Gransnet forums

Food

How to peel a hard-boiled egg?

(64 Posts)
eddiecat78 Mon 19-Aug-24 12:15:04

I have a few hens so we eat a lot of very fresh eggs. We enjoy cold hard-boiled ones in salads and sandwiches but I have yet to find a way to peel them successfully. I always put them in cold water after boiling and leave them a while. I usually then crack them all over and remove the shell with the handle of a teaspoon - but invariably a layer of white comes off with the shell.
Any ideas?

Siope Mon 19-Aug-24 12:16:40

Put a teaspoon of bicarb in the water that you boil them in.

JaneJudge Mon 19-Aug-24 12:16:59

Do you feed them grit? They are easier to peel if they have grit or oyster shell supplemented in their diet

Siope Mon 19-Aug-24 12:17:51

Unless you keep your eggs in the fridge. I gather it doesn’t work then.

Theexwife Mon 19-Aug-24 12:18:23

Older eggs are difficult to peel but I would have thought yours are very fresh, I do it the same as you and dont have a problem.

Mollygo Mon 19-Aug-24 12:22:20

I’m trying not to laugh at this timely post.
I’ve just now, done two hard boiled eggs for sandwiches.
Like you, I put them in cold water.
One peeled beautifully, the other was not so successful.
I’d have to buy soda bicarbonate so I guess I’ll just persevere.

MaizieD Mon 19-Aug-24 12:26:13

Theexwife

Older eggs are difficult to peel but I would have thought yours are very fresh, I do it the same as you and dont have a problem.

When we had hens I found that it was the very fresh ones that were hardest to peel. 😁

karmalady Mon 19-Aug-24 12:30:05

fresh eggs are the hardest to peel

I use a pricker device and put the boiled eggs straight into cold water. Never a problem since I bought the egg pricker

Indigo8 Mon 19-Aug-24 12:33:03

I tap them gently until a bit of shell breaks and then gain entry via the crack with my fingers slowly peeling the shell back. (no double entendre intended, sorry if this sounds smutty)blushhmm

This nearly always works. I find that there is a tough, white, opaque membrane just below the shell which I remove with the shell while trying not to dig into the white.

I buy free range eggs from a variety of supermarkets so I do not have any idea of their provenance.

My problem is, that, however long I boil the eggs, the yolk always seems to be slightly runny right in the middle.

midgey Mon 19-Aug-24 12:34:17

The fresher the egg the harder to peel! Use older eggs for hard boiling.

NotSpaghetti Mon 19-Aug-24 12:39:46

I boil mine, removing them one by one to under a slow running cold tap for peeling. I cracked them a bit on the sink then sort-of scrunch them till the shell is like crazy-paving. It comes off easily. The eggs are still quite warm.

I tend to start at the pointy end and run the water into the gap.
I did 6 perfectly just a few mins ago.

A friend puts her egg/eggs in a screw top jar and shajes it. She then has the crazy-pacing egg and does what I do under the cold tap.

Septimia Mon 19-Aug-24 12:46:23

I was told by a Scotch Egg maker (peeling hundreds a day) to work from the broad end. Crack the shell and gently insert the bowl of a teaspoon and work it round. It certainly worked when we were have a Scotch Egg-making lesson!

eddiecat78 Mon 19-Aug-24 12:55:44

Thanks very much ,- lots of methods to try now!
The hens have plenty of grit and the eggs aren't kept in the fridge

Calendargirl Mon 19-Aug-24 13:43:14

My DH faffs about with a teaspoon as that’s how his mother peeled eggs.

I never use one. I put them in cold water as I hate to see that black line around the white. Then I tap and peel.

Some peel perfectly, some not.

I agree it probably depends on how fresh they are.

Oreo Mon 19-Aug-24 16:30:50

Never used the teaspoon idea, I cool them down but peel them slightly warm, just tap to break the shell and they usually peel ok.
If still hot then they don’t peel well.I keep eggs in a pottery chicken in a small larder.

Bea65 Tue 20-Aug-24 11:39:15

Just cut the egg in half and use teaspoon to eat it or scoop out😊

GreyhairedWarrior Tue 20-Aug-24 11:44:35

I find that they peel much more easily if I lower the eggs into boiling water when I’m boiling them rather than starting them in cold water. I think the science of it is that the shock of the heat stops the membrane inside the shell clinging to the white.

Shinamae Tue 20-Aug-24 11:47:33

GreyhairedWarrior

I find that they peel much more easily if I lower the eggs into boiling water when I’m boiling them rather than starting them in cold water. I think the science of it is that the shock of the heat stops the membrane inside the shell clinging to the white.

Yes that’s how I do mine boil them for 10 minutes then put them in cold water add a few ice cubes. Leave for a few minutes Crack them on the side then roll them as well that loosens shell and I find them easy to peel…

mabon1 Tue 20-Aug-24 11:56:47

Message deleted by Gransnet. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Shinamae Tue 20-Aug-24 11:58:24

Withdrawn. Quotes a deleted post.

GrauntyHelen Tue 20-Aug-24 12:19:53

Ditch the teaspoon

MissInterpreted Tue 20-Aug-24 12:21:16

Message deleted by Gransnet. Quotes a deleted post.

Nagmad2016 Tue 20-Aug-24 12:39:30

I usually boil them, drain them and put them back into the pan in cold water. I then fetch them out, crack them against the sink and return them to the cold water for a minute or so. They are usually easier to peel once the cold water has gone between the shell and the white. Works for me.

icanhandthemback Tue 20-Aug-24 12:43:53

MaizieD

Theexwife

Older eggs are difficult to peel but I would have thought yours are very fresh, I do it the same as you and dont have a problem.

When we had hens I found that it was the very fresh ones that were hardest to peel. 😁

I agree!

Cossy Tue 20-Aug-24 12:49:47

Message deleted by Gransnet. Quotes a deleted post.