Gransnet forums

Dieting & exercise

No I really don't need a cycle helmet... or do I?

(102 Posts)
Mrskipling Fri 29-Apr-22 10:06:31

On the one hand, it's a bit health and safety gone mad. I've been cycling for half a century, on and off. Never had a helmet, don't need one now, and a peaked cap keeps the sun out of my eyes better.

On the other hand, I've been chatting to a couple of cyclists my age (60s) recently who are horrified I don't have one and recommend I should get one pronto. And "nobody thought seat belts were necessary until they became compulsory, but who would think of not wearing one now?".

Any thoughts?

Aldom Sat 30-Apr-22 10:21:19

Sixty-five years ago, when the roads were so much quieter and before the advent of cycling helmets, my twenty year old cousin was found on the ground. His unprotected head against the edge of the kerb, his bicycle between his legs. He had sustained a fractured skull and died on the operating table. If he had had the advantage of a cycling helmet he probably would have survived this tumble, no other vehicle involved.

Katek Sat 30-Apr-22 10:25:54

We had to have public liability cover for horses-it should also be compulsory for cyclists

Chestnut Sat 30-Apr-22 12:43:14

I agree Katek that cyclists should be properly licenced with stiff fines and points if they don't have one. Anyone can jump on a bike and whizz along the pavement. I've seen some really dangerous pavement cycling. Then what if they knock over a pedestrian resulting in serious injury? They are not insured. It's a very complex situation because of the ease of using a bike, and those e-scooters also whizz along pavements.

Nightsky2 Sat 30-Apr-22 13:21:25

Chestnut

I agree Katek that cyclists should be properly licenced with stiff fines and points if they don't have one. Anyone can jump on a bike and whizz along the pavement. I've seen some really dangerous pavement cycling. Then what if they knock over a pedestrian resulting in serious injury? They are not insured. It's a very complex situation because of the ease of using a bike, and those e-scooters also whizz along pavements.

Yes, those e- scooters, they’re everywhere. You need eyes in the back of your head when driving.

Luckygirl3 Sat 30-Apr-22 13:31:20

I worked for a head injury service for many years - take it from me, you need to wear a helmet!! Get one right now!!!

nanna8 Sat 30-Apr-22 13:43:42

You have to here, no matter how young. It is a legal requirement. I agree with licences once the cyclist is a certain age because they use the road, they get bike lanes specially assigned to them and the rest of us have to hang back and leave a lot of space whilst we overtake them which causes many traffic delays.

MayBee70 Sat 30-Apr-22 16:47:33

With all the new rulings about giving bicycles a lot of room when passing them (which I’ve always done anyway) it took me ages to get past a line of cyclists which consisted of adults, children and one of those imo dangerous trailers with a baby in. But it horrified me that not one of them was wearing reflective clothing or helmets. Safety works both ways.

Germanshepherdsmum Sat 30-Apr-22 18:20:03

It should be mandatory for cyclists to wear helmets as I believe is the case with motorcyclists. I realise the latter are likely to travel at far higher speeds but as has been demonstrated here it doesn’t take much of a knock for a cyclist to suffer a fatal or catastrophic head injury. It has been mandatory to wear a seat belt for years and we all accept that. What’s the problem with cycle helmets? Vanity? Dignity? Someone who has suffered a life changing brain injury rendering them totally dependent on others for everything has neither.

Aveline Sat 30-Apr-22 18:27:54

I never forgot the face of a young family member, a newly qualified doctor, after his first shift in A&E. A young man had been brought it, fell off his bike, hit his head in a kerb and that was it. Stone dead. Had been happily on his way to meet friends and then just gone! I made such an impression on the young doctor. He always wore a helmet.

Aveline Sat 30-Apr-22 18:28:26

Sorry. Lots of typos! Please excuse.

Luckygirl3 Sat 30-Apr-22 19:14:01

Aveline

I never forgot the face of a young family member, a newly qualified doctor, after his first shift in A&E. A young man had been brought it, fell off his bike, hit his head in a kerb and that was it. Stone dead. Had been happily on his way to meet friends and then just gone! I made such an impression on the young doctor. He always wore a helmet.

Exactly.

We saw head injured cyclists all the time, and I could not help feeling sometimes that it would have been better had they died - sounds cruel, but some of them lost their personalities, their sight, their ability to speak, their mobility, their ability to control their tempers which led to marriages breaking down, their hearing - well, I could go on - anything that is controlled by the brain could go. And often the personality changes were the most difficult to deal with - and things like losing the ability to think through actions, such as getting dressed in order. All things that kept people out of the job market and on benefits and lost to their families and the chances of marriage and children for the rest of their lives.

Sadly, so often these were young people with their lives ahead of them. I cannot stress too strongly how important it is to wear a helmet. On a par with wearing a seatbelt in a car.

M0nica Sat 30-Apr-22 19:26:26

Luckygirl3 When my parents realised the extent of the head injury my sister received in her accident and realised the 'life' that might lie ahead for her if she survived. She said she did something she could never imagine she could ever do - pray for the death of her own child as the best and kindest outcome.

Audi10 Sat 30-Apr-22 19:33:03

I’d say yes you do,

Aveline Sat 30-Apr-22 19:52:46

Oh M0nica how desperately awful. Your poor mum. Poor family.

Yammy Sat 30-Apr-22 19:58:51

Yes do, unfortunately, we live near the Coast to Coast cycle route and I have seen and heard the results of some nasty tumbles.

MissAdventure Sat 30-Apr-22 20:05:53

It's important to realise that devastating injuries can still happen when someone is wearing a helmet, too.
I know of someone left with epilepsy, blind, all kinds of problems, who was wearing one.

Luckygirl3 Sat 30-Apr-22 22:36:24

M0nica

Luckygirl3 When my parents realised the extent of the head injury my sister received in her accident and realised the 'life' that might lie ahead for her if she survived. She said she did something she could never imagine she could ever do - pray for the death of her own child as the best and kindest outcome.

Sorry my post touched such a raw nerve flowers - but I really wanted to get across how very important a helmet is. Cyclists are so vulnerable in these days of busy roads - it is madness to cycle without one.

Luckygirl3 Sat 30-Apr-22 22:38:13

it's a bit health and safety gone mad - words fail me.

PaperMonster Mon 02-May-22 17:21:56

I have a friend who spent nine months in hospital following a cycle accident - he wouldn’t have survived without his helmet.

Pepper59 Mon 02-May-22 17:48:22

MayBee, those baby trailer things give me the heebeejeebies. Roads now are so busy. I'm not a driver, but even as a car or bus passenger, I can't even look at those things with little children inside and cars whizzing past.

M0nica Mon 02-May-22 22:05:26

Luckygirl Nothing to be sorry for. People like OP need to realise what these accidents do to families, and these are the decisions real people find themselves having to think about.

People more generally need to think about it. I saw a young family out cycling this weekend. Both children wearing helmets, father without one. His head is as breakable as the childrens. If anything happens to him, the family will probably be left in poverty. Why do not people THINK?

Chardy Tue 03-May-22 07:46:31

It's protecting the cyclist from the crazy people on the roads, and there are so many more of them now than 50 years ago. Not just cars, but also escooters (which are illegal except in trial areas), lycra-clad cyclists doing 20+mph - I assume that's not you, Mrskipling - pedestrians who walk out onto road/footpath without looking because their phones are so interesting etc.

karmalady Tue 03-May-22 08:03:05

Katek

We had to have public liability cover for horses-it should also be compulsory for cyclists

Too often, children only wear token helmets, perhaps something off a market stall or second hand which went with the second hand childs bike.

Also people do not know how to wear a cycle helmet properly, so it is at its most protective

I will replace mine next year, it has never been bumped and cost a lot but I will make sure to destroy it. The materials can lose structural integrity. This is what knowledgeable people do, they destroy the helmet so no-one else is put into danger. Cycle helmets should be replaced every 3-5 years

PaperMonster Sat 07-May-22 20:20:29

Regarding the insurance, my ex-hubby had a bike accident whilst not wearing a helmet, totally his fault and obviously he came off worse but the car driver was able to claim off our house insurance for the damages.

BlueBalou Sun 08-May-22 07:13:48

I think it’s totally irresponsible to not wear a helmet and I really don’t understand the ‘It won’t happen to me’ mentality.
I have nursed far too many patients of all ages whose lives were irreversibly wrecked by horrendous head injuries from a cycling accident.
So please think about it and have consideration for the people who will be devastated by your refusal to wear a helmet when you have an accident and those who spend their lives caring for you because of your decision.