I just think the cruelty of making it so public is beyond belief. No one knows what happened but the desire to inflict as much harm on his mother and her reputation as possible - to try to destroy her career and life - says a great deal about his character. She will already be totally heartbroken. I hope she has good people around her to help her through this.
Gransnet forums
Estrangement
Support and friendship for those whose lives have been affected by estrangement.
(967 Posts)So here we are again, another thread for friends we've already made and for those we are yet to meet.
The last few days have been difficult because for as long as some of us have been contributing to the support threads, offensive posts from these 'new' members still not only disrupt, but can hurt too.
'The truth shall set you free' popped into my head over the weekend because these 'new' members/trolls/previously banned posters are not being truthful to us here on this forum or possibly to themselves either.
In order for the truth to free us we have to be honest because honesty and truthfulness can liberate us from all kinds of emotional baggage like guilt and fear and also the impact of deception on our lives.
Guilt often prevents 'admitting' to estrangement in the first place and many live with the fear of permanent estrangement, that estrangement is inevitable or the fear of what a reconciliation my bring.
The impact that the deception from those who lie about us to others is sometimes unquantifiable as is the impact of lying to themselves.
What we share may not always be pretty, it may not always be easy to share or to read but it does help ourselves, one another and who knows how many who read but never post and that I believe is what really matters.
If it does resonate with any of our EAC Debbie I wonder in what way. Does the telling of lies about the parents they've estranged resonate I wonder
.
Try not to become despondent. There will always be something that brings it all back because it never goes away but each time you get through them, you'll be that little bit stronger
.
Yes Smileless, at least our estrangements weren't made public. How awful. Whatever we might think about his parents, or indeed Brooklyn himself, only we can understand how painful this all is.
Sadly though, for me, listening to it all is not helping me to try to accept and move on in my own situation. It just keeps bringing it all back. I wonder what our estAC are thinking as it must resonate with them too?
Morning everyone.
Another celebrity couple's relationship with an AC bites the dust and we see lies from Brooklyn in a vain attempt to discredit his parents, in particular his mother, to try to justify his behaviour.
All too familiar for so many of us but at least we've been spared the public humiliation.
At this point in time and where we are with the estrangement, we will split what’s left equally between all our children…..but while we’re alive we are giving monetary gifts to our non estranged kids to help with housing etc. We’re happily treating them while we can (hoping to live 7 years more to avoid tax). As our EC has cut off contact we have no details of how to get in touch and have no guilt about this. Not yet at the point where we’d leave them out of the will, but that may change….estrangement takes us all on a journey and none of us can predict how we’ll think or feel at any given stage.
Weren't we all so trusting and full of good intentions! I'm so sorry. We have all learnt a lot since then, unfortunately. I'd never heard of estrangement. Oh well, never mind, l suppose, let's just get on with life and try to put it out of our minds, that's all we can do. I'm just hoping my executors have no bother from them after I'm dead.
It makes me laugh too Hilltop. They're so entitled aren't they and it's so glaringly obvious that it's all about them, what they want and how they behave and yet we've all wasted so much time and effort, dissecting their childhoods and how we parented, wondering what we did wrong.
When we said it would be better for all concerned for the money to be repaid, we received a solicitors letter stating the terms and conditions of the investment, that it was only to be repaid if the house was sold!!!
So be it, but that means that they'll probably never be able to move during our life time because what would have to be paid back, would be a significant sum and could be a substantial percentage of what a deposit on another property would be.
Me too; re the money. I gave them quite a bit before they married and paid for their wedding, don't remember getting a thank you for either.
Morning all
Debbbie It's a good idea of yours, to write a letter to your estD but not send, it gets it out of your mind and down on paper, that you can read back and try to process.
After months of not sleeping & waking at 3am, I too took 'Night Kalms' which really helped me fall asleep & not to wake at 3am. Took for many years but finally managed to stop, I sleep well now, but this is 13yrs on from first being CO.
There seems to be a pattern here. I also helped my estD to buy her first home with her boyfriend. I was a single parent at the time on a low income and I took a big risk to borrow money for them. They've conveniently forgotten I did that for them.
I had to laugh, Smileless, sorry.
We gave them the money very early on in their relationship, they were both recently divorced. I noticed she never mentioned it or said thanks but l didn't bother about it. I had written the cheque out to him, posted it, can't remember if l put both names on the envelope, probably just his.
When estrangement happened years later, l was told that I'd "only given it to him" Didn't she know we knew she would be living in the house too! Was l supposed to have made the cheque out to both of them, l don't think that can be done?
One of the many mistakes l apparently made.
Oh the similarities Hilltop. We along with my brother, invested money into our ES's first property to provide the deposit. We did this through solicitors and it's recorded with Land Registry.
When they got engaged, we all transferred our investment so it could be used as a deposit for the house they wanted to buy together. Solicitors were used again.
When he estranged us he said the only reason we'd invested the money was to control them
. We suggested that as they felt that was the reason it maybe better for all concerned if they paid the money back.
13 years later we're still waiting.
I like what your solicitor told you Smileless, thank you. l shall add that. We had given them money including deposit for their house (which apparently l had not done correctly--so l was told years later when estrangement happened, cheque had been cashed though)
Good evening everyone.
It's been really lovely to read your long posts Whiff especially as you continue to manage the health issues you have.
Dreams can be a comfort Debbie, especially when they're full of the memories we have before everything changed. They remind us not only of the child we used to have and the good times, but also that we were and are good parents.
You never need to apologise for anything you share here with us, this thread is for the good and the bad times Debbie
.
I'm glad you had a good night's sleep Allsorts, it makes such a difference to our physical and mental well being. I do have bad nights from time to time but on the whole, Mr. S. and I are very fortunate to have 7 to 8 hours a night.
Our solicitor told us that all we needed to stipulate in our wills is that our ES was well provided for by us during our lifetime which of course he was, until he estranged us. We haven't even mentioned the fact that we're estranged as not referring to it makes it irrelevant in terms of our wills.
Thank you for the replies, l have done previous Wills and written letters with them. But perhaps my letter needs to set more out and be stronger, l don't know.
The solicitor said that leaving the EC something doesn't make any difference to whether the Will can be contested, and people sometimes think it does.
I like reading your messages Whiff, l hope the appointment you have coming up will help you a lot
You are an amazing lady Whiff, in spite of your disability you have purpose and strength,
Take care of yourself, i hope your coming appointments are helpful to you.💐
Hilltop good memory . I cut my son out of my will in September 2020. Had to get a letter from my GP stating my neurological condition wasn't a mental illness and I was of sound mind .. Cost me £40.
My solicitor wanted me to write a letter explaining why I changed my will and left everything to my daughter. But in the event she died before me her sons would inherit my estate.
My husband and I believed children inherited from parents not grandparents. Left nothing to my 3 other grandsons but I don't even know the name or exact date of birth of their youngest son
My solicitor wanted me to write about our life with the children my husband's cancer , his death what we did as a family afterwards . My life once the children left home ,looking after my parents and mother in law. My health and my life . Like I said I had no life after my husband died I existed. My relationship with my daughter in law who I treated as my own as her parents left the country taking her siblings with them .
My relationship once I moved here and my life and health . My replies to my son's lies and assumptions.
A weekend I never want to relive . I wrote 13 pages of A4 paper . Had a copy of my son's email in hard copy and his letter. My solicitor cried when she read my letter.
It will never see the light of day unless my son contest my will. As anyone can contest anyone's will up to 2 years after they die. Then it will be read out in court plus,his email and letter.
At the same time I took out both powers of attorney my daughter and son in law are my attorneys. But it was cheaper to do it all together.
My will stands and won't change .
When my son was a child and he was naughty then there where consequences. This is the consequences of his estrangement.
He wasn't rewarded for bad behaviour as a child it's no different now and an adult.
It wasn't an easy decision to make but glad I did it .
Going through a solicitor was expense but it makes it water tight . But my son will never know when I die as it will never be posted anywhere. And none of the family would tell him as he cut all our side of the family out of their life .
Once I make a decision I stick to it . It's how my life has always worked . I plan ahead and live by routine. It's how my life has worked since I was at junior school. It's how I worked out how to cope with my disability.
Whiff, what a lovely loyal daughter in law you were in looking after your MIL to the end. My Mum and I had our disputes, as she did with my siblings, but we were all there for her after Dad died and to the end (which was many years of care needed). Despite everything she had said or done to us, we respected her as our Mum and could never have done anything as cruel as estranging her. Though we might have had a couple of weeks of not speaking 😂 This makes it so much harder to understand what I have done to my estD to make her do this to me.
Hilltop. I have written so many versions of a letter. At the moment I have not changed my will and she still gets the same as her sister. But if I don't hear from her in the next year, I may change my will. The letter I am writing explains the hurt she has caused as I think she has no idea of how much pain she has caused. But I have also added nice words about my happy memories of our lives before. The bit I can't decide on is whether to end the letter being kind and keep her in my will and end it on a loving tone, or be more punishing. That seems cruel and I will not steep to her level. I think I will sit on it for a while (and hope nothing happens to me!).
Please, if you have a letter with your Will to explain why you have left your EC very little or nothing in your Will, how much detail have you put as to why you are estranged?
Do l remember Whiff saying she had written a few pages ?
Debbie you are not being negative. You are saying how you feel. It saddens me that you needed anti depressants which glad found didn't suit you . Please be very taking Sleep aid . It could damage your health.
It's a sad fact what our estranged children drive some people to.
You are not to blame your daughter made her choice . I know it's hard to accept but for your mental and physical health you have to let go of hope .
It's easy for our children to throw us away and blame us for everything . I could have done that with my in laws . We had verbal abuse everytime we where with them before we married . But my husband love his parents. If they kicked off after we married we walked out but where back the next Sunday .
After my husband died his mother denied she had a son or 2 grandchildren. She outlived my husband by 11 years . I hated that woman for 40 years but I was brought up with a strong sense of family . So I looked after her visited her every week ,protected her from treatments she didn't want and even spend the last 2 days of her life for 15 hours each day by her bed . Only just got home on the second day when they phoned to say she had died. I was down as het next if kin emergency contact. Her brother showed up once she was dead.
I could have estranged her but she was still my mother in law,nan to our kids and my husband's mom .
I couldn't abandon her anymore than I would have done to my own parents . We all have a moral code we live by .
I know my son must have had that email ready to send last time I saw him . I also know he didn't write it on his own my daughter in law had a hand in it. The spelling was correct , paragraph and punctuation. My son wouldn't have known what punctuation was if it bite him on the arse.
But the letter was him . His hand writing ,spelling mistakes and no punctuation.
As soon as I put my house on the market March 2018 my daughter in law started a hate compaign against me on Reddit. Long story how I found out .
Both children had wanted to live closer to them for years . But couldn't move until I had no one dependant on me anymore. Mom died in 2017.
Our children and some cases grandchildren as well make their choices . They don't suffer but dwell in the fact they know that we will.
I gave up hope after 3 years wish I had done it sooner . I am at the stage that I don't want to see my son . He is a stranger but I am not the mom he knew so a stranger to him . I will always love him but the 32 year old son I knew not the one that will be 39 this year .
He will never know when I die as there in no need for him to know .
Estrangement is hard but acceptable is harder. But with acceptable you can be happy as holding on to something you can't have is futile .
My husband dieing hurts me everyday and my grief for him worse. But because of his love I face each day and live my life to the full.
I will not let my son and daughter in law stop me living my life for me . In a way that is my revenge. I don't hate them . Had enough of that for 40 years . Don't wish them any harm . But hope karma bites them on the butt when my 3 grandson's are older and have partners . Who will see especially what a piece of work my daughter in law is.
I know if the trolls read this then they will attack me . But I don't engage I just report them .
I am sorry to hear of your struggles Whiff, but you sound such a positive lady. Good luck with the GP and the neurologist in March. I hope they find something to help you. And yes, definitely get a cleaner. I’m all for making life easier by paying someone if I can afford it. Why struggle with cleaning when you have other struggles.
Allsorts, It’s interesting that you dream about your children when they were younger and remember it as a happy memory. I am glad that it gives you pleasure and yes, whatever happened to us, our children are still always there. But in my case, sadly, my dreams are nightmares about my estD. Maybe I am still being tormented by it all as estrangement is more recent for me. I hope that I will have nice dreams about her one day, or none at all!
I have been struggling with it all again. First it was Christmas and now because it’s my birthday next week. Stupidly I live in hope that she will turn up with a card and some flowers and an apology. I know I am only kidding myself though.
Last week, I wrote her a letter which I might leave with my will - I wont post it to her.. I have torn up a few versions already! It helps me to get my feelings out by writing them down, but I also wonder if it’s just tormenting me more.
My health is suffering. I took anti depressants which I had a reaction to so have stopped. I have become an insomniac through the anxiety of it all and am now addicted to ‘Sleep Aid’. I can’t sleep without it. And when I do sleep and I wake in the morning, or in the middle of the night, I have a surge of what feels like adrenaline which is like a sinking feeling in my tummy and almost hurts. That sets the tone for the day ahead!
Sorry to be so negative, but I dont really have anyone other than you ladies who really understand what it’s like. So I hope you dont mind me offloading. My mantra is that ‘it’s better out than in’!
Last night I slept well, rare for me but I had a dream, my son and daughter used to get in bed with me every Saturday morning and we would have marmite on toast, change from Monday to Friday when I worked. It was as if it were yesterday. We were laughing about something, usually what my son had said or done.. That was before I met my second husband so a long time ago but it was just us, so they are always there.,
I would hate to think I have forgotten you all but had lot to deal with this year . Still no better but no worse than when I came out if hospital in January last year . But had more information about health issues. Seeing GP end of the month then my neurologist in March . Hopefully my neurologist can help. On list for speech therapy.
But you know me I don't let things stop me . Just so annoyed after 5 years my limbs where under control no jerking . Thankfully it's just my arms effected. After my last fall in the autumn decide to get a cleaner gone with a company that way someone will always come . She starts next week.
Any way I still read and new people are getting the support they need from you wonderful friends.
💞
Mr. S. likes his steak medium rare Yogin and that's bad enough.
Join the conversation
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join the discussion, watch threads and lots more.
Register now »Already registered? Log in with:
Gransnet »
