Gransnet forums

Estrangement

Domestic Violence from kids to parents

(679 Posts)
Lavazza1st Sun 11-Oct-20 15:55:35

I am copying and pasting a post I just found on our local Facebook page for police. This is what the man wrote:

"Why aren't we highlighting mother's of domestic abuse at the hands of their sons?.
These mothers of lads need support after failing to set boundaries early on got irretrievably out of hand as I imagine the mums end up victims of domestic abuse from little back chatting tyrants who hold the mum to ransom, so she gives in for an easy life, and he learns that being abusive gets him rewarded.
You should never reward bad behaviour.
It's like the kid that screams and screams til the parent gives in and gets them a packet of sweets.
I do believe we have parents who've given up after being ground down to nothing over time.
It's a thing that goes on under the radar."

I was really surprised this was written by a man and also really surprised that this is being openly discussed. I think it's a good thing to be open about it and remove the shame factor so people can get help. I hope it helps someone here , that's why I posted it.

EllanVannin Mon 12-Oct-20 17:39:45

Please read it properly MrsWarren ( rolls eyes )

I said-----It's NOT something that CAN'T be solved, even without medication. Meaning that it CAN be solved with medication.

Sheesh----you are hard work.

Smileless2012 Mon 12-Oct-20 17:40:50

confused how is saying It's not something that can't be solved, even without medication writing someone off.

Evan was saying it can be solved, "even without medication".

MrsWarren Mon 12-Oct-20 17:43:53

Indeed we do all make mistakes Starblaze, as you know; but not normally repeating the same mistake on the same subject.

Different mistakes, Chewbacca.

As I said, I didn’t see your “No” amongst the italics last night. It was difficult to see. And double negatives, well, there is a reason they are not used.

Anyway, does it really matter?

EllanVannin Mon 12-Oct-20 17:45:57

MrsWarren has the problem, not I !

Starblaze Mon 12-Oct-20 17:46:02

Oh my goodness, let's not pile on MrsWarren please it's very uncomfortable to read.

We all make mistakes and both of those were easy ones and already addressed

Smileless2012 Mon 12-Oct-20 17:47:33

Seeking clarification for what someone's posted isn't piling on.

MrsWarren Mon 12-Oct-20 17:49:47

EllanVannin

Please read it properly MrsWarren ( rolls eyes )

I said-----It's NOT something that CAN'T be solved, even without medication. Meaning that it CAN be solved with medication.

Sheesh----you are hard work.

I was about to apologise to you for misunderstanding what you said.

But then I seen this.

So, please use correct grammar in future to avoid such confusion.

Starblaze Mon 12-Oct-20 17:50:15

Well if you aren't piling on, let's let it go shall we?

MrsWarren Mon 12-Oct-20 17:59:16

@EllanVannin, you know what, I’m sorry, I shouldn’t have said that to you. That was childish.

MrsWarren Mon 12-Oct-20 18:00:32

Starblaze

Well if you aren't piling on, let's let it go shall we?

Aw, Starblaze, that’s a really decent thing of you to say.

But if anyone else has something to say about it, it’s alright.

I mean, I clearly didn’t see the double negative - I don’t know what clarification/penance is needed?

MrsWarren Mon 12-Oct-20 18:01:41

Starblaze

Well if you aren't piling on, let's let it go shall we?

Starblaze, thank you, that’s really decent of you.

MrsWarren Mon 12-Oct-20 18:01:55

Smileless2012

Seeking clarification for what someone's posted isn't piling on.

I clearly didn’t see the double negative - I’m not sure what clarification/penance is required?

EllanVannin Mon 12-Oct-20 18:02:53

I accept your apology MrsWarren.

Iam64 Mon 12-Oct-20 18:05:45

Is Mr Johnsons address to Parliament and later to the nation getting to people? Let's all sing the song from Frozen and let it go

Smileless2012 Mon 12-Oct-20 18:05:59

I posted about seeking clarification MrsWarren. I didn't mention penance.

Starblaze Mon 12-Oct-20 18:08:58

I too am very passionate about child protection and understanding what creates dysfunctional adults...

The child phase of it all though is very distressing and upsetting and reacting to that does not make a bad person

MrsWarren Mon 12-Oct-20 18:09:51

EllanVannin

I accept your apology MrsWarren.

Thank you. That was mean spirited of me.

Starblaze Mon 12-Oct-20 18:11:07

Iam64 what time is it?

I rarely watch the news these days because life is dark enough but try and see the big addresses

Davidhs Mon 12-Oct-20 18:18:43

There might be some genetic influence but the home environment is by far the biggest factor in child behavior. Surprise, surprise if a child grows up in a violent household he will think that is normal behavior, moreover some will probably have PTSD as a consequence and never have a normal life.

MrsWarren Mon 12-Oct-20 18:20:05

Starblaze

I too am very passionate about child protection and understanding what creates dysfunctional adults...

The child phase of it all though is very distressing and upsetting and reacting to that does not make a bad person

Dr Robert Block says “Adverse childhood experiences are the single greatest unaddressed public health threat facing our nation today.”

Nothing could be more true.

MrsWarren Mon 12-Oct-20 18:20:51

Iam64

Is Mr Johnsons address to Parliament and later to the nation getting to people? Let's all sing the song from Frozen and let it go

Ha! My son loves Frozen and is dressing up as Elsa this Halloween!

HolyHannah Mon 12-Oct-20 18:29:12

www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/targeted-parenting/202010/the-3-letter-words-child-psychologists-love

I think this high-lights what was discussed about calling a child "nasty and naughty" and calling their behavior that...

Starblaze Mon 12-Oct-20 18:31:04

Holyhannah

I love the Power of Yet!

HolyHannah Mon 12-Oct-20 18:44:24

Starblaze -- It certainly shows why shoving a child into a 'box'/labeling them something inherently negative is an adult issue and not the child's. By doing so you are "writing the child off"/suggesting no change is possible and children are by growth changing all the time. If the child is developing in the 'wrong direction' is it ALL their fault or do the adults guiding them have some role/part in their development?

Iam64 Mon 12-Oct-20 20:05:58

I suspect the point about naming the behaviour, rather than labelling the child 'nasty/naughty' has been well made on this thread. I hope the grandmother who told that story doesn't feel unable to post anymore because she feels people have been to coin a phrase 'piling on'. To be shocked as a grandmother, by your much loved 7 year old granddaughter shouting at you to 'f* off" isn't really surprising. Sometimes when surprised, we react badly.
I'm very clear that we should never label the child, we can challenge the behaviour without giving a child the message that they are bad or naughty.
By the same token, surely we can talk with a grandmother about that without dismissing her.