Gransnet forums

Food

Keeping butter in a butter dish

(69 Posts)
Daddima Mon 03-Mar-25 17:20:37

Now, I have discovered that ‘spreadable’ butter isn’t.
Do any of you keep ‘proper’ butter in a butter dish, and for how long?

Septimia Mon 03-Mar-25 17:24:17

Yes, although not for a while. How long? Until it's used up!!

If you think you won't use it very quickly and it might go off, why not cut it into halves or thirds and keep the part you're not using in the fridge until you need it?

JackyB Mon 03-Mar-25 17:24:31

I keep a quarter of a pound at a time in a butter dish by the bread bin. It lasts a few days out of the fridge and if there's just a bit left, I use it up for.cooking or greasing a cake tin.

Allira Mon 03-Mar-25 17:25:17

Yes, always.
In the summer it might go in the fridge during a particularly hot spell but otherwise it's out on the work surface.

and for how long?
Well, it gets used up fairly rapidly.

J52 Mon 03-Mar-25 17:27:33

We use a stoneware covered dish. Once out of the fridge in the morning it keeps the butter cool all day.
For putting butter on the table I use a small stone ware open dish with a small amount for that meal.

Indigo8 Mon 03-Mar-25 17:28:11

Yes. Until it is used up then I wash the covered dish and put another one in. It seems to keep OK because of the high fat content. I only refrigerate it in very hot weather.

Farmor15 Mon 03-Mar-25 17:38:52

Same as others- 2 butter lidded dishes alternated. Don't put in fridge. Never a problem going off - usually too hard in winter but about 5 seconds in microwave can help.

BlueBelle Mon 03-Mar-25 17:41:29

No I don’t keep it in the fridge it lasts for ages out but then I don’t have any heating in the kitchen guess it wouldn’t last more than a week in the summer

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Mon 03-Mar-25 17:41:50

Always have and do. I like block butter.
Not a fan of spreadable.
I especially like it with rock salt crystals. Delish.

Chocolatelovinggran Mon 03-Mar-25 17:52:24

Absolutely FGT.

Pantglas2 Mon 03-Mar-25 18:06:31

FriedGreenTomatoes2

Always have and do. I like block butter.
Not a fan of spreadable.
I especially like it with rock salt crystals. Delish.

Oh yes! Welsh or Cornish butter with sea salt from Lidl £2.25 cut in half and placed in butter dish which lives in large bread bin!

I use cheaper butter for cooking but the above always on toast, crumpet, toasted banana bread, bara brith 😋

The half block lasts about a week/10 days and I stick it in the freezer if we’re off on ‘olidays!

Babs03 Mon 03-Mar-25 18:09:52

Slightly salted Lidl butter in a block, keep a third in a butter dish and the rest in the fridge.

Babs03 Mon 03-Mar-25 18:11:20

Our butter dish is a heavy glass one that we got as a wedding present, not sure how it has lasted this long.

Oldbat1 Mon 03-Mar-25 18:14:44

Im sure I read “somewhere” salted butter is ok to keep out of fridge moreso than unsalted. I cut the butter packet in half.

CanadianGran Mon 03-Mar-25 18:18:24

I have a small container with lid that nicely holds about 1/4 lb of butter, that remains on the counter.

kittylester Mon 03-Mar-25 18:21:25

We like butter. We use Waitrose French salted. We have 2 glass butter dishes which are alternated. It is never uneaten for long enough to go off.

Spinnaker Mon 03-Mar-25 18:27:23

Have just discovered making home made butter from scratch - absolutely scrummy ! Keep in a butter dish and doesn't stay in long enough to go off - loving it grin

valdali Mon 03-Mar-25 18:45:39

I keep butter in the fridge in a block. Wrapped on a shelf. We do use spreads for sandwiches / bread with soup, but tbh we use more butter for baking, on veg, in sauces, than we use spreads on bread.

Astitchintime Mon 03-Mar-25 18:53:35

Septimia

Yes, although not for a while. How long? Until it's used up!!

If you think you won't use it very quickly and it might go off, why not cut it into halves or thirds and keep the part you're not using in the fridge until you need it?

I do just this......particularly in warmer weather.

crazyH Mon 03-Mar-25 18:58:20

In a butter dish on the worktop. The lid has broken, so I will have to get a new one, methinks.

Davida1968 Mon 03-Mar-25 19:03:14

Yes, always. It's a stainless steel one from Lakeland. We also have a lovely china one, complete with matching butter knife. We get this out for visitors.

Calendargirl Mon 03-Mar-25 19:08:42

Ours is in my late mum’s Tupperware butter dish. (No doubt very bad for us as it’s probably the wrong sort of plastic or something nowadays)

🤔

M0nica Mon 03-Mar-25 19:13:46

Indigo8

Yes. Until it is used up then I wash the covered dish and put another one in. It seems to keep OK because of the high fat content. I only refrigerate it in very hot weather.

Likewise.

Butter is a product first produced many thousands of years ago as a way of preserving milk for months and months. If it smells OK and a bit on the tongue tastes OK, then it is fine.

Mine stands on the side for weeks without problem.

Baggs Mon 03-Mar-25 19:17:41

Yes. All the time. Till it's used up. With thick crockery butter dishes it stays cool enough in our kitchen to still need me to zap small pieces of it for immediate spreading during winter.

Visgir1 Mon 03-Mar-25 19:21:42

I do but only when I have a house full. Otherwise, it wouldn't get used with just the two of us, especially as I don't eat bread etc.
It's cute with a Highland Cow on it.