Gransnet forums

Food

Why doesn’t porridge smell or taste like I remember?….

(31 Posts)
hamster58 Sat 18-May-24 08:38:27

Whenever we go away to a hotel in this country and order porridge for breakfast, it has the smell and taste of when we were children. However no matter what brand I buy-never the instant kind and most recently the real deal Quaker Scots porridge original-it tastes nice but is missing that nostalgic aroma and taste. Does anyone else know what I mean and can anyone suggest one that definitely does smell and taste like it used to please?

pascal30 Sat 18-May-24 08:56:24

I think you have to get porridge oats from an organic wholefood shop,and then cook them for some time.. add milk/ cream and brown sugar at the end..

Germanshepherdsmum Sat 18-May-24 08:57:45

Why don’t you try the instant kind? You might be pleasantly surprised.

Calendargirl Sat 18-May-24 09:02:09

Quaker Oats porridge has a distinctive taste to me. I now buy Tescos Scottish porridge oats as they are cheaper.

I also think that the hotel porridge probably has whole milk, superior oats, cream, ….all stuff that is not so healthy, but delicious as a holiday treat.

Auntieflo Sat 18-May-24 09:11:50

Oh GSM, when in hospital I asked for porridge for breakfast, they brought me the instant kind. It was like wallpaper paste!

Nandalot Sat 18-May-24 09:15:41

Whenever we have porridge in a hotel, it is never as good as the version DH makes. He uses Quaker Oats or Tesco equivalent and semi skimmed milk. The secret, I think, is in the cooking. Six minutes in the microwave but stirred a third and two thirds of the way through. Visitors staying always rave about it.

Clawdy Sat 18-May-24 09:16:39

Flahavens is the best - lovely creamy taste, made in Ireland.

Freya5 Sat 18-May-24 09:16:42

I buy Aldi Organic oats, more nutritious, research shows a higher antioxidant concentration, in organic oats, cheap healthy and delicious. Makes lovely overnight oats too.

Redhead56 Sat 18-May-24 09:17:31

I can’t remember the smell of porridge my mum used to make a massive pan of it. I still make it the same way Scott’s in a pan with water I add sugar while it cooks. I top with a sprinkle of sugar and milk leave it to go luke warm then eat it.

flappergirl Sat 18-May-24 09:17:55

In many cases our tastebuds change or become rather jaded as we get older. A lot of things don't taste as delicious as they used to. I often find that something tastes nicer when I'm on holiday and I don't have to cook it or wash up.

Unless you're staying at the Dorchester or similar I doubt they are using superior, organic oats and Cornish cream. Most hotels buy huge packs of catering porridge, which is basically a sort of Ready Brek.

LucyAnna2 Sat 18-May-24 09:19:29

Try these ones - they’re delicious. And step away from the instant ones!

Primrose53 Sat 18-May-24 09:30:48

We eat porridge every other day. We like the Jumbo oats and sometimes we buy a bag of oatbran and do half and half.

Last week I started eating my porridge which husband made and it didn’t taste right. Next day was the same. I told my husband and it turned out the bag was 2 years old!! they were binned and training has taken place on how to store shopping properly. 😝

DamaskRose Sat 18-May-24 09:42:18

I agree with Hamster so I rarely have porridge at home. Instant porridge! 😬

Germanshepherdsmum Sat 18-May-24 09:47:29

I confess to liking ReadyBrek. That’s my reputation down the drain!

Sarnia Sat 18-May-24 09:48:20

My Mum was a big fan of Robertson's Groats but I am unable to find them and they were lovely. I have Quaker's Jumbo Oats at home to make from scratch. I don't like the sachets of instant porridge.

Chestnut Sat 18-May-24 09:53:03

Nandalot

Whenever we have porridge in a hotel, it is never as good as the version DH makes. He uses Quaker Oats or Tesco equivalent and semi skimmed milk. The secret, I think, is in the cooking. Six minutes in the microwave but stirred a third and two thirds of the way through. Visitors staying always rave about it.

The length of microwave time depends on the ingredients, so can I ask what weight of oats and how much milk?

Jaxjacky Sat 18-May-24 09:54:01

I use Flahavan too Clawdy it’s proper.

NotSpaghetti Sat 18-May-24 10:29:37

You could try some kibbled oats or oatmeal porridge?
I think that is the absolute best but confess to using flakes more often as much quicker.

I've only once been given porridge made of pinhead oats when in a hotel though...

Have you tried stirring a knob of butter in at the end, just before serving? That's what I do (whether made with water, milk or half-and-hslf).

I'm another who only uses organic whole oats.

M0nica Sat 18-May-24 10:44:58

I am afraid, *haamster58, that the problem, may be you!

As we get older our sense of change does fade a bit, that is why older people were once notrious for pouring salt and pepper on all their food. The medications you take, if any can also distort your sense of taste.

Also our memory of how things tasted can, like everything else in life, fade with time. So that the memory we think we have isn't quite what it ought to be.

Think of things you remember from some time ago, a house you lived in 40 years ago, or something like that. When you go back often what you remember isn't quite what was actually there. The bathroom isn't where you remember it, or the bend of the stairs is different.

NotSpaghetti Sat 18-May-24 10:58:37

Germanshepherdsmum

I confess to liking ReadyBrek. That’s my reputation down the drain!

I think you can enjoy ready brek and porridge to be honest!
I like oatibix now and then which my husband referred to as glue-bars. grin

dogsmother Sat 18-May-24 12:04:50

Lucyanna I too am a fan of the Mornflake range. I can’t see the problem with putting some in a bowl and blitzing in the microwave they are almost instant anyway and totally delicious.

seadragon Sat 18-May-24 15:17:50

We use Hamlyns oatmeal. However it started getting lumpy in the pan a few years ago - poor harvest ? I experimented and developed a ritual of measuring 3 cups of boiled water in a pan bringing it back up to a roiling boil. I then stream the oatmeal into the bubbling water gradually using a hand whisk. Then switch off for 5 minutes leaving on the hot ring or plate stirring vigorously before serving - sugar, Greek yoghurt and a little milk for me. I enjoy the ritual too. I find the microwaved versions too slimy preferring the texture of the oatmeal....

grandtanteJE65 Sat 18-May-24 15:29:48

Unless you know exactly how your mother made porridge you won't get it to taste as you remember, whatever you do.

My mother used half milk and half water, a compromise, as she being Danish always made porridge with milk, and my father being Scottish was accustomed to porridge made with water, so they met half-way on culinary matters.

No-one gets me making porridge with water. and I prefer it with far fewer oats than the standard hotel lumpy solid version!

In other words - I don't think anyone can give you a recipe.
Expermiment until you get it right, or ask the hotel chef how he or she makes the porridge you enjoy when on holiday.

Primrose53 Sat 18-May-24 15:38:42

My Mum made lovely porridge. I have a feeling she put some Carnation evaporated milk in too. It was certainly lovely and creamy. Always added a wee pinch of salt too.

Sallywally1 Sat 18-May-24 15:39:59

I have porridge every morning, made with water, but with a little milk added during cooking.i add fresh fruit on the bottom of the dish, fruit on top, yogurt.i have also discovered a calorie free golden syrup from the skinny food company. Strawberries are also often used! It tastes lovely and fills me up for several hours. The syrup tastes as nice as the brown sugar I no longer use.