Gransnet forums

Estrangement

Toxic Mother

(346 Posts)
Gampsy Tue 24-Aug-21 22:11:51

Hi All,
This is my first time posting and I would really appreciate your thoughts and comments on my relationship with my Mum. To cut a long story short, my brother and I have spent our lives walking on eggshells with her and she has always tried to play us off against each other. Our children have watched her emotionally abuse us but we have remained loyal and steadfast out of a sense of duty and begrudging love. She is now in her 80’s and since our Dad died she has unleashed her full toxicity on her friends, shop staff and us. She thinks that she can sulk, belittle and abuse us and when we push back she denies everything and says she doesn’t care about anyone and that she wishes she was dead - something she’s been saying for over 30 years when she feels called out on her bs. My brother had Covid and she didn’t even call to see how he was and when I said, imagine something happened to him, she said “well I could die anytime”. I phone her and get her shopping twice a week but apparently her neighbour’s son goes round three times a week!!! She is now not talking to my brother or his wife because she upset them and THEY haven’t apologised to her. I tried today to rationalise with her but she’s adamant she doesn’t care about anyone and I know when i phone her I will get the silent treatment to make me feel guilty. I’m wondering if I should cut ties with her even though I know I will feel guilty but my mental, physical and emotional health have taken a battering for many years and I can’t take much more. If she was an abusive partner I would have walked years ago so why are we allowing her to treat us like this? Please help.

Edith81 Sat 28-Aug-21 22:11:15

There comes a time when one day you have to say”Enough is enough”. Yes, she’s you’re mum, but she’s also a very nasty person, and would you allow anyone else to treat you like this. I have not spoken to my first born son for 11 years now as he became so rude ans nasty and blocked out all our friends and family for absolutely no reason, and we found out that other people who knew him had a very bad opinion of him. It broke my heart when this happened and was very hard to come to terms with, but after some years I accepted it and there is more peace within the family. We felt we always had to walk on eggshells around him. My advice is sever your ties with your mum and find some peace and happiness.

red1 Sat 28-Aug-21 22:48:07

Your mother is unwell clearly. Why is it children from toxic parents often keep going back for more? because they live in hope one they will receive the love they so desired in childhood.Ever noticed that folk with good relationships with their parents don't have the same obligations to their parents?
Its a tough call for sure to walk away ,some folk do, some don't.

Sewmaven Sat 28-Aug-21 22:59:28

You have had enough abuse and now as an adult you can fight back by putting yourself and your family first. Don’t call her and most importantly have no guilt about doing so. You are so worth it and I think we would all feel better for you and applaud you. Put on your big boy pants, you can do this.

Sawsage2 Sat 28-Aug-21 23:26:50

Walk away. You only have one life.

Cossy Sun 29-Aug-21 11:03:18

Let Social Care know she may now support as you are no longer able or willing to assist her, then put as much distance between you as you can !!

jen53 Sun 29-Aug-21 16:28:34

I think Grey Rock sounds a powerful strategy. I haven’t heard of it before either. I haven’t had any experience of this since my own mother died many years ago but Gampsy’s mother certainly sounds extremely self-centered and controlling. Perhaps give Grey Rock a try - you’ll be satisfying daughterly duties but might feel you’re clawing back some control over a difficult situation. I wish you well.

Pinkrinse Sun 29-Aug-21 16:56:07

This really struck home to me. My mother was very similar, not quite as toxic but emotionally manipulated me and my sister, and played us off against each other. I didn't cut contact with her but when she died I realised how free I felt. I wish I'd had the courage to end the relationship years earlier, so I strongly recommend you do. good Luck thou - its very hard.

Allsorts Sun 29-Aug-21 17:48:03

I have looked at all these posts and afraid I rather agree with Pammeil, . Mother gets very old and more annoying, what’s new? Lost her partner and memory not so good, let someone else have the problem. This should have been confronted many many years ago, but obviously wasn’t. In my book you don’t just walk away from responsibilities. Totally think the opposite of Hithere, we are responsible for our elderly parents, however difficult, find a way to sort it. Cowards walk away.
Perhaps one day you will be judged and your children do the same.

Jodieb Sun 29-Aug-21 17:49:09

"Where the mind goes the body follows."

So take care of yourself.

Guilt is a wasted emotion.

Gran16 Sun 29-Aug-21 23:26:09

Allsorts
That's a bit harsh .. in these circumstances it's not cowardly to walk away from a toxic parent that hasn't been a decent parent to you and has harmed your mental health enough. You walk away to prevent them from destroying you completely. I've been in counselling for years trying to deal with the damage my mother did to me in childhood and beyond and I stuck it out until my father passed away to help him through her torment of him too. She showed her true colours and proved she had no interest in me from that point on so did I walk or was I finally pushed, whichever I feel no guilt but I wonder if she does!!!

Eloethan Mon 30-Aug-21 00:10:46

Allsorts In my view, responsibility works both ways but, in the first instance, parents are responsible for the emotional and psychological wellbeing of their children, to stand them in good stead for the future. It appears to me, from the OP's post, that her mother undermined the confidence and general self esteem of her and her brother, which has affected them in later life.

Of course, most, if not all parents make mistakes - and sometimes bad mistakes - in the way they care for their children. I am the first to admit that I made many mistakes with my first child which I believe affected her ability to cope with life as an adult. However, I acknowledged those mistakes and did my best to be a more caring and supportive parent in later life. Conversely, the OP's mother continues to undermine and manipulate her adult children and, from what the OP has said, remains critical and self-centred.

It is easy to be judgmental about other people's feelings and actions but I feel the OP has gone out of her way to manage a very difficult and soul-destroying situation. She does not need any more criticism - it sounds as if she has had a lifetime of that.

VioletSky Mon 30-Aug-21 00:42:00

Allsorts none of us chose to be born. None of us signed up to be responsible for elderly parents one day. Parents make the choice to have children.

Those who care for their parents do so out of love and respect or misplaced duty and guilt.

Which would anyone rather have? If the answer is either, then the parent deserves neither.

Abusive parents do incredible damage to their children. Many do not believe this as they do not believe children capable of great stress and feeling. They view them as less than. They say that they want to raise strong independant adults while demanding meek, quiet, subservient children.

It doesn't matter if an abusive person is 18 or 80. We do not forgive crimes because of the elderly status of those who commit them and emotional abuse is now a criminal offence.

It is only justice that comes when their victims finally decide they will not be one any more.

Oswin Mon 30-Aug-21 03:40:02

Allsorts

I have looked at all these posts and afraid I rather agree with Pammeil, . Mother gets very old and more annoying, what’s new? Lost her partner and memory not so good, let someone else have the problem. This should have been confronted many many years ago, but obviously wasn’t. In my book you don’t just walk away from responsibilities. Totally think the opposite of Hithere, we are responsible for our elderly parents, however difficult, find a way to sort it. Cowards walk away.
Perhaps one day you will be judged and your children do the same.

This is a really horrible thing to say.
The mother had a responsibility to not abuse her children. The op has no responsibility at all to her.

Allsorts Mon 30-Aug-21 06:01:29

I am truly sorry for anyone in an abusive relationship and entirely agree no one should be subjected to it. I know I made the point badly. I think to wait until someone is getting frail, in their eighties and on their own is just a little late to walk away. The original poster was not going to abandon her mother, just start to reduce contact to what she could cope with and agree her mother truly sounds a nightmare, I would not be subjected to that treatment. I did post and entirely support that. I was talking about the many older parents who are never visited when old as they have become a nuisance. Then yes, I do think you have a duty.
I do not condone in any way any abusive relationship, you get out ASAP .

BRAVEBETH Mon 30-Aug-21 06:54:55

My mother is 101. She is in a hospital bed unable to do anything for herself. I have been her carer for 15 years. Yes it has been hard but I have learnt so much about her. Her parents were very strict and she spent most of her childhood terrified. She stated she never knew what she had done wrong. She was told every misdemeanor was in the book of life She left school at 14 and wanted to be a hairdresser She had to work in her father's shop. She married and had children She followed her parents in disciplining her children. It was hard but I coped by being an avid reader.
She is still.terrified of everyone and lived a very sad life.
Human beings cope with the life in whatever manner they can
I am the last relative and I will not give up. Everyone can change.

Sara1954 Mon 30-Aug-21 07:28:51

I think that for those of you who wish to retain a relationship with a difficult parent, no matter what the cost, you must once, or maybe still do love them.
For those of us without that, who don’t like our parent, and have never had a satisfactory relationship, it is asking way too much.

March Mon 30-Aug-21 08:00:24

Grey rock it all the way.
I've used this in the past and it worked a treat.

Best way to win with these people is stop playing the game. Best advice I was given 10+ years ago.

Allsorts Mon 30-Aug-21 08:17:27

Do all the phrases come from America as I have never heard of Grey Rocking someone. Unfortunately there are very toxic children out there and nobody can deny that. I do think toxic people have to justify their actions be it mother, daughter, sister or neighbour.

March Mon 30-Aug-21 08:46:42

I'm not sure where it comes from but it's such a useful tactic.
I'm from the UK.

It's a way of protecting yourself from toxic people, just giving them small snippets of information that they can't 'use' to guilt you, manipulate you or make you feel bad.

You still have a relationship with them up but hold apart of you back. It's a shame that it has to be like that but the guilt trips from walking away can eat you up inside.

I hope I've explained that right.

March Mon 30-Aug-21 08:48:25

'I do think toxic people have to justify their actions be it mother, daughter, sister or neighbour.'

If they could or would do that, they wouldn't be a toxic person grin
It's like trying to communicate with a brick wall.

Witzend Mon 30-Aug-21 09:29:03

The Grey Rock method sounds excellent. I would love to pass this on to a friend of a dd, whose mother certainly strikes me as toxic - constantly belittling her, calling her thick, ruining her relationships by being scathing about every nice bloke she ever had, not to mention being horribly rude to them in person. In the past she’s been vile to my own dds, too.

Now long grown up, the dd can’t seem to keep away, or even cut down contact - it’s as if there are invisible cords, endlessly pulling her back.

And I don’t know why someone always has to suggest that such a person is ‘unwell’. Some people just are unpleasant or downright nasty.

As for Allsorts saying that we have a responsibility to our parents, no matter how unpleasant they may be, I would say it surely comes down to ‘Do as you would be done by.’ Or, as my DM was fond of saying, ‘You reap what you sow.’

But I might add that although I have a very good relationship with dds, there is no way I ever want or expect them to look after me in old age. I have told them as much very firmly, and have also made a point of it in my Health and Welfare Power of Attorney.

Whiff Mon 30-Aug-21 10:46:24

My husband had to use the phrase posters seen to like toxic parents. He didn't like them but always said he loved to them. They treated us and my family appallingly. But my husband never gave up on them. Therefore neither than I. His dad adored our children his mother took against our daughter when she was a baby but was all our son until he became older. His dad died when our children were 4 and 8 months. His mother got worse but still he wouldn't give up on her. When he was dieing he asked me to look after her which I did until she died. I hated my in laws with a vengeance but loved my husband more.

Even when she denied she ever had a son or grandchildren because I promised him I still looked after her. It was me not any of her family who sent 15 hours a day the last 2 days of her life by her hospital bedside . Because they couldn't do anything for her the doctors wanted to move her out of the room she had to herself into a home . I refused and the nurses backed me . I did that for someone I hated.

My son knows how his father's parents treated us and knows how his grandmother treated him and his sister and my family .

It's ironic he is treating me like they did. Luckily had zero contact since August last year. All the lies he wrote in his email and letter are echos of them. Seems he and his wife have turned into my in laws.

And yet I am branded the bad mother, mother in law and grandmother.

Allsorts Mon 30-Aug-21 11:25:07

Must say I can’t agree that if a person were toxic they would not need to justify their actions, if that what you meant March. That’s exactly what narcissists do, making you think you’ve misunderstood them or got the wrong end of the stick, belittling you until you wonder at your sanity. Breaking you down.
Whiff, it was to your credit that you continued to care for awful mil and fil, and understand it, as you couldn’t let your husband down, I don’t think I could if I’m truthful. I think I would have stepped back many years ago. Everyone does what they choose according to their conscience,

Hetty58 Mon 30-Aug-21 11:37:53

My mother was similar (not just in her later years) so I minimised contact. Really, I only made an effort for the sake of my father and siblings.

Emotionally, I detached myself - so really didn't care what she said or did - from quite a young age. My own children hardly saw her except at large family gatherings.

It's possible (and easier) to view the person as damaged and ill, try to be kind - and never take anything to heart. We never really know why people can be so cruel.

In her later years, I often laughed off her comments, so I didn't quite manage to be as kind as I intended.

March Mon 30-Aug-21 11:45:03

I agree they do need to justify their actions but if you have to Grey rock them, that's the last resort.
You would of already tried everything else.