’ve managed to get your anti mask propaganda an airing without providing any scientific evidence to prove that masks don’t work so you’ve achieved your goal.

Doodledog Fri 14-May-21 14:56:54

donnab31 I agree that there are very troubling aspects about the whole situation. I am particularly unhappy about the way (some) people behaved in the first lockdown, when they were reporting their neighbours for buying 'unnecessary' shopping, and arguing over who should be entitled to get groceries delivered. The laws that have been brought in under the cover of the virus are worrying, as are the ways in which parliamentary process has been disrupted.

These things need to be monitored very carefully, and rescinded as soon as we know (from the evidence) that it is safe to do so.

All the same, I do feel that human lives are more important than the economy (and yes, I understand the links between lockdown, poverty and mental health, and recognise that people with non-Covid illness are being overlooked), and that the priority needs to be to keep people safe.

If that means extending the current pseudo-lockdown for a bit longer, then I think it would be worth it.

EllanVannin Fri 14-May-21 14:59:13

Be prepared, is all I can say. Lockdown or else ?

rosie1959 Fri 14-May-21 15:03:22

No more lockdown we have to learn to live with this virus

Doodledog Fri 14-May-21 15:13:58

rosie1959

No more lockdown we have to learn to live with this virus

The trouble is that we can't learn to live with it, can we?

If by that you mean that we will have to learn to accept that our loved ones will continue to die from it, then I think it's too high a price.

What is wrong with closing the borders, hunkering down until everyone is vaccinated and seeing how the land lies then?

Greeneyedgirl Fri 14-May-21 15:18:40

I have just been listening to Indy Sage Group (live on YouTube every Friday 1.30pm). This is a much more reliable source of information about Covid, and variants, from a group of doctors, epidemiologists, virologists, and public health specialists, amongst others, rather than media sources. I recommend it.

donnab31 Fri 14-May-21 15:19:30

MayBee70

Well, you’ve managed to get your anti mask propaganda an airing without providing any scientific evidence to prove that masks don’t work so you’ve achieved your goal.

I'm not anti-mask as such actually, and I've been very responsible for the last 14 months but I am pro-choice.
And I don't think all this fear-mongering is helping anyones mental health.
None of us have any scientific evidence of anything, apart from the scientists themselves.
If they can show this variant is more dangerous and the numbers start to rise again, then I will start to worry.

EllanVannin Fri 14-May-21 15:22:42

If you've watched the devastation the virus has caused in India and it's this one which will wreak havoc here, as no ordinary virus, then will it get past the vaccinations in this country ? We don't know and it seems neither does anyone else either.

It'll be interesting to find out if those who've recently died of the Indian virus, had the vaccination.

Doodledog Fri 14-May-21 15:31:49

I repeat, though - what about the young people who have not been vaccinated?

Casdon Fri 14-May-21 15:36:10

www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-57094274
According to the BBC news the majority of people testing positive for the Indian variant are younger, unvaccinated people, and there’s no evidence to suggest that the variant doesn’t respond to the vaccination.
We will see what Boris says tonight, but it’s unlikely to vary much from that.

Alegrias1 Fri 14-May-21 15:39:49

The voice of reason Casdon. Thanks for the link.

MaizieD Fri 14-May-21 15:40:40

Those (mainly younger) who don't want the jab are at a much lower risk of serious infection anyway, the risk to young healthy children is virtually non-existent and all the vulnerable and older generations have been offered it already.

Sorry, donnab31, but you're forgetting the possibility of Long Covid, which affects young people and can be devastatingly life altering.

There is also the possibility of vaccine resistant mutations. Yes, the current vaccines have been amazingly good in preventing serious infection and death, but I'm not sure that a responsible government should rely on this and just let the virus run wild...

donnab31 Fri 14-May-21 15:42:04

www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-india-56345591

news.sky.com/story/covid-19-four-people-in-the-uk-have-died-with-new-indian-variant-while-risk-levels-remain-low-data-shows-12306192

Doodledog Fri 14-May-21 15:48:36

Casdon

www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-57094274
According to the BBC news the majority of people testing positive for the Indian variant are younger, unvaccinated people, and there’s no evidence to suggest that the variant doesn’t respond to the vaccination.
We will see what Boris says tonight, but it’s unlikely to vary much from that.

So why not wait until they have all been vaccinated before unlocking?

Am I honestly the only one who thinks that after all their sacrifices for the older generations expecting them to take more risks is beyond inconsiderate? Maybe they won't all die, (although some will, statistically, if the surge continues), but others will suffer from Long Covid, which may affect the rest of their lives.

donnab31 Fri 14-May-21 15:49:19

I'm not in any way saying covid isn't horrible, isn't life threatening or doesn't have a lasting impact on those with long covid. My husband and daughter have had it and a paramedic friend was very ill with it so I know it's very real.
Please don't think I'm playing down the seriousness of the illness, I'm merely saying that the figures - according to the ONS - show that it has levelled off now.
Chris Witty also showed that with his graphs last Monday.
Even with the new variant, it doesn't seem to be having a worse impact than the variants that have been here much longer.

rosie1959 Fri 14-May-21 15:50:15

Doodledog reports from India say that people that had been vaccinated did not fall seriously ill
Our vunerable have had at least one vaccine if not two
Some may be able to afford to hunker down many businesses cannot
I honestly think many especially the young are not prepared to put life on hold any longer

donnab31 Fri 14-May-21 15:52:46

coronavirus.data.gov.uk/

donnab31 Fri 14-May-21 15:53:49

coronavirus.data.gov.uk/details/cases

Callistemon Fri 14-May-21 15:54:09

It wasn't my intention to offend so I'll sign off now.

You didn't offend me but brought up some points which were worthy of discussion, donna.

donnab31 Fri 14-May-21 15:57:39

Callistemon

^It wasn't my intention to offend so I'll sign off now.^

You didn't offend me but brought up some points which were worthy of discussion, donna.

Of course and we're all entitled to have different opinions. smile

Callistemon Fri 14-May-21 15:59:20

Am I honestly the only one who thinks that after all their sacrifices for the older generations expecting them to take more risks is beyond inconsiderate? Maybe they won't all die, (although some will, statistically, if the surge continues), but others will suffer from Long Covid, which may affect the rest of their lives.

No, you're not.

Doodledog Fri 14-May-21 16:00:49

I'm not offended either.

I am a bit taken aback at how many people keep arguing that the reason for not reining back the roadmap is because the vulnerable have been vaccinated, though - it does come across as very selfish. When it comes to Long Covid, there is no way of knowing who is vulnerable and who isn't, and asthmatics are not counted as clinically vulnerable at any age, and I know from experience that it would be terrifying for them to catch Covid.

We are supposed to be going to have everyone over 18 saf(er) by the end of July. Why not wait until then?

Doodledog Fri 14-May-21 16:01:23

Thank you Callistemon. That's a relief.