Gransnet forums

Estrangement

Stunned by daughter’s actions. Advice needed please.

(32 Posts)
notanan2 Fri 20-Dec-19 20:47:58

One clean rejection may be easier and healthier than on-off-on-off-on-off

In this case it might be for the best. Since they have never had a consistantly good relationship, they probably never will at this point. Better the children are not in the middle of it.

Smileless2012 Fri 20-Dec-19 20:14:30

Having just seen the posts from mumofmadboys and Urmstongran please ignore mine; they're right.

This isn't something you should have to do. If this is what your D wants, she should tell her D herself.

flowers.

Smileless2012 Fri 20-Dec-19 20:11:42

Oh dear Grannytomany what an awful position to be in.

If I thought there was a way to keep this from your GD I'd advise you to do that, for the time being at least. As you're going Christmas present shopping with her tomorrow, and she'll be wanting to buy a gift for mother, I don't see how you can.

I agree that estrangement would be better for your GD and GGC in the long run but it may take time for her to see it that way.

I think you need to tell her, easy for me to say I know but I don't honestly know what else you can do.

I'm so sorry.

Urmstongran Fri 20-Dec-19 20:10:27

If in doubt say nowt.
Sorry for your family upset. x

mumofmadboys Fri 20-Dec-19 20:04:17

I would keep quiet. It is up to your DD to tell her own D if she wants to break contact. Try to avoid being a messenger. I am sorry you have these problems right on Christmas but try not to get sucked in. Let them sort it themselves would be my advice.

Grannytomany Fri 20-Dec-19 19:47:38

Also not aldo!

Grannytomany Fri 20-Dec-19 19:47:07

I’ve known for months that my younger daughter was deliberately avoiding her only daughter (and three young grandchildren) and had been running out of excuses to make light of this when granddaughter kept asking me whether I’d heard from her mum or knew why mum wouldn’t answer her calls and hadn’t responded to things like photos of the grandchildren posted on FB. But this afternoon we had a rare visit from our daughter (who always seems angry) - mainly to use our printer - and found out that daughter has turned her back entirely on both our grandaughter and her children. So no Xmas presents for any of them. When I mentioned that granddaughter had a cash present waiting to give to her youngest brother, 13, my daughter retorted that the present wasn’t wanted and was pointless because granddaughter would never see her brother again. I was completely stunned.

My granddaughter has always had a difficult) relationship with her mother, starting from the very young age of 2 or 3, and has spent a lot of her life with us as a result. But she has always wanted a proper mother/daughter relationship and has always hoped that one day that would happen. Neither daughter nor granddaughter are robust mentally and I’m very worried about having to pass this news on to my granddaughter so near to Xmas and Aldo so near to her becoming a single parent after the breakdown of her 10 year partnership with her children’s father.

A large part of me thinks that perhaps estrangement will be better in the long run than an up down, up down relationship with her mother who has certainly not be a consistent positive force in her life but I know my granddaughter will be heartbroken at the news, especially for her three beautiful children who are now rejected by their maternal grandmother. And at Xmas.

What would you do?

I’m due to go with granddaughter tomorrow to help get the rest of her Xmas presents, one of which was to be for her mother.